McCartin - The biggest recruiting disaster of all time

[citywest]

Massive mistake by our recruiters. He is destined to be the worst Number 1 draft pick of all time.

<warning issued under the troll policy as a first strike and just a warning and the next post that is deemed to be solely designed to inflame the community will result in a one month ban>

[citywest]

He is not an elite runner.
He does not take contested marks.
He is not a lead up forward.
Derm is right, he has no tricks at all.

[matrix]

You


Are a complete trolling peanut
And a bit of a knob it seems as well

[manoffewwords]

Why is this knob still allowed to post here?

[citywest]

You


Are a complete trolling peanut
And a bit of a knob it seems as well

I am being brutally honest which will probably get me banned. Can you please tell me what tricks McCartin possesses? And what elite qualities you envisage he will have when he reaches 100 games?

[LTN16]

Massive mistake by our recruiters. He is destined to be the worst Number 1 draft pick of all time.

Ahhhh <edited>.. He is definitely a saints fan hey mods..

[matrix]

How many afl standard pre seasons?
How many games?
How old?.....


Troll

[Locals322]

Yeah at least you know Jack Watts is a good kick with an OK contested mark. Where is the space that McCartin will even move into, he may need to go into the ruck or something but jeez, if you can't clunk a few at his height there isn't much hope for you.

WORST OF ALL tonight he is getting in Nick's way literally making the forward line more dysfunctional

[matrix]

Time to eat trolls!!!!!!

[LTN16]

Locals322 and chitypest are the same person..

[matrix]

Really????!!!



Oh...my....god!!!!!!!!

[citywest]

Locals322 and chitypest are the same person..

False, outright lie.

[LTN16]

Really????!!!



Oh...my....god!!!!!!!!

Just pointing out the obvious for the less intelligent ones like yourself

[matrix]

I know
Im in that mood

s*** loss and <edited> wants to be a <edited>

[saintkid]

He is entitled to his opinion without resorting to personal abuse. Watts showed much more agility, made more contests at the same stage and was still bagged often by Melb supporters for his one dimensional play. McCartin was way off it tonight with his ability to contest and as for his pace, he looked very, very slow.

[felix]

Well I think we can all acknowledge he had a shocker .

[Con Gorozidis]

Marcus Adams could be the best pick 35 of all time.

[Locals322]

If Carlisle was playing...who has kicked as many as 8 for Essendon he'd be a fair bit more useful down there than Paddy

[Con Gorozidis]

There was one piece of play where he didnt even compete and let Caleb Daniel shepherd him off. Was insipid at times.

[Myron Gaines]

He had an ordinary game. Seriously lacks intensity.

[Griggsy]

Oh gtfo, yes paddy played poor but about 90% of the full forwards in the comp would have in that game with the trash our defense and mids offered up moving forward, if they even got it over half way.

[Toy Saint]

So I guess we should have recurited Petracca...or...who should we have taken?

[Con Gorozidis]

Andrew Lovett and Jake Carlsile are hard to beat as recruiting disasters. Neither has played a single game so far.

[fugazi]

So I guess we should have recurited Petracca...or...who should we have taken?

Brayshaw will be a champ, Petracca if he gets himself organized could be anything.

We will have to be patient with Paddy, but didn't do much tonight.

[Griggsy]

And I'm still picking him over million dollar man on the other team with an extra season