Carro the hypocrite

[saynta]

I alway love it when the schoolgirl topic comes up. Everyone has an opinion even though so few know the real story. It's not a story that the club wants to get out. Some journos know the real story and couldn't print it. The others who know the truth were bullied and threatened into staying quiet.

Usually the crap on this forum makes me laugh.

Topics like this put this place into perspective and how little most know about what really goes on.

Mofw

Well, after that, me thinks you should stay true to your nic and STFU.

[White Winmar]

I alway love it when the schoolgirl topic comes up. Everyone has an opinion even though so few know the real story. It's not a story that the club wants to get out. Some journos know the real story and couldn't print it. The others who know the truth were bullied and threatened into staying quiet.

Usually the crap on this forum makes me laugh.

Topics like this put this place into perspective and how little most know about what really goes on.

Mofw

Well inform us of the truth or STFU. Deliver if you can. I won't hold my breath.

[White Winmar]

I alway love it when the schoolgirl topic comes up. Everyone has an opinion even though so few know the real story. It's not a story that the club wants to get out. Some journos know the real story and couldn't print it. The others who know the truth were bullied and threatened into staying quiet.

Usually the crap on this forum makes me laugh.

Topics like this put this place into perspective and how little most know about what really goes on.

Mofw

Well inform us of the truth or STFU. Deliver if you can. I won't hold my breath.

[stonecold]

Yes White-Winnie, good call, interesting call, go ahead, the floor is yours MOFWS!!!!!

[The OtherThommo]

I had a little correspondence with Ms Wilson, during the height of the E'dope matter. A certain journalist acted as the conduit, and suggested she might benefit from understanding some of the real nuts and bolts.

From that experience, I'm with those who suggest she is more interested in the interpersonal relationships, the 'goss' and what might titillate, rather than cold hard facts, and how those facts lie within the context of what's right, and what's wrong.

Some time later, Ms Wilson went to print with a E'dope story that was filled with easily identifiable factual errors - she'd merely channeled a couple of vested parties, put the pen away, and concluded job done.

Somewhat enraged, I contacted the above mentioned journalist. When I explained the errors, his response went like 'Oh no, she hasn't has she?'. I assured him she had, he had a read, agreed, and went down a floor or 2 to suggest she publish corrections.

When he got back in touch, to relay what he'd done, he concluded by saying 'I doubt she'll do anything'.

She didn't, and I haven't read or listened to her since.

I am reminded here of something Seymour Hersh said in an interview, recently. When asked what he thought about a particularly warm current issue dominating the media, Hersh said, rather angrily:

"It doesn't matter what I think, it only matters what I know".

[manoffewwords]

At the time, certain journalists were unable to publish the facts about the beginning of the saga as the person with said facts was bullied and threatened to say nothing. They had been lined up to go public but backed out at the last minute.

For the same reasons, it would be very foolish to discuss on a public forum.
All I am saying is that there is another reality here that only a handful of people know.


i apologise if this challenges some of you.


Mofw

[Devilhead]

At the time, certain journalists were unable to publish the facts about the beginning of the saga as the person with said facts was bullied and threatened to say nothing. They had been lined up to go public but backed out at the last minute.

For the same reasons, it would be very foolish to discuss on a public forum.
All I am saying is that there is another reality here that only a handful of people know.


i apologise if this challenges some of you.


Mofw

So whatever it is - true or not - is dead and buried as no one will come forward

In that case why even bring it up?? Especially on a St Kilda forum ...... By a supposed St Kilda supporter no less!!

Poor form if you ask me and no credibility from here on in for you

[mr six o'clock]

For the same reasons, it would be very foolish to discuss on a public forum.
All I am saying is that there is another reality here that only a handful of people know.



Mofw

in the words of mr stiring !
Is this a reality as vast as space and as timeless as infinity.
It is the middle ground between light and shadow , between science and superstition , and it lies between the pit of man's fear and the summit of his knowledge.
This is the dimension of imagination .
It is an area which we will call
The Twilight Zone

[White Winmar]

At the time, certain journalists were unable to publish the facts about the beginning of the saga as the person with said facts was bullied and threatened to say nothing. They had been lined up to go public but backed out at the last minute.

For the same reasons, it would be very foolish to discuss on a public forum.
All I am saying is that there is another reality here that only a handful of people know.


i apologise if this challenges some of you.


Mofw

Well if it's so foolish to discuss on a public forum, why discuss it on a public forum? Ipso facto, you must be foolish and therefore not to be taken seriously.

[Enrico_Misso]

At the time, certain journalists were unable to publish the facts about the beginning of the saga as the person with said facts was bullied and threatened to say nothing. They had been lined up to go public but backed out at the last minute.

For the same reasons, it would be very foolish to discuss on a public forum.
All I am saying is that there is another reality here that only a handful of people know.


i apologise if this challenges some of you.


