Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

Tough one this week


In fisher billings sinclair


Out Delaney minchington ray

[Old Mate]

Fisher won't play
In
Billings Sinclair Mckenzie
Out
Minch robbo Ray

[#gosaintas]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

[Beno88]

In : Sinclair, Billings

Out : Minchington, Savage

[mohannair]

I thought we all smashed Gilbert last week but no one has ruled him out yet.

[#gosaintas]

I thought we all smashed Gilbert last week but no one has ruled him out yet.

He needs to play no further back than wing otherwise his consistent turnovers just cause immediate goals to the opposition. If this doesn't work, drop him.

[spert]

Wouldn't mind seeing a bit of young talent get a run, rest a couple of older blokes.. and Essendon are not really in top form.
IN: Paddy, DMac, Hickey, Sinclair(if elevated?)
Out: Gilbert, Ray, Roo, Minch

[karnaby]

IN: Billings
OUT: Minchington

[Saint wagga]

IN: Fisher, Billings, Templeton
Out: Delaney, Minch, Ray

[4ever_saint]

Ins: Sinclair, Billings
Outs: Minchington, Ray

[coopergrech]

DELANEY done well last week. ....

In - Fisher and Billings
Out- Gilbert and Minchington

[plugger66]

Wouldn't mind seeing a bit of young talent get a run, rest a couple of older blokes.. and Essendon are not really in top form.
IN: Paddy, DMac, Hickey, Sinclair(if elevated?)
Out: Gilbert, Ray, Roo, Minch

Is Roo Dropped or injured? Surely neither. This is the week not to experiment. Do that when we cant win. Well that's how I think the club will feel.

[saintspremiers]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

Schneider out is trolling

[#gosaintas]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

Schneider out is trolling

Are you kidding? Did you watch last week? Once again he choked in front of goal, missed targets and lettuce leafed his tackles. What's the story wit the love for this spud? Is it just the Scneiderman thing and the vibe?

[plugger66]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

Schneider out is trolling

Are you kidding? Did you watch last week? Once again he choked in front of goal, missed targets and lettuce leafed his tackles. What's the story wit the love for this spud? Is it just the Scneiderman thing and the vibe?

Maybe your bias against him or do you think the selectors just pick the side based on the Schneiderman video or the vibe? Remember we don't pick the side, the selectors do so it matters little why we think he should be in the side.

[Bunk_Moreland]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

Schneider out is trolling

Agreed, only a troll would have that.

Well spotted.

[#gosaintas]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

Schneider out is trolling

Are you kidding? Did you watch last week? Once again he choked in front of goal, missed targets and lettuce leafed his tackles. What's the story wit the love for this spud? Is it just the Scneiderman thing and the vibe?

Maybe your bias against him or do you think the selectors just pick the side based on the Schneiderman video or the vibe? Remember we don't pick the side, the selectors do so it matters little why we think he should be in the side.

Did you watch last week? Once again he choked in front of goal, missed targets and lettuce leafed his tackles.

[plugger66]

IN : Goddard, Sinclair, Billings
Out : Minch, Schneider, Ray

Schneider out is trolling

Are you kidding? Did you watch last week? Once again he choked in front of goal, missed targets and lettuce leafed his tackles. What's the story wit the love for this spud? Is it just the Scneiderman thing and the vibe?

Maybe your bias against him or do you think the selectors just pick the side based on the Schneiderman video or the vibe? Remember we don't pick the side, the selectors do so it matters little why we think he should be in the side.

Did you watch last week? Once again he choked in front of goal, missed targets and lettuce leafed his tackles.

Yes I watched the side. I don't go to the game and only watch one player and only look for his bad points. And why does it matter what I see. Again us on here don't pick the side so it seems the selectors totally disagree with you. By the way I think your bias is really effecting your judgement. He had 7 tackles last week and they don't count lettuce leaf tackles unless champion data lie.

[spert]

Wouldn't mind seeing a bit of young talent get a run, rest a couple of older blokes.. and Essendon are not really in top form.
IN: Paddy, DMac, Hickey, Sinclair(if elevated?)
Out: Gilbert, Ray, Roo, Minch

Is Roo Dropped or injured? Surely neither. This is the week not to experiment. Do that when we cant win. Well that's how I think the club will feel.

Nah, just thought Roo could be rested and we could give Paddy a run in the forward line now he has had the chance to get up to pace a bit more..it would be massive for the club to beat Essendon with less than our full-strength team.

[plugger66]

Wouldn't mind seeing a bit of young talent get a run, rest a couple of older blokes.. and Essendon are not really in top form.
IN: Paddy, DMac, Hickey, Sinclair(if elevated?)
Out: Gilbert, Ray, Roo, Minch

Is Roo Dropped or injured? Surely neither. This is the week not to experiment. Do that when we cant win. Well that's how I think the club will feel.

Nah, just thought Roo could be rested and we could give Paddy a run in the forward line now he has had the chance to get up to pace a bit more..it would be massive for the club to beat Essendon with less than our full-strength team.

I thought he rested a week ago? And why would the club try to beat Essendon with a less than full strength side? Surely we aren't that good or arrogant to try that.

[MCG-Unit]

In: Billings, Sinclair

Out: Minchington, xxxx

[The Disch]

Hard to see us resting players and still winning in a canter. Love to see it though.
On another note atleast we should be guaranteed a few free kicks in our forward line, with whoever plays on Jimmy G.
Love to see him line up on Bruce.

[saynta]

In : Sinclair, Billings

Out : Minchington, Savage

You could be closest to the pin.

[saintsRrising]

In: Billings, Sinclair

Out: Minchington, xxxx

Yes I am not sure who the second out will be as well. Whoever it is will be stiff. But I want to see that extra class, ball handling skill and mobility in against the Dons.

[MCG-Unit]

In: Billings, Sinclair

Out: Minchington, xxxx

Yes I am not sure who the second out will be as well. Whoever it is will be stiff. But I want to see that extra class, ball handling skill and mobility in against the Dons.

Yep really tough one the second out - don't envy the coaching panel - won't even know for sure tonight, as they name squads for Sunday matches