Votes v GWS

[goods]

Paton is so underrated and kept Toby Greene very quiet

Not sure why he was a running all Australian defender with coffield and Clavarino as a key. Exciting

[bangaulegend]

Not going to get in a debate about Sebs efficiency I just thought last night his clearance work was good especially in the second half , lowered his eyes & was a very big part of why we had such a good win & gave him votes accordingly but as I have mentioned in the previous post its just my view I know you don't agree that's just our difference of opinion & I can live with that.

[6621104]

Steele
Ryder
Lonie
Marshall
Clark

(descending order)

[Scollop]

From saints.com.au

BEST
St Kilda: Steele, Butler, Marshall, Wilkie, Ryder, Clark, ROSS, Long
Greater Western Sydney: Whitfield, Coniglio, Lloyd, Hopper, Perryman

From the age .com.au

BEST
St Kilda: Steele, Marshall, Clark, Battle, ROSS
GWS: Whitfield, Coniglio, Keeffe.

I'll be stuffed if I know how the people who made those 'best' lists can leave out Brad Hill.

Might have been off to the fridge too often

Obviously they didn't watch every minute of the match...most posters here had Hill in their votes...including saynta

[Sainter_Dad]

From the age .com.au

BEST
St Kilda: Steele, Marshall, Clark, Battle, ROSS
GWS: Whitfield, Coniglio, Keeffe.

Why do you feel you need to justify that Ross was in the best 6 ? IMO he was in our best 6 this week but some sites didn't but some did. Just don't get why you feel compelled to keep highlighting what paper or site rated him .Everyone sees things differently that doesn't mean its right or wrong it's just their view

Why do you guys feel the need to corrupt the voting thread with your petty arguing - take it elsewhere!!!! [ie Start ANOTHER look at me thread!!]

[bangaulegend]

From the age .com.au

BEST
St Kilda: Steele, Marshall, Clark, Battle, ROSS
GWS: Whitfield, Coniglio, Keeffe.

Why do you feel you need to justify that Ross was in the best 6 ? IMO he was in our best 6 this week but some sites didn't but some did. Just don't get why you feel compelled to keep highlighting what paper or site rated him .Everyone sees things differently that doesn't mean its right or wrong it's just their view

Why do you guys feel the need to corrupt the voting thread with your petty arguing - take it elsewhere!!!! [ie Start ANOTHER look at me thread!!]

Sorry mate my bad good call

[saynta]

From the age .com.au

BEST
St Kilda: Steele, Marshall, Clark, Battle, ROSS
GWS: Whitfield, Coniglio, Keeffe.

Why do you feel you need to justify that Ross was in the best 6 ? IMO he was in our best 6 this week but some sites didn't but some did. Just don't get why you feel compelled to keep highlighting what paper or site rated him .Everyone sees things differently that doesn't mean its right or wrong it's just their view

Why do you guys feel the need to corrupt the voting thread with your petty arguing - take it elsewhere!!!! [ie Start ANOTHER look at me thread!!]

[StPeter]

5 Steele
4 Marshall
3 Clark
2 Wilkie
1 Hill

[terry smith rules]

5 Steele
4 Marshall
3 Coffield
1 Lonie
1 Clark
1 Battle

[Sainter_Dad]

156 Steele
104 Marshall
92 Ryder
61 Clark
29 Hill
22.5 Paton
10 Battle
10 Ross
9 Howard
9 Lonie
8.5 Wilkie
7 Butler
7 Coffield
5 Sinclair
2 King
2 Long
1 Billings

Therefore:
5 Steele
4 Marshall
3 Ryder
2 Clark
1 Hill

[George27]

Thanks as always , SainterDad. 17 blokes polling votes is a great reflection of the fact that we had so many contributors.

[avid]

Thanks as always , SainterDad. 17 blokes polling votes is a great reflection of the fact that we had so many contributors.

As a matter of interest, who missed?
Carlisle,
Kent,
Geary,
Membrey,
Hannebery

[Sainter_Dad]

Thanks as always , SainterDad. 17 blokes polling votes is a great reflection of the fact that we had so many contributors.

As a matter of interest, who missed?
Carlisle,
Kent,
Geary,
Membrey,
Hannebery

Correct