Teams Round 20

[redwhite&blackblood]

I would have brought in Phelps and Rice both born winners with a ton of gold.

[bobmurray]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

[plugger66]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

[bobmurray]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

I'm not going by what anybody else says in this instance,i'm going by what i've seen and i've seen a lack of real depth and talent in a host of positions....

[maverick]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

You're not wrong there

[plugger66]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

I'm not going by what anybody else says in this instance,i'm going by what i've seen and i've seen a lack of real depth and talent in a host of positions....

Did mean you in this instance just used your post to make a point.

[bobmurray]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

I'm not going by what anybody else says in this instance,i'm going by what i've seen and i've seen a lack of real depth and talent in a host of positions....

Did mean you in this instance just used your post to make a point.

Yep......what did you just do with your post...not much really

[plugger66]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

I'm not going by what anybody else says in this instance,i'm going by what i've seen and i've seen a lack of real depth and talent in a host of positions....

Did mean you in this instance just used your post to make a point.

Yep......what did you just do with your post...not much really

Left out the not. Sorry about that.

[saintbob]

Weak as piss, Ross Lyon

Milne- Just doesn't get a kick interstate

Dal Santo- Doesn't seem to care whether he gets a kick or not.

These 2 should've been the first ones dropped!!!!!

[perfectionist]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

I'm not going by what anybody else says in this instance,i'm going by what i've seen and i've seen a lack of real depth and talent in a host of positions....

Did mean you in this instance just used your post to make a point.

Yep......what did you just do with your post...not much really

Left out the not. Sorry about that.

Just thought I'd add another layer to see what it looked like. Got no idea what the content is. Hang on, that's the aim of the game isn't it?

[battye]

Simply can't complain about Geary been dropped


done SFA in the last 2 weeks, and his little act in the forward pocket while the game was in the balance was very humorous, luckily probably our 3rd or 4th best player came through and took a big contested mark in BJ

Well put

[WayneJudson42]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

Nah, I doubt that very much. WHen u see coaches in the box, with their PCs... they're actually looking at this forum, and saying "let's see how badly we can p1ss the supporters off with our next rotation".

[WayneJudson42]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.

Have to agree about the lack of depth,i hope the coaches are discussing the problem and working out what they need to player wise to overcome it,to some extent at least.....

How can there be lack of depth. We were told on here my a lot of people that our depth this year was the best ever. That was when we were winning the practice games. Its amazing how bad your depth looks when you are losing.

I'm not going by what anybody else says in this instance,i'm going by what i've seen and i've seen a lack of real depth and talent in a host of positions....

Did mean you in this instance just used your post to make a point.

Yep......what did you just do with your post...not much really

Left out the not. Sorry about that.

F***, you're really splitting hairs tonite P66! Have you been on the Sanctimonious Ball Breaking pills today?

Depth in the sense of young kids, or lack thereof.

We have depth... but it just ain't deep as we thought it would be.

[saintspremiers]

I would play either gardiner or ferg as a lead up forward and Birss so 2 changes. cannot see Schneider beig dropped maybe gwilt but I doubt it.

Schneider is a safe as houses, unless he's injured....didn't he kick 3 goals last week?

I'd never drop a player who has kicked 3 goals the previous week!

Raph is a good chance of playing - has been busting a gut for Casey for several weeks now and deserves a chance.

Interesting to see Armo is on the outer, not even a chance of playing.

[saintspremiers]

Weak as piss, Ross Lyon

Milne- Just doesn't get a kick interstate

Dal Santo- Doesn't seem to care whether he gets a kick or not.

These 2 should've been the first ones dropped!!!!!

quite true, and when they were both dropped last time we beat Freo, albiet by a skinny margin in a crap game in MELBOURNE not PERTH!!!

[hotdish]

In: C Gardiner, R Clarke
Out: Aaron Fiora (suspended); Jarryn Geary (omitted)

ST KILDA
B: Sean Dempster, Sam Fisher, Jason Gram
HB: Brendon Goddard, Max Hudghton, Jason Blake
C: Sam Gilbert, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes
HF: Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt, Robert Eddy
F: Clint Jones, Justin Koschitzke, Stephen Milne
Foll: Steven King, Andrew McQualter, Leigh Montagna
Int: Adam Schneider, James Gwilt, Charlie Gardiner, Raphael Clarke
Emg: Matthew Ferguson, Shane Birss, Michael Rix

[Solar]

In: C Gardiner, R Clarke
Out: Aaron Fiora (suspended); Jarryn Geary (omitted)

ST KILDA
B: Sean Dempster, Sam Fisher, Jason Gram
HB: Brendon Goddard, Max Hudghton, Jason Blake
C: Sam Gilbert, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes
HF: Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt, Robert Eddy
F: Clint Jones, Justin Koschitzke, Stephen Milne
Foll: Steven King, Andrew McQualter, Leigh Montagna
Int: Adam Schneider, James Gwilt, Charlie Gardiner, Raphael Clarke
Emg: Matthew Ferguson, Shane Birss, Michael Rix

at least we have enough lead up forwards....

welcome back raph, hope you go forward and kick some goals

[st_Trav_ofWA]

In: C Gardiner, R Clarke
Out: Aaron Fiora (suspended); Jarryn Geary (omitted)

ST KILDA
B: Sean Dempster, Sam Fisher, Jason Gram
HB: Brendon Goddard, Max Hudghton, Jason Blake
C: Sam Gilbert, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes
HF: Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt, Robert Eddy
F: Clint Jones, Justin Koschitzke, Stephen Milne
Foll: Steven King, Andrew McQualter, Leigh Montagna
Int: Adam Schneider, James Gwilt, Charlie Gardiner, Raphael Clarke
Emg: Matthew Ferguson, Shane Birss, Michael Rix

i reckon there maybe a late withdrawal cant say too much but i think a listed 22 player wont be playin

[3rd generation saint]

Well they picked a third forward in C Gardiner or R Clarke.

Actually R Clarke can play defence (not as good as I would like) and this might release Goddard forward.

Let's remember when we were really good 04/05 we had three big forwards, Gehrig, Roo and Hamill.

That gave us three targets to kick to and all them back then could also be defensive, especially Hamill.

We need to find that mix again, if not this season, than next season.

Having three mobile marking options up forward stretches defences and brings guys like Milne, Schneider etc into the game.

On a different matter, I'd rather watch the Olympics than Port vs Collingwood tonight, going to miss all the swimming heats!