Hunter vs Peris

[JR23]

Whats happened

Hunter is emergency' vs Peris ?

Not that I hope Peris is not ready but what is RTB saying about Hunter

[outside66]

Probably a couple of reasons; Peris coming in for Higgins/Billings as the second small forward. Also, Hunter has played one game at Sandy since returning from injury whereas Peris has played all year. Hunter as the sub would be a good move!

[Teflon]

Clark 1 VFL game 3 quarters looked rusty from those on hand
Sub might be good for him

[bobmurray]

Hunter v Peris is interesting but McCartin v Petracca is more interesting.
Petracca tore Brisbane a new a hole tonight, who do we have that can do that. Could we have had him ?

We need to have faith in SOS and Allan not to stuff up.

[magnifisaint]

Hunter v Peris is interesting but McCartin v Petracca is more interesting.
Petracca tore Brisbane a new a hole tonight, who do we have that can do that. Could we have had him ?

We need to have faith in SOS and Allan not to stuff up.

That's what I thought. We all wanted Petracca except Trout. Paddy is a better human being through. That won't help St Kilda win a premiership though.

[SaintPav]

Where is good old Trout now.

He really tore us a new one.

Thanks a lot Trout.

[Scollop]

I think this is appropriate

[B.M]

Mate

When it happened at the time

Most on here jumped on McCartin and leapt to the defence of Elshaug (in the ‘have faith’ motto)

People who criticised the decision at the time were howled down as it was justified by the masses

I went a bit far by saying we picked a fat diabetic ahead of the best player 18yo in Australia

Joffaboy tried to run me out of town with his pitchfork carrying cronies!
Funnily enough he flipped out draft night too (

But then flip flopped onto to the Paddy train the next day proclaiming it a master stroke! The McCartin Hugh Goddard bookends had set us up for a decade!!!!

While we overlooked a future champion mid

Seriously- it was a circus

[Otiman]

Playing your first game as a sub is a cop out.

Glad the club backs first gamers in with a spot in the 22.

[Saintmatt]

Playing your first game as a sub is a cop out.

Glad the club backs first gamers in with a spot in the 22.

Are you forgetting we played NWM7 as a sub in R1 last year? Even worse … unused.

[sks023]

Clark should have been out there from the first
Rusty , not fit ... f off with the clichie bulls***

[SaintPav]

A lot of posters were pissed that we didn’t select Petracca.

[B.M]

Now they are, that’s hindsight

At the time they leapt to the defence of list management and recruiting

Calling him fattracca and even taking solace that he did an ACL year 1

It was the single biggest recruiting blunder (without hindsight) I can recall!

[Otiman]

Are you forgetting we played NWM7 as a sub in R1 last year? Even worse … unused.

I didn't know that, but that's terrible.