J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

parkeysainter · Sat 23 Jun 2018 7:49pm

ANALYSIS: Star Giant set for Tribunal date - http://m.afl.com.au/news/2018-06-23/ana ... urweek-ban

Plugger would have got 10 for this. Still remember when he cleaned up Caven. That was a scary hit back in the day.

asiu · Post: # 1737976Post **asiu** » Sat 23 Jun 2018 8:59pm

have to get 6 for that wouldnt he ?

big brainfade
... very lucky the young fella doesnt have a smashed jaw
or it'd be 8

skeptic · Post: # 1737979Post **skeptic** » Sat 23 Jun 2018 9:07pm

That was brutal...

Imagine if it was Stevie Baker...

Surely that’s t least 8 weeks if not 10

parkeysainter · Sat 23 Jun 2018 9:34pm

He should miss the rest of the year nearly.

bigred · Post: # 1737984Post **bigred** » Sat 23 Jun 2018 9:46pm

yeah a really s*** effort that one.

Looks like he just wanted to smash the bloke.

silverhalo · Sat 23 Jun 2018 10:46pm

bigred wrote: ↑Sat 23 Jun 2018 9:46pm yeah a really s*** effort that one.

Looks like he just wanted to smash the bloke.

yep, pretty p@#$weak act to do that .......eyes only for the man - lots of priors for Cameron, throw the book at him.

mr six o'clock · Sat 23 Jun 2018 10:54pm

parkeysainter wrote: ↑Sat 23 Jun 2018 9:34pm He should miss the rest of the year nearly.

Yep
But what bullshite rules will the AFL use .
I think in a small way they are to blame .
Buddy elbowed someone , no penalty
Then even worse
Fyfe elbows yeo , gets a fine
Should have got at least 2 weeks
Now this
Should get 6 weeks minimum
But its one of the best giants so who knows.
Can't help but think that if they had penalised buddy heavily it may have sent the message to players to keep the arms down
But we all know they have two sets of rules , one for their favorites and one for the rest.

Yorkeys · Post: # 1737990Post **Yorkeys** » Sat 23 Jun 2018 11:14pm

Need a yellow card system. Cameron played on and kicked goals, no justice for Brissy.

Jacks Back · Sat 23 Jun 2018 11:55pm

Brisbane one man down and Cameron plays out the game. Maybe they need an instant MRP type set up for the big hits like this. Tick the relevant boxes and if the offender gets weeks for the indiscretion then it starts straight away and the player has to go off (evening the players available on the day).

If the downed player is able to return then the offender can return for that match only.

chico2001 · Post: # 1738033Post **chico2001** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 1:39pm

Might get 6 weeks for that one. Probably depends on the injury report.

saynta · Post: # 1738036Post **saynta** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 1:47pm

Will get weeks for sure.

saintbob · Post: # 1738045Post **saintbob** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 2:48pm

Must get 6-8wks

skeptic · Post: # 1738053Post **skeptic** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 5:23pm

Jacks Back wrote: ↑Sat 23 Jun 2018 11:55pm Brisbane one man down and Cameron plays out the game. Maybe they need an instant MRP type set up for the big hits like this. Tick the relevant boxes and if the offender gets weeks for the indiscretion then it starts straight away and the player has to go off (evening the players available on the day).

If the downed player is able to return then the offender can return for that match only.

It's interesting isn't it...

I know at a lot of local levels they have the send off rule for a quarter or a match depending on the severity

This would have been the exact type of scenario where the player could get sent off for the match and his team play a man down too (pbly allow someone to swap on as otherwise it would be too severe a penalty)

asiu · Post: # 1738062Post **asiu** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 7:09pm

admitted to hossy

http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-2 ... al/9904274

Sainter_Dad · Sun 24 Jun 2018 7:45pm

J. Cameron - 4 weeks - lock it in!

dragit · Post: # 1738068Post **dragit** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 8:17pm

Bit of a beat up IMO… another one of those incidents where the player leaves the ground before the ball arrives to make a realistic contest, but has no opportunity to pull out.

Andrews was brave but put himself in a pretty dangerous position. I have no doubt Cameron was genuinely trying to compete rather than inflict injury, maybe poor judgement to compete in hindsight. He actually looks like he tries to not collect the head to me.

I can see footy will become essentially non contact down the track, as collision will always cause head injuries at this pace.

degruch · Post: # 1738078Post **degruch** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 9:56pm

dragit wrote: ↑Sun 24 Jun 2018 8:17pmHe actually looks like he tries to not collect the head to me.

By softening the blow with his elbow? He ironed out a Brissy player in the pre-season too, obviously doesn't like being challenged much.

stjohnc · Post: # 1738083Post **stjohnc** » Sun 24 Jun 2018 10:17pm

2 weeks, same result as Carlisle

parkeysainter · Mon 25 Jun 2018 9:10am

stjohnc wrote: ↑Sun 24 Jun 2018 10:17pm 2 weeks, same result as Carlisle

I will spew up if he got 2.

Yorkeys · Post: # 1738099Post **Yorkeys** » Mon 25 Jun 2018 9:35am

Mitigating factors - AFL need GWS to play finals; Cameron is the team's best forward. There will have to be a strong penalty but I would be surprised if t is not watered down. Watching the nudge nudge on the footy shows it is easy to get the impression that incidents are not judged on their merits, expediency is heavily weighted. Remember Matty McGuire's solar plexus punch. I found the "fight night' promotion of Barry Hall such poor taste. Quite a few of the storied football mothers will have crossed AFL off the sports to play list for their kids. Oh, and Cameron apologised after the game.

asiu · Post: # 1738123Post **asiu** » Mon 25 Jun 2018 2:36pm

bleeding on the brain
2 weeks minimum before he returns

SaintPav · Post: # 1738134Post **SaintPav** » Mon 25 Jun 2018 4:57pm

10 weeks.

Dog act.

Animal.

bigred · Post: # 1738137Post **bigred** » Mon 25 Jun 2018 6:26pm

cocked that elbow pretty early.

parkeysainter · Mon 25 Jun 2018 8:48pm

Bears player is in hospital. Has internal bleeding in the head I think. Poor fella.

sendmehomehappy · Mon 25 Jun 2018 11:10pm

Bleed on/in the brain...he will be out for a lot longer than 2 weeks.

Cameron should be stood out for the season.

It was a king-hit.

Priors ++

Animal act!

Needs a real lesson.

AFL cannot minimise this and simultaneously retain any shred of credibility.

J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player

Re: J. Cameron hit on Brisbane player