Mofw

Well if it's so foolish to discuss on a public forum, why discuss it on a public forum? Ipso facto, you must be foolish and therefore not to be taken seriously.

Man of few brains?

[HardSaint]

At the time, certain journalists were unable to publish the facts about the beginning of the saga as the person with said facts was bullied and threatened to say nothing. They had been lined up to go public but backed out at the last minute.

For the same reasons, it would be very foolish to discuss on a public forum.
All I am saying is that there is another reality here that only a handful of people know.


i apologise if this challenges some of you.


Mofw

Come clean, spill the beans... all the above we already know, FFS we're not talking the geopolitics of the Middle East or Eastern Europe, you'd be surprised how unchallenged many of us are by knowing that there has always been "another reality that only a handful know" FFS dont get me started on that track...

what, so you think the CIA will have you marked for revealing intel on their agent Kim Duthie? stop flattering yourself with notions of being an insider yourself and withholding the juice as though everyone else cant handle the truth or it would be foolish to reveal or discuss on a public forum because it would blow the collective mind of society ...

It's tattle and gossip and ripe for discussion, who are you Caro? feeling special about keeping mum about what you wont reveal, protecting sources and being privy to secrets that you dare not speak of - yet tease others with your knowing of.... that old power trip

cough it up or stop big noting about being in on the special secret that us proles cant handle

[Mr Magic]

Seems like Caro continues to try and create an issue between Roo and the Club.
For weeks she has been harping on about 'a problem' between the parties over next season.
BUT on Monday night on Footy Classified' she seemed to step back from her position by making the following statement/question on the issue
'surely there's a problem?' .

Apparently today in her column in The Age she's gone back to her forthright opinion (as fact) that there is a problem.

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?
Maybe his management are fuelling it by leaking bits of information/misinformation to her?
Or maybe she just doesn't like Roo?
Or maybe she just doesn't like St Kilda?

[thejiggingsaint]

Seems like Caro continues to try and create an issue between Roo and the Club.
For weeks she has been harping on about 'a problem' between the parties over next season.
BUT on Monday night on Footy Classified' she seemed to step back from her position by making the following statement/question on the issue
'surely there's a problem?' .

Apparently today in her column in The Age she's gone back to her forthright opinion (as fact) that there is a problem.

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?
Maybe his management are fuelling it by leaking bits of information/misinformation to her?
Or maybe she just doesn't like Roo?
Or maybe she just doesn't like St Kilda?

Couldn't give a continental for Ms Wilson's opinion of the Saints.

[freely]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

[Mr Magic]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

Obviously older than you as I'm able to both read and comprehend.
Something you seemingly still find difficult to do.

Maybe if I replaced the word 'infatuation' with 'obsession' you might better understand the point I was making.
But then again your natural inclination was to go the 'schoolgirl' route so changing the word would probably not aid your comprehension in any significant way.

[elizabethr]

This woman suffers from a major Personality Disorder.

[stonecold]

Sorry Folks, just felt the need to post this in this thread as well as the other one:

I think the Club and Roo should be left to make the decision for the best for both parties, then, if they can not agree, the Club makes the final call!!!!!

All media build up at the moment, just bottom feeders like Caro looking for a story that isn't there, just trying to extract some form of revenge or poison our/he's image!!!!!

[satchmo]

Sorry Folks, just felt the need to post this in this thread as well as the other one:

I think the Club and Roo should be left to make the decision for the best for both parties, then, if they can not agree, the Club makes the final call!!!!!

All media build up at the moment, just bottom feeders like Caro looking for a story that isn't there, just trying to extract some form of revenge or poison our/he's image!!!!!

Stoney nails it.

[freely]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

Obviously older than you as I'm able to both read and comprehend.
Something you seemingly still find difficult to do.

Maybe if I replaced the word 'infatuation' with 'obsession' you might better understand the point I was making.
But then again your natural inclination was to go the 'schoolgirl' route so changing the word would probably not aid your comprehension in any significant way.

Sorry Magic - shouldn't have made it personal - but it drives me nuts on here that people demonise and belittle Caroline Wilson, especially when that's coupled with casual sexism. So - just sticking to my own opinion - I think she does a difficult job incredibly well and haven't noticed any particular bias against the Saints, certainly no obsession with Riewoldt. I can't remember the last time she wrote about him.

[Mr Magic]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

Obviously older than you as I'm able to both read and comprehend.
Something you seemingly still find difficult to do.

Maybe if I replaced the word 'infatuation' with 'obsession' you might better understand the point I was making.
But then again your natural inclination was to go the 'schoolgirl' route so changing the word would probably not aid your comprehension in any significant way.

Sorry Magic - shouldn't have made it personal - but it drives me nuts on here that people demonise and belittle Caroline Wilson, especially when that's coupled with casual sexism. So - just sticking to my own opinion - I think she does a difficult job incredibly well and haven't noticed any particular bias against the Saints, certainly no obsession with Riewoldt. I can't remember the last time she wrote about him.

