Team changes against Kangas

mad saint guy · Wed 29 Jun 2011 6:57pm

Stanley or Archer must play. McEvoy needs backup and Dawson sure ain't it. I'd really rather not have Walsh play his first AFL game horribly out of position and outsized as well.

plugger66 · Post: # 1096869Post **plugger66** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 7:11pm

mad saint guy wrote:Stanley or Archer must play. McEvoy needs backup and Dawson sure ain't it. I'd really rather not have Walsh play his first AFL game horribly out of position and outsized as well.

Well Stanley hasnt played for 4 weeks so that wouldnt be doing him to many favours. Archer aint a ruckmans bootlace and hasnt been in great form either. Id rather Mini ruck than either of those 2 this week.

Wrote for Luck · Wed 29 Jun 2011 8:01pm

I think there is more fast development in Walsh than Siposs based on age at this stage. So I would go Walsh in this weekend.

Surely Monty is going to be in? And I would expect Simpkin in too.

For me Gamble and Kosi and Baker will have a rest.

Wild card; Ledger

Hallalj#3 · Post: # 1096889Post **Hallalj#3** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 8:09pm

Fb. Dempster. Walsh. Gilbert

Hb. Gwilt Fisher. Gram

C. Joey Dal Goddard

Hf. Siposs Johnson Lynch

FF Milne Roo Schnider

Rucks. Mac Steven Jones

Int. Ray Ledger peake sub Winmar..

vacuous space · Wed 29 Jun 2011 8:12pm

plugger66 wrote:Id rather Mini ruck than either of those 2 this week.

BOG two weeks in a row as a centre. In the best pretty much every time he's played for Sandy. So we're probably getting to around the time Ross brings him in, plays him forward, he does nothing and is back in the V in a week or two.

At least if we rucked him, he'd be in the centre where he's shown his form. I can't understand why Ross loves playing guys like him and ledger off the ball. Totally wrong skillset. Too small, maybe. It wouldn't kill us to try though.

Bernard Shakey · Wed 29 Jun 2011 10:36pm

millarsaint wrote:I think there is more fast development in Walsh than Siposs based on age at this stage. So I would go Walsh in this weekend.

Surely Monty is going to be in? And I would expect Simpkin in too.

For me Gamble and Kosi and Baker will have a rest.

Wild card; Ledger

Joey wasn't out, so he won't be an in.

Dr Spaceman · Wed 29 Jun 2011 10:46pm

vacuous space wrote:
plugger66 wrote:Id rather Mini ruck than either of those 2 this week.
BOG two weeks in a row as a centre. In the best pretty much every time he's played for Sandy. So we're probably getting to around the time Ross brings him in, plays him forward, he does nothing and is back in the V in a week or two.

At least if we rucked him, he'd be in the centre where he's shown his form. I can't understand why Ross loves playing guys like him and ledger off the ball. Totally wrong skillset. Too small, maybe. It wouldn't kill us to try though.

Mini may very well come in. Ross seems to like him, he's playing very well at Sandy and the senior team is struggling.

However with Armo currently playing that role, and doing it quite well, he's probably keeping #32 out. And I'm sure Ross is keen to have a look at a few more newbies before the year's out.

So my guess is we won't see Mini - at least this week.

SainterK · Post: # 1096979Post **SainterK** » Wed 29 Jun 2011 11:21pm

I think Mini would find it hard to break in, because Armo is playing his role with goals.

After today, I think

Out Kosi, Raph, Gamble
In Walsh, Ledger, Siposs

sasaint · Post: # 1097006Post **sasaint** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 12:06am

Keep it simple

Out Kosi, Gamble
In Walsh, Mini

Walsh as a Forward, backfill ruck
Mini on form.

Bernard Shakey · Thu 30 Jun 2011 12:08am

sasaint wrote:Keep it simple

Out Kosi, Gamble
In Walsh, Mini

Walsh as a Forward, backfill ruck
Mini on form.

What form?

saintbob · Post: # 1097010Post **saintbob** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 12:22am

Hallalj#3 wrote:Fb. Dempster. Walsh. Gilbert

Hb. Gwilt Fisher. Gram

C. Joey Dal Goddard

Hf. Siposs Johnson Lynch

FF Milne Roo Schnider

Rucks. Mac Steven Jones

Int. Ray Ledger peake sub Winmar..

Love the look of this side!!!!

A few different targets up forward and the best thing is Dawson has been omitted.

Would have Baker in at the expence of Gram, who is absolutely finished.

sasaint · Post: # 1097027Post **sasaint** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 8:29am

Bernard Shakey wrote:
sasaint wrote:Keep it simple

Out Kosi, Gamble
In Walsh, Mini

Walsh as a Forward, backfill ruck
Mini on form.
What form?

Round 13 Sandringham

Best Players: A. McQualter, T. Simpkin, R. Clarke, J. Magner, T. LEDGER, M. Marigliani

Round 11 Sandringham

Best Players: A. McQualter, T. Lynch, R. Eddy, D. Polo, J. Magner, T. Walsh

Round 10 Sandringham

Best Players: R. Clarke, C. Irving, A. Smith, A. McQualter, T. Walsh, M. Lourey

bigcarl · Post: # 1097036Post **bigcarl** » Thu 30 Jun 2011 9:24am

sasaint wrote:Round 13 Sandringham

Best Players: A. McQualter, T. Simpkin, R. Clarke, J. Magner, T. LEDGER, M. Marigliani

Round 11 Sandringham

Best Players: A. McQualter, T. Lynch, R. Eddy, D. Polo, J. Magner, T. Walsh

Round 10 Sandringham

Best Players: R. Clarke, C. Irving, A. Smith, A. McQualter, T. Walsh, M. Lourey

That is good form.

To the Sandringham watchers, where has he been playing? Midfield?

Is his form good enough for a recall as a clearance midfielder?