Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
I want to come out and defend Freo's song. In the group-think world of AFL commentary - it is commonplace to bag their song.
To me this is close minded. It is meant to be a sea-shanty. People need to get their hand around that. As soon as people dont hear a 'catchy little ditty' they tap their feet to - then they just say 'oh its sh*t'. But I like the sea shanty concept. Its is about the old school hard labour of workers pulling and pushing in tandem on a ship. It is about hard labour and team work. It is appropriate for the port city. It has more relevance to the actual team than most other songs. They need to slow it down. But once you get the concept of what is a sea shanty is - it makes sense and is pretty good. Sadly the footy commentators are too closed minded to follow the idea.
dragit wrote:Absolutely slaughtering collingwood tonight... Kicking off with a lazy 300-odd percentage.
In the words of Jason Gram.... Coached by a genius.
Is that multiple Premiership coach Lyon you are talking about?
No its the coach that has Fremantle sitting on top of the ladder after an opening round away match at Etihad stadium.
Apparently not that good.
Its an easy job transforming a laughing stock of a football club into a feared, respected, consistent team that now wins on the road - In less than two years.
A coach that makes the most tangible difference to any team I have witnessed over a ten year period. The most influence, over a continually period of time.
That's why he is on the big bucks now! Without a release clause.
Stephen Theodore wrote:Bottom line is, he has transferred Freo in the space of two seasons from pretenders to contenders.
Anyone on here who can't admit he's a very good coach should remove the blinkers.
He's a brilliant coach. Doesn't mean we can't see some flaws, perhaps fatal flaws on grand final day. Its the closest thing to a cult in football I've seen, with all players having ruthlessly defined roles and Ross' "bubble" where he controls what comes out of the club. But cults often explode in the end due to pent up feelings from being so regimented and dehumanised. Lyon has little concept of pacing his team throughout the year. He runs his machine at full steam all year, physically and mentally exhausting the players and then wonders why some players melt down on the most intense day of the year and tighten up like they are terrified of disapproval from the master.
If we kick 1 more point in 2010 decider then Magpies would be talked about as the biggest wasted club now in a rebuild and would be laughed at for sacking Mick.
We get rid of Dal, McEvoy, Goddard and we are a basket case, yet they got rid of Shaw, Thomas, Jolly, Didak, yet are awesomely rebuilding.
Lets say we won the bloody thing in 09 or 10, we would still be in the same place right now, keen to rebuild,