Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
B.M wrote: ↑Tue 12 Apr 2022 6:26pm
How did those Ruthless Hawks go Sunday?!
Meanwhile Membrey kicked another 4 and flogged Sicily
Membrey's performance on Sunday actually enhances my suggestion. I have already said he is a good player. With him killing it, it makes it more likely that we would snag a pick in the region of pick 15 for him and say a 3rd or 4th round pick.
Thanks for helping validating my suggestion B.M.
St Kilda should never trade with Essendon and Sydney ever again!!!
Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Tue 12 Apr 2022 6:46pm
You've just validated my suggestion, one that I have kept to myself for fear of incurring a lifetime ban.
2015 is 7 years ago now. Their rebuild started with giving us a first and second rounder for Jaeger O Meara - ruthless indeed
Before the 1971 Grand Final between St Kilda and Hawthorn, both teams had one premiership. St Kilda still has one, guess how many Hawthorn have?
Stick to your op without bringing up other questions and comparing Hawthorn’s lists from the past 50 years
Do to tell us about Hawthorns list build around 1975-1979 and please have a look at their recruits from 1985-1989 and also more recently could you please score their playing list and their drafting from 2005-2009…. I mean seriously mate! Get a grip. It takes a lot more than just a simple trade here and there to win a premiership
You bought up the trade regarding Membrey. If Skunk is in this sort of form and is providing this sort leadership on field, then your suggestion looks dumber every week that goes by. If we are going to go deep into September this year and perhaps next year again, then this will have to be the dumbest thread of 2022 without doubt
2015 is 7 years ago now. Their rebuild started with giving us a first and second rounder for Jaeger O Meara - ruthless indeed
Before the 1971 Grand Final between St Kilda and Hawthorn, both teams had one premiership. St Kilda still has one, guess how many Hawthorn have?
Stick to your op without bringing up other questions and comparing Hawthorn’s lists from the past 50 years
Do to tell us about Hawthorns list build around 1975-1979 and please have a look at their recruits from 1985-1989 and also more recently could you please score their playing list and their drafting from 2005-2009…. I mean seriously mate! Get a grip. It takes a lot more than just a simple trade here and there to win a premiership
You bought up the trade regarding Membrey. If Skunk is in this sort of form and is providing this sort leadership on field, then your suggestion looks dumber every week that goes by. If we are going to go deep into September this year and perhaps next year again, then this will have to be the dumbest thread of 2022 without doubt
I don't agree. Membrey is stunting Sharman's growth. By trading him out we clear the way for Sharman and we get a bonus FRDP. That's the key for successful list building. ie. make decisions that are for the now and for the future!!
St Kilda should never trade with Essendon and Sydney ever again!!!
I’ll tell you what’s good for now and for the future…. give it a rest Ernie
Next you’ll be telling us that Marshall is stunting Heath’s growth. Next you’ll be telling us that Gresham is stunting Owen’s growth
If Sharman kicks a few goals and King is struggling, next you’ll be telling us that Max is stunting Cooper’s growth…
St Kilda is a contender. Do you not see that at all? Membrey is for now because we need him now. We could be looking at an opportunity for St Kilda to go deep into September this year or next year
Scollop, he's not about saying the sky is blue if you say it's blue, he'll call it an angry shade of periwinkle just for the reaction. That said, I'm a fan of periwinkle but prefer my sky to be blue.
I cant believe a true Saints supporter would ever consider trading Membrey, it would have been akin to Richmond trading Riewoldt 5 years - absolute rubbish.
