Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
Strange how bigmart is nearly always on the ball and now we have another poster prepared to reply with one hand under the table alah p66...BringBackMadDog wrote:You should change your Nick to Kmart because your posts are the second rate sh*t that you would find thereBigMart wrote:Correct - Why hasn't anyone defended Raph yet....we must agree he was disgusting....he was WOG by a long way... he made ridiculous errors...
Correct - Milne would be second in those stakes....13 possesions - 8 clangers
Correct - Sam Fisher and Lenny Hayes 10 clangers
Correct - Andrew McQualter 3 kicks...two tackles...not enough for a defensive fwd
Correct - Justin Koschitke....well
Correct - Michael Gardiner....7 possesions
Correct - Zac Dawson who was on Ebert leading up to HT for 5 mins whilst he took 3 marks on the lead...Zac stood the mark in all of them...prompting the commentators to say a move needs to bemade...
My opinion - Zac Dawson has not played well since R18 2009....and should thank Jason Blake for saving his arse most of the time
Correct - Gwilt 18 possesions as a lead up presenting fwd....4 tackles
Correct - Schnieder 24 and 3 goals...top game
Correct - Montagna 36 and Dal 18 and 4 tackles 4 clearances OK
Correct - Eddy used it well for his 18
Correct - Peak 18 and not many errors
Correct - Goddard...some very creative use
Correct - Blake and Baker solid as always
Correct - Gilbert...24 and 10 marks (2 contetsed) as an attacking HB..he did turn 4 over, but does take high risks with the footy..and had one mis-kick...Gilbert not only wins contested ball but gives drive...he is heading towards elite defender IMO
Why is he nearly always on the ball. He said to his own post he was correct. Not many if any others aparty from you have said he is correct. Anyway how can you be correct when it is only an opinion of players. Obviously Bigmart lacks a bit of confidence in his posts if he has to say his own post is correct.BallBanger wrote:Strange how bigmart is nearly always on the ball and now we have another poster prepared to reply with one hand under the table alah p66...BringBackMadDog wrote:You should change your Nick to Kmart because your posts are the second rate sh*t that you would find thereBigMart wrote:Correct - Why hasn't anyone defended Raph yet....we must agree he was disgusting....he was WOG by a long way... he made ridiculous errors...
Correct - Milne would be second in those stakes....13 possesions - 8 clangers
Correct - Sam Fisher and Lenny Hayes 10 clangers
Correct - Andrew McQualter 3 kicks...two tackles...not enough for a defensive fwd
Correct - Justin Koschitke....well
Correct - Michael Gardiner....7 possesions
Correct - Zac Dawson who was on Ebert leading up to HT for 5 mins whilst he took 3 marks on the lead...Zac stood the mark in all of them...prompting the commentators to say a move needs to bemade...
My opinion - Zac Dawson has not played well since R18 2009....and should thank Jason Blake for saving his arse most of the time
Correct - Gwilt 18 possesions as a lead up presenting fwd....4 tackles
Correct - Schnieder 24 and 3 goals...top game
Correct - Montagna 36 and Dal 18 and 4 tackles 4 clearances OK
Correct - Eddy used it well for his 18
Correct - Peak 18 and not many errors
Correct - Goddard...some very creative use
Correct - Blake and Baker solid as always
Correct - Gilbert...24 and 10 marks (2 contetsed) as an attacking HB..he did turn 4 over, but does take high risks with the footy..and had one mis-kick...Gilbert not only wins contested ball but gives drive...he is heading towards elite defender IMO
i hope it felt good
Are you for real?plugger66 wrote:Why is he nearly always on the ball. He said to his own post he was correct. Not many if any others aparty from you have said he is correct. Anyway how can you be correct when it is only an opinion of players. Obviously Bigmart lacks a bit of confidence in his posts if he has to say his own post is correct.BallBanger wrote:Strange how bigmart is nearly always on the ball and now we have another poster prepared to reply with one hand under the table alah p66...BringBackMadDog wrote:You should change your Nick to Kmart because your posts are the second rate sh*t that you would find thereBigMart wrote:Correct - Why hasn't anyone defended Raph yet....we must agree he was disgusting....he was WOG by a long way... he made ridiculous errors...
