Goddard to Carlton?

IluvHarvey · Mon 03 Oct 2011 3:39pm

borderbarry wrote:Must apologise. I posted above after only reading Page One.

NOT GOOD ENOUGH!! Apology not accepted!

Cairnsman · Post: # 1155021Post **Cairnsman** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 3:42pm

Moccha wrote:Why do they reckon they can bend St.Kilda over so they can take it up the backside?

Because they know St Kilda likes it up the backside.

Ross who? · Post: # 1155022Post **Ross who?** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 3:43pm

Sports news first, Kim Hagdon......

Move on, nothing to see here

Sainternist · Mon 03 Oct 2011 4:47pm

Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so

What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?

shmic_s · Post: # 1155072Post **shmic_s** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 4:52pm

Can't believe some people are actually okay with BJ leaving.
BJ, Dal Santo, Fisher IMO are the 3 players we would be trying like mad to hang on to.
Losing the decision making, disposal and leadership they provide would be a huge negative weather we are maintaing our assult towards a flag or rebuilding.

saintbrat · Post: # 1155073Post **saintbrat** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 4:55pm

Ross who? wrote:Sports news first, Kim Hagdon......

Move on, nothing to see here

paid by Paul Connors ------ he wishes......

and in bid- Bid all you like stick fat BJ and saints

Sainternist · Mon 03 Oct 2011 4:58pm

shmic_s wrote:Can't believe some people are actually okay with BJ leaving.
BJ, Dal Santo, Fisher IMO are the 3 players we would be trying like mad to hang on to.
Losing the decision making, disposal and leadership they provide would be a huge negative weather we are maintaing our assult towards a flag or rebuilding.

+1

Sainternist · Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:00pm

Add your comment... Comments (4)
Shlezbian 3 October 2011 1:40PM

GIlbert has re-signed with the saints. Rubbish article. Get your facts straight.

Cairnsman · Post: # 1155081Post **Cairnsman** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:03pm

Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?

Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.

saintbrat · Post: # 1155082Post **saintbrat** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:04pm

Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.

he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ

plugger66 · Post: # 1155083Post **plugger66** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:05pm

saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ

When was this hip injury mentioned? Never heard it before.

saintbrat · Post: # 1155085Post **saintbrat** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:07pm

plugger66 wrote:
saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ
When was this hip injury mentioned? Never heard it before.

before the game- and if I could find the video I'd know how to spell it- had two injuryies repaired when he went in. the suggestion was given to him that one of them wasn't new and he said yeh he may have had it a while.

plugger66 · Post: # 1155092Post **plugger66** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:11pm

saintbrat wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ
When was this hip injury mentioned? Never heard it before.
before the game- and if I could find the video I'd know how to spell it- had two injuryies repaired when he went in. the suggestion was given to him that one of them wasn't new and he said yeh he may have had it a while.

Doesnt sound much in it then.

Sainternist · Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:14pm

saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ

Bratty, never hear about the hip injury either, but I share your exact sentiments on Brendan.

Cairnsman, I see you're still heading the pack for the Barry Crocker Saintsational Forum Award

Cairnsman · Post: # 1155096Post **Cairnsman** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:17pm

Sainternist wrote:
saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ
Bratty, never hear about the hip injury either, but I share your exact sentiments on Brendan.

Cairnsman, I see you're still heading the pack for the Barry Crocker Saintsational Forum Award

Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.

IluvHarvey · Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:18pm

Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ
Bratty, never hear about the hip injury either, but I share your exact sentiments on Brendan.

Cairnsman, I see you're still heading the pack for the Barry Crocker Saintsational Forum Award
Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.

We will also get nothing for him if we keep him!! Which you seem so sure wont happen. Why?

maverick · Post: # 1155099Post **maverick** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:21pm

saintbrat wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ
When was this hip injury mentioned? Never heard it before.
before the game- and if I could find the video I'd know how to spell it- had two injuryies repaired when he went in. the suggestion was given to him that one of them wasn't new and he said yeh he may have had it a while.

Talked about it on BFG, he definitely carried it all year and definitely affected his movement.

They had to drag the comments out of him, he was at pains to say he wasn't making excuses.

Not that sort of bloke.

