Votes v Dons

[bangaulegend]

5. Ryder
3. Billings
2. Battle
2. Jones
1. Marshall
1. Coffield
1. Membrey

[saynta]

5. Ryder
3. Billings
2. Jones
1. Battle
1. Steele
1. Marshall
1. Coffield
1. Hill.

[MCG-Unit]

3 - Battle
3 - Billings
3 - Marshall
3 - Ryder
1 - Clark
1 - Jones
1 - King

[terry smith rules]

5 Ryder
4 billings
3 Roma
2 Coffield
1 zj

[Scollop]

I’d love to see DownAtThe Junction do his Impact Scores for our game against the Dons. A few have mentioned how even the contribution was. I’m happy to go a little left field with my votes.

2 Paddy
2 Roma
2 Coff
2 Jones
2 Billings
2 King
1 Josh Battle
1 Hill
1 Long

Membrey was good, Bytel, Seb and Sincs and Jack Steele were all ok, but I think Long was our second best backman. Longy loves to contest and his defending was very good. Not sure what game people are watching, but his disposal and decision making also important in the game against the druggies

[SemperFidelis]

4. Jones
4. Paddy
3. JB
2. Battle
1. Coff
1. Hill

[Secret Kiel]

I’d love to see DownAtThe Junction do his Impact Scores for our game against the Dons. A few have mentioned how even the contribution was. I’m happy to go a little left field with my votes.

2 Paddy
2 Roma
2 Coff
2 Jones
2 Billings
2 King
1 Josh Battle
1 Hill
1 Long

Membrey was good, Bytel, Seb and Sincs and Jack Steele were all ok, but I think Long was our second best backman. Longy loves to contest and his defending was very good. Not sure what game people are watching, but his disposal and decision making also important in the game against the druggies

I've watched the game again and I think I might have short changed Coff.

[Sainter_Dad]

1. Coffield
2. Battle
3. Jones
4. Marshall
5. Ryder

Are you giving Coff best on or Ryder? At this point I have you voting for Ryder as being best.

[spert]

5. Ryder (probably the only 4 quarter effort from our players)
4. Marshall
3. Jones
2. Coff
1. Billings

Had to mark the midfield down a bit as they let Essendon run all over them in the third.

[Sanctorum]

In a lacklustre game there was no individual player that stood out for me but I felt ZJ had the greatest impact with his fierce attack on the ball - while the consensus is that Jack Steele become the next skipper, I wouldn't mind at all if Zak got the job, he leads from the front and can't help but inspire his team mates on game day, he's the Saints' most aggressive, attacking player!!

5 Zak Jones
4 Paddy Ryder
3 Nick Coffield
2 Josh Battle
1 Jack Billings

[Bernard Shakey]

Jones
Battle
Billings
Coffield
Hill

[Yorkeys]

Hi Y'all votes to MC Ben and DJ Hunter for best handshake routine from defenders - who don't get to celebrate goals. Dermy award leaders at this point.

[Sainter_Dad]

91 Ryder
82 Jones
66 Battle
58 Coffield
57 Billings
47 Marshall
16 King
10 Hill
9 Membrey
7 Wilkie
3 Clark
2 Long
1 Ross
1 Steele

Therefore
5 Ryder
4 Jones
3 Battle
2 Coffield
1 Billings

[freely]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

[Ghost Like]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

[Secret Kiel]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

We should go to a game together one day so I can teach you about the non TV version of footy.

[Ghost Like]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

We should go to a game together one day so I can teach you about the non TV version of footy.

Ahhh, so you were up there watching it live? If not, then the one vote to Ross can only be described as mischievous.

Interesting, that some genuine St Kilda supporters were there yet could not squeeze him in.

I'd love to enjoy your wisdom at a match but it appears you'll be busy educating the rest on this forum. I can organise a guest pass for you.

[Secret Kiel]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

We should go to a game together one day so I can teach you about the non TV version of footy.

Ahhh, so you were up there watching it live? If not, then the one vote to Ross can only be described as mischievous.

Interesting, that some genuine St Kilda supporters were there yet could not squeeze him in.

I'd love to enjoy your wisdom at a match but it appears you'll be busy educating the rest on this forum. I can organise a guest pass for you.

It's possible the lack of votes from fans in an internet enclave is due to hatred and group think, but mosy likely due to never having played or coached the game thus lacking complete football knowledge. I can get you into the change rooms sometime if you like.

[Ghost Like]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

We should go to a game together one day so I can teach you about the non TV version of footy.

Ahhh, so you were up there watching it live? If not, then the one vote to Ross can only be described as mischievous.

Interesting, that some genuine St Kilda supporters were there yet could not squeeze him in.

I'd love to enjoy your wisdom at a match but it appears you'll be busy educating the rest on this forum. I can organise a guest pass for you.

It's possible the lack of votes from fans in an internet enclave is due to hatred and group think, but mosy likely due to never having played or coached the game thus lacking complete football knowledge. I can get you into the change rooms sometime if you like.

I find that offer completely inappropriate.

[Secret Kiel]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

We should go to a game together one day so I can teach you about the non TV version of footy.

Ahhh, so you were up there watching it live? If not, then the one vote to Ross can only be described as mischievous.

Interesting, that some genuine St Kilda supporters were there yet could not squeeze him in.

I'd love to enjoy your wisdom at a match but it appears you'll be busy educating the rest on this forum. I can organise a guest pass for you.

It's possible the lack of votes from fans in an internet enclave is due to hatred and group think, but mosy likely due to never having played or coached the game thus lacking complete football knowledge. I can get you into the change rooms sometime if you like.

I find that offer completely inappropriate.

Strange and I don't get it but I guess it's hard to make sense when you can't walk away.

[saynta]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

I don't know who gave him a vote but it was not entirely left field. He actually had 16 possessions which was more than 16 of his fellow team mates. Your analogy is a bit harsh imho.

[The_Dud]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

We all know what that vote was given, no one needs to dance around it

He hasn't received any coaches votes this season either after getting 35 last year, so it seems it's not just "an internet enclave" that can see where he's at.

According to SK, "never having played or coached the game thus lacking complete football knowledge" is how he sums up Ratts

But then again, he's got a worse batting average than Chris Martin, so I don't know why we give any time to this troll! haha

[Ghost Like]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

I don't know who gave him a vote but it was not entirely left field. He actually had 16 possessions which was more than 16 of his fellow team mates. Your analogy is a bit harsh imho.

You never struck me as a stats man saynta. Using that rule of thumb, he played a better game than Ryder & Marshall and an infinitely better game than King. Yet still 7 deserved votes in front of him.

The vote for Ross wasn't about his 16 possessions.

[saynta]

Props, Sainter Dad - even when the top 5 are different or different order from the 5 I picked, I always find myself nodding with the results thrown up from this thread.

It is quite good, sometimes votes given can make you shake your head. To give Ross a vote is intriguing. He's a good player but unless it's an encouragement award from a fish n chip shop, it really is taking the p155.

I don't know who gave him a vote but it was not entirely left field. He actually had 16 possessions which was more than 16 of his fellow team mates. Your analogy is a bit harsh imho.

You never struck me as a stats man saynta. Using that rule of thumb, he played a better game than Ryder & Marshall and an infinitely better game than King. Yet still 7 deserved votes in front of him.

The vote for Ross wasn't about his 16 possessions.

No. all I am saying is that the vote given him was not unreasonable. His game wasn't piss poor and was certainly an improvement. As i stated above, not entirely left field.

[Goose is king]

Ross gave Max his first goal.