Trade with Coll?

locoplayaz · Post: # 467110Post **locoplayaz** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 2:37pm

If Judd goes to Coll..

Would you take J.Fraser and B.Holland for Pick 9 and Saints 3rd OR 4th round pick? (Whichever gets the deal done)

That would give us a ruck combo of Gardi/Fraser and a speedy defensive mid/fwd who can tag along with Bakes. Add some much needed grunt and in Holland's last 3 seasons has avg 19ppg. Also would release Kosi to FF.
**After that we only need another small fwd..

Cats Premiership side

T.Harley/S.Fisher M.Scarlett/M.Hudghton J.Hunt/L.Fisher
A.Mackie/J.Gram D.Milburn/M.Maguire C.Enright/B.Goddard
D.Wojcinski/L.Montagna C.Ling/B.Holland J.Corey/L.Hayes
S.Johnson/X.Clarke N.Ablett/N.Riewoldt J.Kelly/R.Harvey
M.Stokes/S.Milne C.Mooney/J.Koschitzke P.Chapman/(Small Fwd?)
B.Ottens/J.Fraser G.Ablett/N.Dal Santo J.Bartel/L.Ball
S.King/M.Gardiner J.Selwood/D.Armitage M.Rooke/A.Fiora S.Byrnes/S.Baker

st.byron · Post: # 467113Post **st.byron** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 2:40pm

A reminder Loco that Gardiner has played three games of AFL footy in four years. We'll be lucky to get him on th epark at all and if we do, it remains to be seen if he can hod a place in the team.

Cityboy · Post: # 467114Post **Cityboy** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 2:40pm

I wouldn't take Fraser for free.
________
MAKE A VAPORIZER

saintm · Post: # 467115Post **saintm** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 2:41pm

Doesn't Holland have some type of long-term injury which was possibly going to require surgery?? (could I be any more vague??)

Dan Warna · Post: # 467116Post **Dan Warna** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 2:44pm

holland isn't in collingwoods best 22. not worth it.

fraser IMO well Im interested but J.boy and others have alluded to him having a bad back injury despite being a robust player for nearly a decade.

love fraser but frankly busted back, so sad, too bad, we have our injury worries without another member to sit out the season in the st kilda wing of the epworth.

Fraser is 25/26 after 8 season...if fit has 5 to 6 seasons in him, throw fraser in with a first 22 kid and their first round pick and do a thorough medical on him.

IMO we should NOT do any trades unless its heavily skewed in our favour.

BARREL them IMO.

Dan Warna · Post: # 467117Post **Dan Warna** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 2:45pm

saintm wrote:Doesn't Holland have some type of long-term injury which was possibly going to require surgery?? (could I be any more vague??)

pretty sure I saw holland and licuria running around in their seconds side on Aunty a couple of weeks ago.

if we are going about having a crack at the flag, last thing we need to do is recruit for casey.

kp83 · Post: # 467129Post **kp83** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 3:00pm

No way! Both have chronic, long term injuries (Fraser - low back, Holland - Achilles) and therefore are beyond their best.

saintsRrising · Mon 01 Oct 2007 3:10pm

st.byron wrote:A reminder Loco that Gardiner has played three games of AFL footy in four years. We'll be lucky to get him on th epark at all and if we do, it remains to be seen if he can hod a place in the team.

I think that might be 18 games over the last 4 seasons including 2007.

36 over the last 5.

Year Team Games Kicks Handballs Disposals Marks Goals Behinds Tackles Hitouts Frees For Frees Ag. Brownlow
2006 West Coast 3 19 7 26 14 1 0 5 42 1 3
2005 West Coast 12 65 13 78 47 16 9 2 25 7 2
2004 West Coast 3 17 4 21 14 4 2 0 36 0 0
2003 West Coast 18 179 64 243 113 10 11 6 453 21 22 8

saintspremiers · Mon 01 Oct 2007 5:39pm

kp83 wrote:No way! Both have chronic, long term injuries (Fraser - low back, Holland - Achilles) and therefore are beyond their best.

makes them a perfect fit for us then!

my les foote · Mon 01 Oct 2007 6:19pm

If we get Brodie Holland do we get Sarita Stella? That would sweeten the deal.

Mr Magic · Post: # 467295Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 6:22pm

my les foote wrote:If we get Brodie Holland do we get Sarita Stella? That would sweeten the deal.

What we have to settle for 'seconds' all around?

Judd - Holland
Twigley - Stella

Batnoe · Post: # 467387Post **Batnoe** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 7:44pm

One of my mates loves Didak, and as a joke i have been saying that Pies are trading Didak, He has the number 4 on his back and he said the guernsay is going in the fire, i would love Didak t be traded, not that i want him or anything, i would rather a

Pendlebury, Thomas, Marty Clarke, even Nick Maxwell before Didak

brewski · Post: # 467395Post **brewski** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 7:52pm

Fraser and Holland - NO
Didak - Yes

spert · Post: # 467409Post **spert** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 8:13pm

I'm sure RL won't look at any more players with chronic injuries or fringe players.

stinger · Post: # 467416Post **stinger** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 8:21pm

should we help the filth sign judd...and in the process sign away our hopes for the 2008 premiership cup...or seriously dent them by giving the team who missed out by a whisker this year, a leg up.....no....seriously, why the f*** would we................??????

battye · Post: # 467422Post **battye** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 8:24pm

Don't really think it's worth giving up pick 9 unless the deal involves Thomas or Pendlebury.

Teflon · Post: # 467519Post **Teflon** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 9:32pm

funny thread.

johnpeterbudgefanclub · Mon 01 Oct 2007 10:13pm

Teflon wrote:funny thread.

It is actually......ok.....let me pour some water on the fire. Thomas and Pendlebury signed.....not going anywhere. Not just signed, SIGNED. We have a few things going on at the minute. Not having high draft picks is not our immediate concern.

And yes it is a funny thread.......

Eastern · Post: # 467568Post **Eastern** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 10:18pm

I thought there were 15 clubs who were reluctant to deal/trade with Collingwood !!

goodie · Post: # 467569Post **goodie** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 10:19pm

Trade with Collingwood? Even the thought makes me feel all dirty

Teflon · Post: # 467617Post **Teflon** » Mon 01 Oct 2007 10:53pm

johnpeterbudgefanclub wrote:
Teflon wrote:funny thread.

It is actually......ok.....let me pour some water on the fire. Thomas and Pendlebury signed.....not going anywhere. Not just signed, SIGNED. We have a few things going on at the minute. Not having high draft picks is not our immediate concern.

And yes it is a funny thread.......

Collingwood have nought Id be interested in.

johnpeterbudgefanclub · Mon 01 Oct 2007 10:54pm

Brian Collis · Tue 02 Oct 2007 9:01am

F*** Collingwood, they don't deserve anything from anybody.