Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

Ins
Rooy, Geary, Delaney, Lonie

Outs
Longer, Shenton. Templeton, Fisher

[desertsaint]

Ins
Rooy, Geary, Delaney, Lonie

Outs
Longer, Shenton. Templeton, Fisher

if those four are back in we're half a chance.

[bergholt]

IN: Geary, Lonie, Riewoldt
OUT: Membrey, Fisher, Templeton

[Beno88]

In : Riewoldt, Geary, Delaney, Lonie

Out : Membrey, Shenton, Fisher, Templeton

[maverick]

In : Riewoldt, Geary, Delaney, Lonie

Out : Membrey, Shenton, Fisher, Templeton

Agreed
Not the week to drop a ruck they are short down back
Lonie sub

[Kernal75]

In : Roo, Goddard, Lonie, Geary,
Out : Hickey, Fisher, Shenton.

Delaney gets another week to recover from his hip

[CURLY]

Wasnt Templeton tagging Hurn last week?

[merimbula]

Already a thread on this topic titled "changes for this week"

Don't think we need another but I could be wrong.

[merimbula]

Already a thread on this topic titled "changes for this week"

Don't think we need another but I could be wrong.

[Sobraz]

Already a thread on this topic titled "changes for this week"

Don't think we need another but I could be wrong.

You're right, you are wrong.

This thread is a weekly tradition.
Although P66 did stipulate earlier in the season that the thread should also include changes we'd want v changes we think, nonetheless, an essential thread.

Out: longer, fish, Templeton
In: Roo, Lee, Geary

[gringo]

Out Fisher, Templeton, Members
In Rooey, Lee or Delaney, Geary

[RW&B]

In : Roo, Goddard, Lonie, Geary,
Out : Hickey, Fisher, Shenton.

Delaney gets another week to recover from his hip

After losing players early the last two weeks I agree that it's only fair that we get an extra rotation this week. Gillion is a huge fan of equalisation after all.

[stevie]

Just heard that Lions fwd McStay is out. He's a promising young player.

[MCG-Unit]

Already a thread on this topic titled "changes for this week"

Don't think we need another but I could be wrong.

How many other duplicate threads are there?

On topic

In: Riewoldt, the only one I'm confident on. Delaney, Geary and Lonie subject to fitness tests. xxxx

Out: Fisher (inj) and maybe Webster (concussion) Not sure on the other outs - but not the usual calls for Schneider or Dunstan

[Jacks Back]

Ins
Rooy, Geary, Delaney, Lonie, Lee, Ross, Minchington (Sunday game)

Outs
Longer, Shenton. Templeton, Fisher

[plugger66]

Ins
Rooy, Geary, Delaney, Lonie, Lee, Ross, Minchington (Sunday game)

Outs
Longer, Shenton. Templeton, Fisher

You do realise to have that many ins they would have to drop those 3 tonight and that isn't going to happen.

[1966]

Amazed that people want to see Longer dropped.
To me, he has been the biggest positive of the season so far.
He looks like he will be our number 1 ruck for many years to come.

[gringo]

Amazed that people want to see Longer dropped.
To me, he has been the biggest positive of the season so far.
He looks like he will be our number 1 ruck for many years to come.

I think he's come a huge way too. The biggest positive of the season has to be Bruce though. He is like finding $500 bucks you didn't remember having in your pocket.

[Jacks Back]

Amazed that people want to see Longer dropped.
To me, he has been the biggest positive of the season so far.
He looks like he will be our number 1 ruck for many years to come.

Longer just doesn't do anything at all around the ground. At least Hickey can take a mark, kick a goal and can get some possies. It's time to stick Hickey back in the ruck imho and see what he can do.

[plugger66]

Amazed that people want to see Longer dropped.
To me, he has been the biggest positive of the season so far.
He looks like he will be our number 1 ruck for many years to come.

Averaged 6 possessions a game since Hickey has been back. Very lucky to play especially if Hickey is dropped. But he gets a lot of hit outs. Big deal. May as well play Holmes. And the other ruckman nearly plays his best game for the year every week we play them.

[saintsRrising]

Amazed that people want to see Longer dropped.
To me, he has been the biggest positive of the season so far.

Bruce is easily the biggest positive of the year to date....then DAYLIGHT.

After that I have the improvement in Armo
Then the emergence of Sinclair and Lonie up there..

But yes the improvement in Longer has been healthy.

He looks like he will be our number 1 ruck for many years to come.

Trend is good, but he will only become that if he learns to contribute around the ground more including taking some marks.

[saintjake]

Who are the three that will get dropped!

Surely it can't be Acres!

[plugger66]

Who are the three that will get dropped!

Surely it can't be Acres!

Well there is no certain all 4 will come in but I suppose going by the bench it will Hickey or Membery, McKenzie and Templeton.

[stjay]

Who are the three that will get dropped!

Surely it can't be Acres!

Well there is no certain all 4 will come in but I suppose going by the bench it will Hickey or Membery, McKenzie and Templeton.

You'd have to think Roo & Lonie are locks to come back in so Templeton and probably Membrey (Hickey had a bad game last week but overall the last few weeks they seems to be happy with the experiment) will make way.
Greary & Delaney are the suspect ones but given they didn't name another tall defender Delaney must be close to a certain starter which leaves Gears.
They have named him at HBF which is normally Savage. If Gears plays could Savage be in trouble?
I must admit I thought he was going OK but maybe the coaches think otherwise.
Best guess is Shenton makes way.
They seem to want to get games into MacKenzie - I can't see him being dropped but I'll be wrong.

[stjay]

Who are the three that will get dropped!

Surely it can't be Acres!

Well there is no certain all 4 will come in but I suppose going by the bench it will Hickey or Membery, McKenzie and Templeton.

You'd have to think Roo & Lonie are locks to come back in so Templeton and probably Membrey (Hickey had a bad game last week but overall the last few weeks they seems to be happy with the experiment) will make way.
Greary & Delaney are the suspect ones but given they didn't name another tall defender Delaney must be close to a certain starter which leaves Gears.
They have named him at HBF which is normally Savage. If Gears plays could Savage be in trouble?
I must admit I thought he was going OK but maybe the coaches think otherwise.
Best guess is Shenton makes way.
They seem to want to get games into MacKenzie - I can't see him being dropped but I'll be wrong.

Looks like Savage is in the gun.