Correct - Milne would be second in those stakes....13 possesions - 8 clangers
Correct - Sam Fisher and Lenny Hayes 10 clangers
Correct - Andrew McQualter 3 kicks...two tackles...not enough for a defensive fwd
Correct - Justin Koschitke....well
Correct - Michael Gardiner....7 possesions
Correct - Zac Dawson who was on Ebert leading up to HT for 5 mins whilst he took 3 marks on the lead...Zac stood the mark in all of them...prompting the commentators to say a move needs to bemade...
My opinion - Zac Dawson has not played well since R18 2009....and should thank Jason Blake for saving his arse most of the time
Correct - Gwilt 18 possesions as a lead up presenting fwd....4 tackles
Correct - Schnieder 24 and 3 goals...top game
Correct - Montagna 36 and Dal 18 and 4 tackles 4 clearances OK
Correct - Eddy used it well for his 18
Correct - Peak 18 and not many errors
Correct - Goddard...some very creative use
Correct - Blake and Baker solid as always
Correct - Gilbert...24 and 10 marks (2 contetsed) as an attacking HB..he did turn 4 over, but does take high risks with the footy..and had one mis-kick...Gilbert not only wins contested ball but gives drive...he is heading towards elite defender IMO
i hope it felt good
Excellent comeback. Do you actually have any idea at all.BallBanger wrote:Are you for real?plugger66 wrote:Why is he nearly always on the ball. He said to his own post he was correct. Not many if any others aparty from you have said he is correct. Anyway how can you be correct when it is only an opinion of players. Obviously Bigmart lacks a bit of confidence in his posts if he has to say his own post is correct.BallBanger wrote:Strange how bigmart is nearly always on the ball and now we have another poster prepared to reply with one hand under the table alah p66...BringBackMadDog wrote:You should change your Nick to Kmart because your posts are the second rate sh*t that you would find thereBigMart wrote:Correct - Why hasn't anyone defended Raph yet....we must agree he was disgusting....he was WOG by a long way... he made ridiculous errors...
Correct - Milne would be second in those stakes....13 possesions - 8 clangers
Correct - Sam Fisher and Lenny Hayes 10 clangers
Correct - Andrew McQualter 3 kicks...two tackles...not enough for a defensive fwd
Correct - Justin Koschitke....well
Correct - Michael Gardiner....7 possesions
Correct - Zac Dawson who was on Ebert leading up to HT for 5 mins whilst he took 3 marks on the lead...Zac stood the mark in all of them...prompting the commentators to say a move needs to bemade...
My opinion - Zac Dawson has not played well since R18 2009....and should thank Jason Blake for saving his arse most of the time
Correct - Gwilt 18 possesions as a lead up presenting fwd....4 tackles
Correct - Schnieder 24 and 3 goals...top game
Correct - Montagna 36 and Dal 18 and 4 tackles 4 clearances OK
Correct - Eddy used it well for his 18
Correct - Peak 18 and not many errors
Correct - Goddard...some very creative use
Correct - Blake and Baker solid as always
Correct - Gilbert...24 and 10 marks (2 contetsed) as an attacking HB..he did turn 4 over, but does take high risks with the footy..and had one mis-kick...Gilbert not only wins contested ball but gives drive...he is heading towards elite defender IMO
i hope it felt good
Maybe thats why you umpired..no life narrow vision and like to be in control of something in your pathetic little life..
Oh he's so on the ball, we lose 1 game by 10 points and he basically hangs the entire side. Its over-reactionary drivel thats what it isBallBanger wrote:Strange how bigmart is nearly always on the ball and now we have another poster prepared to reply with one hand under the table alah p66...BringBackMadDog wrote:You should change your Nick to Kmart because your posts are the second rate sh*t that you would find thereBigMart wrote:Correct - Why hasn't anyone defended Raph yet....we must agree he was disgusting....he was WOG by a long way... he made ridiculous errors...
