max n goose incident

matrix · Post: # 555578Post **matrix** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 2:59am

max wasnt the only one who gave him a spray....
a few choice words came from my mouth as well.....

goose has seriously lost the standard needed to play at afl level
previous injury or not.....the poor bloke just cant seem to get into it

ratismeat · Post: # 555614Post **ratismeat** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 4:32am

In all honesty the game was pretty much going down the toilet by then anyway - i don't think some kind, constructive, gentlemanly words were going to help. At least Max looked like he wanted a win, Goose looked stoned.

Spinner · Post: # 555618Post **Spinner** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 4:46am

'bout the only ounce of passion I saw all night.

But it really shouldn't get to that. Most are right, it sends a pretty pathetic message to the opposition.

But If it had to be done, it had to be done.

jonesy · Post: # 555636Post **jonesy** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 5:22am

Good on Max! All his efforts over the years are going to go in veign unfortunatly.

Maguire is finished as a footballer at this level. If someone is stupid enough to give us a trade at years end then we snaffle it up,don't think they'll be that stupid but

perfectionist · Sun 27 Apr 2008 9:10am

Max going crook at someone because his opponent took a mark? That would be right. Time for Max to think of the team and not just himself - too old - should give it away - never been any good anyway. Can't kick or mark or handball. Just no good. Bye Max.

lovin_dal_santo · Sun 27 Apr 2008 9:11am

Loved it! Max has been playing the game long enough (and playing the game well enough) to hand out a spray when he feels justified. In Matty's defence, probably couldn't have done much else in the situation, but Max is our most senior defender and has a right to criticise when he sees fit.

I am sure neither of them have any hard feelings today.

(To those saying Matt is finished, he snapped his leg in half.. it took Nathan Brown a very long time to recover.. he will be fine!)

starsign · Post: # 555663Post **starsign** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 10:10am

(To those saying Matt is finished, he snapped his leg in half.. it took Nathan Brown a very long time to recover.. he will be fine!)
_________________

have to watch it again but at the time i got the impression max was trying to cover his man and gooses as well
dont blame him for the serve one bit ,as hes been playing his guts out there every week , and goose has been purely making up the numbers
It was a case of the straw that finally broke the camels back i recon

we have been playing one man short down back since Goose returned
Hope your right with the Brown c/f but its time he was put into the magoos
and one thing i wil say about GT he didnt tolerate blokes not putting in
Capuano!!!
Goose wasnt the only one who should have been awarded an Anzac medal for going missing in action , but enough is enough for him!

westy · Post: # 555738Post **westy** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 12:32pm

How many players gave Max a public tongue lashing every time he screwed up week after week a couple of years ago? Nobody!! I love Max like a son, but to behave like that in front of his team mates is unprofessional particularly when Goose obviously isn't fit. It is just a relief that such a disgraceful effort at playing football did not get wide TV coverage. And as for that horrible jumper. What mental cripple designed that?

mad saint guy · Sun 27 Apr 2008 12:40pm

perfectionist wrote:Max going crook at someone because his opponent took a mark? That would be right. Time for Max to think of the team and not just himself - too old - should give it away - never been any good anyway. Can't kick or mark or handball. Just no good. Bye Max.

Maguire let Tredrea stand still by himself inside 50 and take an uncontested mark. If that doesn't warrant a spray for a defender then I don't know what does.

asiu · Post: # 555744Post **asiu** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 12:43pm

I think Goose should listen to anything Max Hudghton has to say.

ditto

i loved it

max is

Armoooo · Post: # 555766Post **Armoooo** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 1:38pm

I think there should be an emergency meeting this week, Harvey, Hudghton, Burke, Leowe and Frawley need to put these boys in their place, make them realise that premierships aren't just a matter of when.

If they are not willing to put in that little bit more after hearing from those guys they don't deserve a flag.