No problem.

[WellardSaint]

This woman suffers from a major Personality Disorder.

Gold

Wilson behaves along the lines of those Bauer Media "journos" who got stuck into Rebel Wilson.
I take no sides in the Rebel vs Media wrestling match, but I point to the fact that Rebel won big time,
and those "journos" were only interested in gossip and rumour, and drove the story at high speed,
leaving our friends "truth" and "facts" sitting on the front doorstep,
mouth open, wondering why they'd been left behind.

Wilson is a nasty piece of work

[saynta]

This woman suffers from a major Personality Disorder.

Gold

Wilson behaves along the lines of those Bauer Media "journos" who got stuck into Rebel Wilson.
I take no sides in the Rebel vs Media wrestling match, but I point to the fact that Rebel won big time,
and those "journos" were only interested in gossip and rumour, and drove the story at high speed,
leaving our friends "truth" and "facts" sitting on the front doorstep,
mouth open, wondering why they'd been left behind.

Wilson is a nasty piece of work

Been saying that for years. You only have to look at her. Nasty.

[WellardSaint]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

Obviously older than you as I'm able to both read and comprehend.
Something you seemingly still find difficult to do.

Maybe if I replaced the word 'infatuation' with 'obsession' you might better understand the point I was making.
But then again your natural inclination was to go the 'schoolgirl' route so changing the word would probably not aid your comprehension in any significant way.

Sorry Magic - shouldn't have made it personal - but it drives me nuts on here that people demonise and belittle Caroline Wilson, especially when that's coupled with casual sexism. So - just sticking to my own opinion - I think she does a difficult job incredibly well and haven't noticed any particular bias against the Saints, certainly no obsession with Riewoldt. I can't remember the last time she wrote about him.

she doesn't do a difficult job incredibly well.
Her job is to create a story based on innuendo and rumour, similar to Barrett the Slug, but she hides her "sources" behind a fog
and just says "I heard" or "I've been reliably informed"

She lives in the gutter and just rakes mud. I cannot stand her as she is evil and rotten to the core.
She takes delight in stirring the pot.
Evil, evil witch, from the depths of hell.

[freely]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

Obviously older than you as I'm able to both read and comprehend.
Something you seemingly still find difficult to do.

Maybe if I replaced the word 'infatuation' with 'obsession' you might better understand the point I was making.
But then again your natural inclination was to go the 'schoolgirl' route so changing the word would probably not aid your comprehension in any significant way.

Sorry Magic - shouldn't have made it personal - but it drives me nuts on here that people demonise and belittle Caroline Wilson, especially when that's coupled with casual sexism. So - just sticking to my own opinion - I think she does a difficult job incredibly well and haven't noticed any particular bias against the Saints, certainly no obsession with Riewoldt. I can't remember the last time she wrote about him.

she doesn't do a difficult job incredibly well.
Her job is to create a story based on innuendo and rumour, similar to Barrett the Slug, but she hides her "sources" behind a fog
and just says "I heard" or "I've been reliably informed"

She lives in the gutter and just rakes mud. I cannot stand her as she is evil and rotten to the core.
She takes delight in stirring the pot.
Evil, evil witch, from the depths of hell.

Lol - why don't you tell us what you really think?

[WellardSaint]

I'm not sure what her motives are for this seeming infatuation with Roo?

She's not a schoolgirl, Mr Magic - but I wonder how old you are making stupid comments like this.

Obviously older than you as I'm able to both read and comprehend.
Something you seemingly still find difficult to do.

Maybe if I replaced the word 'infatuation' with 'obsession' you might better understand the point I was making.
But then again your natural inclination was to go the 'schoolgirl' route so changing the word would probably not aid your comprehension in any significant way.

Sorry Magic - shouldn't have made it personal - but it drives me nuts on here that people demonise and belittle Caroline Wilson, especially when that's coupled with casual sexism. So - just sticking to my own opinion - I think she does a difficult job incredibly well and haven't noticed any particular bias against the Saints, certainly no obsession with Riewoldt. I can't remember the last time she wrote about him.

she doesn't do a difficult job incredibly well.
Her job is to create a story based on innuendo and rumour, similar to Barrett the Slug, but she hides her "sources" behind a fog
and just says "I heard" or "I've been reliably informed"

She lives in the gutter and just rakes mud. I cannot stand her as she is evil and rotten to the core.
She takes delight in stirring the pot.
Evil, evil witch, from the depths of hell.

Lol - why don't you tell us what you really think?

"double, double, toil and trouble,
Eye of Fairfax, Ear of shite
Tell me vicious words tonight
That I may curse and rant and rail
Give me unsubstantiated tale!"

Apologies to the Bard