Correct - Milne would be second in those stakes....13 possesions - 8 clangers
Correct - Sam Fisher and Lenny Hayes 10 clangers
Correct - Andrew McQualter 3 kicks...two tackles...not enough for a defensive fwd
Correct - Justin Koschitke....well
Correct - Michael Gardiner....7 possesions
Correct - Zac Dawson who was on Ebert leading up to HT for 5 mins whilst he took 3 marks on the lead...Zac stood the mark in all of them...prompting the commentators to say a move needs to bemade...
My opinion - Zac Dawson has not played well since R18 2009....and should thank Jason Blake for saving his arse most of the time
Correct - Gwilt 18 possesions as a lead up presenting fwd....4 tackles
Correct - Schnieder 24 and 3 goals...top game
Correct - Montagna 36 and Dal 18 and 4 tackles 4 clearances OK
Correct - Eddy used it well for his 18
Correct - Peak 18 and not many errors
Correct - Goddard...some very creative use
Correct - Blake and Baker solid as always
Correct - Gilbert...24 and 10 marks (2 contetsed) as an attacking HB..he did turn 4 over, but does take high risks with the footy..and had one mis-kick...Gilbert not only wins contested ball but gives drive...he is heading towards elite defender IMO
i hope it felt good
You are WRONG... WRONG, WRONG, WRONG.He made as many errors as possesions....he missed a target 9 meters away which was not marking distance anyway....he fumbled more than I have seen an AFL player before....worse game of his career...and thats saying something...
You are wrong.Raph clarke 13 disposals, 1 free against and 2 clangers
compare that to
lenny hayes 23 disposals, 4 free's against and 7 clangers (nearly 50% mistakes)
stephen milne 13 disposals, 3 free's against and 8 clangers
the two rucks had 13 disposals between them!
And you're just another scapegoating Lenny Hayes hater who probably shouts "RAPIST!" at Milney from over the fence.bigred wrote:You are WRONG... WRONG, WRONG, WRONG.He made as many errors as possesions....he missed a target 9 meters away which was not marking distance anyway....he fumbled more than I have seen an AFL player before....worse game of his career...and thats saying something...
Taken from another thread, strangely enough titled: "Lets not let facts get in the way"..
You are wrong.Raph clarke 13 disposals, 1 free against and 2 clangers
compare that to
lenny hayes 23 disposals, 4 free's against and 7 clangers (nearly 50% mistakes)
stephen milne 13 disposals, 3 free's against and 8 clangers
the two rucks had 13 disposals between them!
And just another scapegoating Raph hater.
it's a confidence thing. personally i wouldn't play him as a defender. release him to the wing or half forward or an on ball roll where he can use his creativity.BigMart wrote:he is like a deer in headlights, more concerned about not stuffing up, than succeeding ... he is like a fielder in cricket who is praying the ball does not come his way ... and guess what happens?
Wow...big assumption there, might just want to retract that post tiger.Beej wrote:And you're just another scapegoating Lenny Hayes hater who probably shouts "RAPIST!" at Milney from over the fence.bigred wrote:You are WRONG... WRONG, WRONG, WRONG.He made as many errors as possesions....he missed a target 9 meters away which was not marking distance anyway....he fumbled more than I have seen an AFL player before....worse game of his career...and thats saying something...
Taken from another thread, strangely enough titled: "Lets not let facts get in the way"..
You are wrong.Raph clarke 13 disposals, 1 free against and 2 clangers
compare that to
lenny hayes 23 disposals, 4 free's against and 7 clangers (nearly 50% mistakes)
stephen milne 13 disposals, 3 free's against and 8 clangers
the two rucks had 13 disposals between them!
And just another scapegoating Raph hater.
Hilarious.
You are a moron.Beej wrote:
And you're just another scapegoating Lenny Hayes hater who probably shouts "RAPIST!" at Milney from over the fence.
Hilarious.
Haha I love it how Milne is open slather on this site yet when Raph is criticised up jumps this sanctimonious twat and the rest of the guardians in his defence.bigred wrote:You are a moron.Beej wrote:
And you're just another scapegoating Lenny Hayes hater who probably shouts "RAPIST!" at Milney from over the fence.