Just like Lenny playing an extra week with his ACL torn back in 2006

plugger66 · Post: # 1155100Post **plugger66** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:21pm

Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
saintbrat wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Geez I hope so
What?!?! You actually hope he leaves?
Not because I don't like him as a player however I just think it's obvious he will have huge money thrown at him and we should be doing something about it while we can get something for some of our players.

He clearly was down this year and he probably needs a fresh start to revive his premiership dream.
he carried ahip injury most of the year and still worked his guts out-- we will never achieve by trading away our quality........ Stick around BJ
Bratty, never hear about the hip injury either, but I share your exact sentiments on Brendan.

Cairnsman, I see you're still heading the pack for the Barry Crocker Saintsational Forum Award
Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.

It isnt sound because we are talking about Carlton who have pick 22. How is that any good to us. We could wait until the end of next year and if he wanted to leave then we would get 2 first rounders if he went to GWS. It makes no sense to let him even try and end up at Carlton.

SENsei · Post: # 1155101Post **SENsei** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:23pm

The only reason Carlton is being mentioned is because of who he barracked for as a kid.

This is a beat up.

dragit · Post: # 1155105Post **dragit** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:23pm

Cairnsman wrote:Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.

The only way we could lose him for nothing wiser nuts is if he walked in 3 yearsâ€¦ by which time we could have him on the veterans list and easily match any rivals offers, so stop beating off on your drums so loudly

Sainternist · Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:25pm

Cairnsman wrote:Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.

Which drums were beating? The doldrums?

Perhaps he found himself a little in the doldrums, but he will pick himself out after a proper pre-season.

I think we'd be mad to let him go. We need to keep a player with his sort of versatility. These type of players are rare.

Plus, it's a risk trading for him. How can you be sure we'll get a good deal?

Only people like Hutchy believe in trading him. Surely, you're not stooping to that level, Cairnsman?

degruch · Post: # 1155121Post **degruch** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 5:51pm

I hope they have a good, hard, well publicised crack at it...should serve to highlight to the AFL once and for all that Carlton are exploiting loopholes that must be closed - they cannot possibly afford that team without considerable off-the-books work.

Cairnsman · Post: # 1155129Post **Cairnsman** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 6:04pm

Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.
Which drums were beating? The doldrums?

Perhaps he found himself a little in the doldrums, but he will pick himself out after a proper pre-season.

I think we'd be mad to let him go. We need to keep a player with his sort of versatility. These type of players are rare.

Plus, it's a risk trading for him. How can you be sure we'll get a good deal?

Only people like Hutchy believe in trading him. Surely, you're not stooping to that level, Cairnsman?

All I'm saying is that the noises are getting louder and history proves that where there's noise there is big cash. He's done at the Saints mark my words. He knows he's not going to get a premiership at the Saints and I reckon that has to come into his decission making.

borderbarry · Mon 03 Oct 2011 6:24pm

Huh. What makes you think we wont be around the mark again this year?

plugger66 · Post: # 1155138Post **plugger66** » Mon 03 Oct 2011 6:26pm

Cairnsman wrote:
Sainternist wrote:
Cairnsman wrote:Not at all wise nuts. My argument is sound. Losing Goddard will not be the worst thing that could happen in a trade deal. The worst thing that could happen is if we lose him for zero. The drums have been beating loadly for a while on this one and the drums usually never lie.
Which drums were beating? The doldrums?

Perhaps he found himself a little in the doldrums, but he will pick himself out after a proper pre-season.

I think we'd be mad to let him go. We need to keep a player with his sort of versatility. These type of players are rare.

Plus, it's a risk trading for him. How can you be sure we'll get a good deal?

Only people like Hutchy believe in trading him. Surely, you're not stooping to that level, Cairnsman?
All I'm saying is that the noises are getting louder and history proves that where there's noise there is big cash. He's done at the Saints mark my words. He knows he's not going to get a premiership at the Saints and I reckon that has to come into his decission making.

This is where you dont make sense. You are probably right that he wont win a flag at the Saints but neither will Dal, Joey or Rooy. Why do you think they wont want to go either. Lets trade them now just in case.

And by the way over 1000 players have never won a flag at the Saints. Most of them didnt go to another club.