Last night I saw Port Adelaide give a rabble countless oppurtunities to steal a win, they were jumping into each other, hitting the post from 15m out, shanking kicks into the centre, being cleaned bowled in the goal square. Yet we had at least 16 players out there who didn't care about winning. It is just not good enough, I would rather see 16 VFL hacks out there being completely outclassed as long as they put in 100%, the last few weeks we have had absolutely no passion and no pride in the jumper, I think we may have to take off the St.Kilda badge for a few weeks until they earn it back

Saints43 · Post: # 555774Post **Saints43** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 2:03pm

mad saint guy wrote:
perfectionist wrote:Max going crook at someone because his opponent took a mark? That would be right. Time for Max to think of the team and not just himself - too old - should give it away - never been any good anyway. Can't kick or mark or handball. Just no good. Bye Max.
Maguire let Tredrea stand still by himself inside 50 and take an uncontested mark. If that doesn't warrant a spray for a defender then I don't know what does.

Max had left Motlop. Max's oppenent at the time to try and cover Tredrea.

Tredrea was Goose's opponent.

Notice that Goose didn't say a word...

perfectionist... hilarious.

MikeSheahan · Sun 27 Apr 2008 2:38pm

If you look closely at the replay, it clearly shows that Maguire in fact shot the first words out. Not a great display by the two defenders, and should've been kept for the dressing room. Ross Lyon would'nt be too happy with it.

clarky449 · Post: # 555835Post **clarky449** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 4:16pm

Well today on the flight home Maxy and goose were infront of me and they were fine so i think it was a spr of the moment

mischa · Post: # 555870Post **mischa** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 5:11pm

Definitely spur of the moment-just general frustration with the way we're playing. We need to take a leaf out of WB, Hawthorn and Geelong playbooks. Still it'll give plenty of ammo to Carolying Wilting and Robert Scumbag on their respective programs to bag the crap out of Goose (again) and probably blame him for the loss

Smirking twits.

saintbrat · Post: # 555895Post **saintbrat** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 5:49pm

clarky449 wrote:Well today on the flight home Maxy and goose were infront of me and they were fine so i think it was a spr of the moment

from what I have observed- generally the team are better at seeing the big picture and realising that pressure brings reactions

and for those who haven't seen the exchnge-it doesn't show the lead up - there is vision on foxsports

http://video2.foxsports.com.au/video.ph ... 52&id=7174

groupie1 · Post: # 555919Post **groupie1** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 6:43pm

I think it was in the third quarter

your momma · Post: # 555930Post **your momma** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 6:53pm

I would be that frustrated if i was max at that point at the game

focusing on Max, not Goose atm...great to see max with some instructions and spray a wake up call for his teamates, hes a great leadership player, which Goose will learn from, especially after he completely recoveres from his injury.

i noticed Goddard was doing a bit of instructon ordering good to see (not in Max's behaviour tho)

your momma · Post: # 555936Post **your momma** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 6:57pm

perfectionist wrote:Max going crook at someone because his opponent took a mark? That would be right. Time for Max to think of the team and not just himself - too old - should give it away - never been any good anyway. Can't kick or mark or handball. Just no good. Bye Max.

O_o

The_Dud · Post: # 555963Post **The_Dud** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 7:30pm

perfectionist wrote:Max going crook at someone because his opponent took a mark? That would be right. Time for Max to think of the team and not just himself - too old - should give it away - never been any good anyway. Can't kick or mark or handball. Just no good. Bye Max.

if you are being serious, then i think its about time you gave it away

bye

WaggaSaint · Post: # 555992Post **WaggaSaint** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 8:00pm

Given that Goose isn't 100% at the moment, what does everyone think of throwing him up forward next week?
Kosi is going to be needed in the ruck, maybe some time up forward so that he can get his hands on it a bit himself, might do him the world of good.
We all know the lad is capable of taking a big grab and is a great kick. Would do his confidence a great help, and also mix up the forward line a bit since it isn't working at the moment.

The spray - justified, but unprofessional. Proves that we're certainly not playing as a team at the moment.

St DAC · Post: # 556009Post **St DAC** » Sun 27 Apr 2008 8:23pm

perfectionist wrote:Max going crook at someone because his opponent took a mark? That would be right. Time for Max to think of the team and not just himself - too old - should give it away - never been any good anyway. Can't kick or mark or handball. Just no good. Bye Max.

Have you always been this stupid, or have you reached new heights?

max n goose incident

max n goose incident

guy keeps asking when it was