Positives for tonight.

[The Fireman]

It's ok, I was only joking.

[desertsaint]

the longer vs hickey debate is over?

[Yorkeys]

Correct

[CURLY]

Hickey and Joey are both gone is one positive.

[Joe Bloggs]

MC Kenzie....just can't see what he brings.

[Proph3t of egan]

Carlisle is a great player, and Savage has found his place back in the team

[cwrcyn]

I think we can put Mckenzie to onesie for a while. Battle played just as I expected. A very stupid selection. Long isnot ready. Our midfield isvery shallow

[fugazi]

Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well.
The boys got worked over and will learn from it.
Also we need speed...lets try Freezer.

[Proph3t of egan]

Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well.
The boys got worked over and will learn from it.
Also we need speed...lets try Freezer.

Really wish Richo got a bit creative to bring more speed. Put Long on Fantasia or AMT instead of Geary, let the skip roam a bit.and set up our defense

[GRAMophone]

Mr reliable ..Jack Sinclair

[SaintPav]

Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well.
The boys got worked over and will learn from it.
Also we need speed...lets try Freezer.

Really wish Richo got a bit creative to bring more speed. Put Long on Fantasia or AMT instead of Geary, let the skip roam a bit.and set up our defense

Geary locks down just about everyone he plays on but these sound like great moves, in hindsight

Wow!

[mr six o'clock]

47k crowd

[Proph3t of egan]

Carlisle , Savage, Roberton and Steven all played well.
The boys got worked over and will learn from it.
Also we need speed...lets try Freezer.

Really wish Richo got a bit creative to bring more speed. Put Long on Fantasia or AMT instead of Geary, let the skip roam a bit.and set up our defense

Geary locks down just about everyone he plays on but these sound like great moves, in hindsight

Wow!

I know right! Maybe I should be coach St Kilda. I like how we can leave Geary to cover 2 different players and beats them both!

I just thought Geary was a bit wasted with those mismatches especially with their speed as my concern. Plus long could learn a thing or two

[borderbarry]

Positive..... Battle has been blooded. Did not get much of it, kicked a nice goal when more experienced players could'nt
Should get another one.
Nathan Brown. how long do we persevere with him?

[Proph3t of egan]

Positive..... Battle has been blooded. Did not get much of it, kicked a nice goal when more experienced players could'nt
Should get another one.
Nathan Brown. how long do we persevere with him?

What do you by perservere? Like keep playing through a slump, or delist him soon?

He's been very solid all year considering last year, Hooker would had a feild day against us

[Scollop]

Coach and match committee will finally realise they MUST get more games into our younger players. We are no where near good enough or consistent enough to challenge, even if we fall into 8th spot (personally, I don't think we'll make the 8 and have thought that we wouldn't prior to the season starting)

[SaintPav]

Positive..... Battle has been blooded. Did not get much of it, kicked a nice goal when more experienced players could'nt
Should get another one.
Nathan Brown. how long do we persevere with him?

Harsh assessment on Brown.

He has been excellent all year.

Pretty hard to defend given the way the ball was coming in.

[saintbob]

Sinclair, Carlisle, Roberton, Savage, Steven and the Bombers bad kicking for goal were all positives for tonight.

Coaches, McKenzie, Lonie, Long and Hickey were f****** dreadful.

[longtimesaint]

Positive..... Battle has been blooded. Did not get much of it, kicked a nice goal when more experienced players could'nt
Should get another one.
Nathan Brown. how long do we persevere with him?

Harsh assessment on Brown.

He has been excellent all year.

Pretty hard to defend given the way the ball was coming in.

Defenders are under the pump when the midfield is being thrashed.
I think the defenders did pretty well considering that.

[older saint]

Carlisle, roberton, steven, savage. I thought Lonnie and Sinclair battled hard .

[elizabethr]

Steven the turnover King
Surely you Jest

[Scollop]

Positive..... Battle has been blooded. Did not get much of it, kicked a nice goal when more experienced players could'nt
Should get another one.
Nathan Brown. how long do we persevere with him?

Harsh assessment on Brown.

He has been excellent all year.

Pretty hard to defend given the way the ball was coming in.

Defenders are under the pump when the midfield is being thrashed.
I think the defenders did pretty well considering that.

Some of our defenders were excellent. Nathan Brown was inconspicuously non influentual, as per his average output.

Have another close look at Nathan's efforts when he had an opportunity to impact a contest or provide an attacking option. He was hopeless

[SydneySainter]

Got a reality check? Hopefully lessons to be learned?

Only been about our third this year...

[saint-stu]

I'm not seeing it in Long or McKenzie. You want to see some glimpses every now and then but I just don't. They also don't stand out much at VFL level from the games I've seen. Really strange decision to bring them in.

Rice and Freezer would appear to be much more deserving.

[SaintPav]

Agree.

Perplexing