Who will win our B & F?

[markinUSA]

Hi,

With the Trevor Barker Award being given in a couple of days, I'd like to ask: Who do you think will win?

I suppose the favourites will be Dal and Roo. I suspect Roo will get it.

I'd like to see some sort of "most improved" award go to Joey (from memory, I think there is an award like that), though I imagine Gilbo will give him a run for his money.

If it's best first-year player award, I think the only ones who would fit into that are... hmm... who is it? Clint Jones, and... is James Gwilt also a first year player, technically? Not sure if Sam Gilbert also fits into this category - if so, he would win in a cakewalk.

Any ideas who will get best clubman? Maybe Joey (maybe Harves?)... I dunno. (Too far away to know what really goes on at the club).

Glad to be talking about actual footy-related things at the club, and not infighting.

Cheers
Mark

[Lennon]

Sam Fisher a chance?

[B W and R all over]

Bakes always polled surprisingly well in the Grant Thomas days, but we'll see how he goes with a new match committee.

My money would be on Roo, with Sam Fisher polling well early.

[gosaints]

Roo should win it by the length of the straight.

He has the toughest job in footy this bloke. To be able to play so well with some of the decision making and disposal he gets on the end of is a sign of how great a player he really is.

[Beno88]

i reckon

B&F : Riewoldt, Dal Santo, Montagna, S.Fisher, Hayes.

Most Improved : Montagna/Gilbert/Fiora

Most Conistent : Riewoldt/Gram/S.Fisher

Best First Year Player : Attard (if eligible)

Best Clubman : Hayes/Harvey/Koschitzke

[SaintBot]

B&F Top Ten

1. Nick Riewoldt
2. Nick Dal Santo
3. Leigh Montagna
4. Sam Fisher
5. Robert Harvey
6. Jason Gram
7. Lenny Hayes
8. Justin Koschitzke
9. Sam Gilbert
10. Aaron Fiora
Outsider. Luke Ball


Best Clubman: Robert Harvey

Most Improved: Sam Gilbert

Best First Year Player: Jayden Attard (If not elligible: Clinton Jones)

Most Consistent: Nick Riewoldt/Sam Fisher

[rexy]

Unsure how Attard could be inelligable but Jones Eligible, they were both elevated rookies I thought?

Roo or Fish will win it with Dal, Lenny, Gilbert, Fiora, Joey, Harves and even possibly Blake polling well. Most improved probably Gilbert and possibly X clarke to get the best club man?

[SaintBot]

Unsure how Attard could be inelligable but Jones Eligible, they were both elevated rookies I thought?

attard has already had a few seasons at brisbane...so if he is elligble then so must birss (and gardiner) which im not sure is the case

[rexy]

Thanks, if that is the case and attard is inelligible then I think it would be embarassing for us to give out a best 1st year award. We didnt have a good one at senior level.

[bozza1980]

Nick Riewoldt will claim his fourth Trevor Barker Medal.

[linz]

I don't really give a stuff who wins. I'm a selfish bastard. I'd rather win a premiership.

[crowjelly]

Gram will poll well and should be in top 3

[battye]

and... is James Gwilt also a first year player, technically? Not sure if Sam Gilbert also fits into this category - if so, he would win in a cakewalk.

Didn't he debut in 2005?

[Dal_Santos_Gal]

I don't really give a stuff who wins. I'm a selfish bastard. I'd rather win a premiership.

I hear what ya saying, rather be celebrating a GF....

but the b&f is a good night and I think Rooey will come very close to snagging another one.

Sam Fisher will also poll very well and watch out for Joey, he had a great year.

[Brian Collis]

Best Clubman = Aaron Hamill

[SaintBot]

Best Clubman = Aaron Hamill

2 - Weeks

[Joey is the bomb!]

1. Joey
2. S.Fisher
3. Dal or gilbo