Hilarious.
Yes you. I call you a moron.
You have no idea who I am, what I stand for and obviously my history following this club.
You are a buffoon and a halfwit.
Another internet hero.
I played the man did I. Did I actually call you a name like you did to me. Cant handle responses to your posts then dont post. And then say i have a high opinion of myself. You write a post critisizing half the side and then say you are correct and when people challenge you , you crack it. I reckon your the one with a high opinion of yourself. By the way didnt you quit this forum some time last year?BigMart wrote:I wrote a post
and the I backed it up with some stats to prove my point...simple
Knobs like P66 took it offensively...and played the man and not the ball..he just doesn't like the fact i critisise sometimes...and am occasionally right..not always...p66 is nothing more than a smartarse who has such a high opininion of himself he tries to humiliate posters rather than debate issues with them....
Did anyone acknowledge that I found as many positives as negatives...and praised a couple of my whipping boys...Gwilt/Eddy
BTW - I believe many of the players I bagged have continuing issues....and only one eyed supporters cannot see why they are roundly critisised
Milne - out of the dome
Zac - takes the eye off the ball and gets out bodied
Kosi - too slow off the mark and turning
Raph - does not play with enough intensity.
Mini - has not enough hurt factor
Gardiner - cumbersome
and these are not on off issues
statistically backed up
The forum would be poorer for bigmarts insights but on the other hand if you p66 were to quit many many forumites would be happyplugger66 wrote:I played the man did I. Did I actually call you a name like you did to me. Cant handle responses to your posts then dont post. And then say i have a high opinion of myself. You write a post critisizing half the side and then say you are correct and when people challenge you , you crack it. I reckon your the one with a high opinion of yourself. By the way didnt you quit this forum some time last year?BigMart wrote:I wrote a post
and the I backed it up with some stats to prove my point...simple
Knobs like P66 took it offensively...and played the man and not the ball..he just doesn't like the fact i critisise sometimes...and am occasionally right..not always...p66 is nothing more than a smartarse who has such a high opininion of himself he tries to humiliate posters rather than debate issues with them....
Did anyone acknowledge that I found as many positives as negatives...and praised a couple of my whipping boys...Gwilt/Eddy
BTW - I believe many of the players I bagged have continuing issues....and only one eyed supporters cannot see why they are roundly critisised
Milne - out of the dome
Zac - takes the eye off the ball and gets out bodied
Kosi - too slow off the mark and turning
Raph - does not play with enough intensity.
Mini - has not enough hurt factor
Gardiner - cumbersome
and these are not on off issues
statistically backed up
You are 100% correct Ballbanger & I and I am sure many others agree with you - we are POORER for BigMarts insights.BallBanger wrote:The forum would be poorer for bigmarts insights but on the other hand if you p66 were to quit many many forumites would be happyplugger66 wrote:I played the man did I. Did I actually call you a name like you did to me. Cant handle responses to your posts then dont post. And then say i have a high opinion of myself. You write a post critisizing half the side and then say you are correct and when people challenge you , you crack it. I reckon your the one with a high opinion of yourself. By the way didnt you quit this forum some time last year?BigMart wrote:I wrote a post
and the I backed it up with some stats to prove my point...simple
Knobs like P66 took it offensively...and played the man and not the ball..he just doesn't like the fact i critisise sometimes...and am occasionally right..not always...p66 is nothing more than a smartarse who has such a high opininion of himself he tries to humiliate posters rather than debate issues with them....
Did anyone acknowledge that I found as many positives as negatives...and praised a couple of my whipping boys...Gwilt/Eddy
BTW - I believe many of the players I bagged have continuing issues....and only one eyed supporters cannot see why they are roundly critisised
Milne - out of the dome
Zac - takes the eye off the ball and gets out bodied
Kosi - too slow off the mark and turning
Raph - does not play with enough intensity.
Mini - has not enough hurt factor
Gardiner - cumbersome
and these are not on off issues
statistically backed up
You have seen the light !
