McCartin

[borderbarry]

We are not taking either. Cockatoo at 1.

[Burkey 1]

I still we will go with Petracca.

We have Spencer White, Rooey just signed for 2 more years, we have Mckernan training with us, Longer & Hickey can pinch hit up forward so I would be very surprised if we went with McCartin as we do need a real classy strong bodied midfielder who I think can be our next Lenny or Harvs, big calls on the kid I know but he does seem to have the goods.

I'm still nervous but I reckon we will go Petracca.

[stinger]

We are not taking either. Cockatoo at 1.

...could do worse...

[cwrcyn]

Well, that was one of the most underwhelming highlights package I've ever seen from a draft prospect. I also noticed that he was playing against a guy about 15 kg lighter. Hmmm......

I'm concerned

[borderbarry]

No matter who we take there will be someone taken later who is better. Wait and see.

[HitTheBoundary]

This thread should be retitled "For drama queens only."

Nothing has actually happened.....

[falka]

I am very concerned!!!!!!!!!

[Munga]

If we're going to be 'different' I'd take Wright or Brayshaw.

[Heidelberg_Saint]

No.
What testing? this is BS.

Petracca is an elite athlete. He marks, handballs better than any and has GOAL SENSE!

IF we choose Paddy, A DIEBETIC, whos highlights were just a lead up forward ILL GO BANANAS!

Reece McKenzie is every bit as good bar endurance.
We can get him at 22.

Seriously what the hell? We will be the laughing stock of the AFL.

I take real offence at someone claiming McCartin can't perform his job because he's a diabetic. As someone's who lived with a life long medical condition, it hasn't stopped me doing one thing. What is has taught me is self-discipline, perspective and given me life experience.

[chook23]

tony74 commented in another thread re JO.....but did not comment in this thread...

[saintbob]

I hope it's al BS

[stinger]

This thread should be retitled "For drama queens only."

Nothing has actually happened.....

[SaintPav]

lol.

I can't believe people are falling for this.

Get a grip. It's a tweet trolling for listeners for its radio show.

The reasoning in the tweet doesn't make much sense anyway and is a bit of a giveaway that it is bullsh!t.

[WinnersOnly]

This thread should be retitled "For drama queens only."

Nothing has actually happened.....

Yep I stand accused - just want the club to get things right!

[magnifisaint]

Doesn't make any sense at all. The recruiting staff have known since trade period who they are taking otherwise they would have swapped no1 for the 2 draft picks and taken someone similar to McCartin and picked up another midfielder. It all points to Petracca otherwise they are more stupid than we think.

[Dr Spaceman]

Doesn't make any sense at all. The recruiting staff have known since trade period who they are taking otherwise they would have swapped no1 for the 2 draft picks and taken someone similar to McCartin and picked up another midfielder. It all points to Petracca otherwise they are more stupid than we think.

Not necessarily.

IF they did/do in fact want McCartin (as opposed to someone similar) then they had to retain pick 1 to ensure they get him.

[magnifisaint]

Doesn't make any sense at all. The recruiting staff have known since trade period who they are taking otherwise they would have swapped no1 for the 2 draft picks and taken someone similar to McCartin and picked up another midfielder. It all points to Petracca otherwise they are more stupid than we think.

Not necessarily.

IF they did/do in fact want McCartin (as opposed to someone similar) then they had to retain pick 1 to ensure they get him.

Looks like the other talls could be as good as him.

[stinger]

i'd be happy wwith this kid as our 2 pick...


http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/a ... 7133412723

[fugazi]

Surely to God someone on this forum must know who we are taking for sure.

Either someone connected with the club or the player or the delivery driver who delivered a package from the StKilda Football Club to a Warrandyte address that looked curiously like a footy jumper!

[stinger]

Surely to God someone on this forum must know who we are taking for sure.

Either someone connected with the club or the player or the delivery driver who delivered a package from the StKilda Football Club to a Warrandyte address that looked curiously like a footy jumper!

yeah...tony

[Old Mate]

lol.

I can't believe people are falling for this.

Get a grip. It's a tweet trolling for listeners for its radio show.

The reasoning in the tweet doesn't make much sense anyway and is a bit of a giveaway that it is bullsh!t.

You're a smart man, pav. I could not have said it better myself!

[Old Mate]

lol.

I can't believe people are falling for this.

Get a grip. It's a tweet trolling for listeners for its radio show.

The reasoning in the tweet doesn't make much sense anyway and is a bit of a giveaway that it is bullsh!t.

You're a smart man, pav. I could not have said it better myself!

[Waltzing St Kilda]

What are their draft player numbers?

I want to know who they've picked a millisecond before they say his actual name.

[Siposstar#2]

We are not allowed to do private testing on under 18 players, petraccas testing was fine. Its BS

[evo]

A lot on here may have counted their chickens a little early and are now venting anger because their love child maybe is not the clubs choice. Most experts cannot split them so there must be a lot to like about Paddy. Good key forwards don't come cheaply and are rarely traded.