Paul Chapman vs Liam Picken

[R. Harvey 3 votes!]

I know this isn't a direct saints blog but it is saints related. I just watched Paul Chapman going hard at Liam Picken from the bulldogs, similar to the Baker Johnson incidents. He better get sited for something and get some weeks for going for an attack on a player off the ball or it is a joke even though we know it is a joke already! Chapman was doing nothing different to what Baker was doing to Johnson? Lets see what happens?

[Teflon]

theyve already got their man....scumbags.

[stinger]

a backhander to the head followed up with four solid punches the chest and body ...worth a couple imho.....

[35...LEGEND]

Should be looked at..........but um..

[jonesy]

Picken deserves a month off after his dog act on Selwood also.

Dogs are pathetic,flat track bullies,soft as butter,pathetic fragile group

[stinger]

Picken deserves a month off after his dog act on Selwood also.

Dogs are pathetic,flat track bullies,soft as butter,pathetic fragile group

think you will get your wish there too,...maybe 2 weeks though...

[nuttsy]

I'm sure he'll get nothing and we'll all continue to watch the games next week

[Bernard Shakey]

I know this isn't a direct saints blog but it is saints related. I just watched Paul Chapman going hard at Liam Picken from the bulldogs, similar to the Baker Johnson incidents. He better get sited for something and get some weeks for going for an attack on a player off the ball or it is a joke even though we know it is a joke already! Chapman was doing nothing different to what Baker was doing to Johnson? Lets see what happens?

Nothing head high, so nothing to answer for.

Bakes plays with bowling balls anyway, so doesn't need the MRP for holidays anymore.

[chook23]

I know this isn't a direct saints blog but it is saints related. I just watched Paul Chapman going hard at Liam Picken from the bulldogs, similar to the Baker Johnson incidents. He better get sited for something and get some weeks for going for an attack on a player off the ball or it is a joke even though we know it is a joke already! Chapman was doing nothing different to what Baker was doing to Johnson? Lets see what happens?

Nothing head high, so nothing to answer for.
Bakes plays with bowling balls anyway, so doesn't need the MRP for holidays anymore.

2 of bakes shots (charged with) not high (head area)...and did have to answer to MR charge.

[Solar]

In addition I heard on the radio that some carlton players were attacking cousins with his hurt leg?

[Milan Faletic]

Good publicity for his doco.

[Pwoit]

Personally I don’t give stuff about other clubs indiscretions as it doesn’t affect us directly, unless we play them the following week.

All I care about is us winning well this week and doing it with purpose and then moving onto the next game.

It’s all about the St Kilda football club I don’t care about others.

Go Saints - we're moving into the last phase of our season.

[plugger66]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

[ChicagoSaint]

attempting to strijk?

[Solar]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

[Thinline]

Perhaps St Kilda should compile a 'highlights' video of Chapman's behaviour off the ball. You know. Just to help out the MRP and the 'process' generally. The AFL can't expect to see everything. Surely we could be of some assistance as a good 'club citizen' and all round champion of the best interests of the game?

[plugger66]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

[Iceman234]

Personally I don’t give stuff about other clubs indiscretions as it doesn’t affect us directly, unless we play them the following week.

I don't subscribe to this theory, as it can certainly affect us come finals time if those players have carry-over points. Another minor indiscretion the week before a big final and it could rub them out against us.

[Teflon]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

cheers Mahatma.

You keep fighting for the "common good of man" but dont mind the rest of us for pointing out what can only be described as disgraceful hypocrisy.

[plugger66]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

cheers Mahatma.

You keep fighting for the "common good of man" but dont mind the rest of us for pointing out what can only be described as disgraceful hypocrisy.

Yes it must you feel better thinking the world is against us. Well i'd worry about things the Saints can control like winning the GF.

[maverick]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

cheers Mahatma.

You keep fighting for the "common good of man" but dont mind the rest of us for pointing out what can only be described as disgraceful hypocrisy.

Yes it must you feel better thinking the world is against us. Well i'd worry about things the Saints can control like winning the GF.

Well if Chapman missed last year's GF we would have won, but take your point, we won't talk about anything else other than the Saints or what you think is OK.

[Sainternist]

If only Chapman accosted BBB instead and then got his comeuppance.

I don't care to see Chapman get suspended, I would much prefer to see someone knock the stuffing out of him instead

[plugger66]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

cheers Mahatma.

You keep fighting for the "common good of man" but dont mind the rest of us for pointing out what can only be described as disgraceful hypocrisy.

Yes it must you feel better thinking the world is against us. Well i'd worry about things the Saints can control like winning the GF.

Well if Chapman missed last year's GF we would have won, but take your point, we won't talk about anything else other than the Saints or what you think is OK.

Not sure I ever mentioned what others can talk about. I think I only mentioned what is important to me.

[Middo]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

cheers Mahatma.

You keep fighting for the "common good of man" but dont mind the rest of us for pointing out what can only be described as disgraceful hypocrisy.

Yes it must you feel better thinking the world is against us. Well i'd worry about things the Saints can control like winning the GF.

Well if Chapman missed last year's GF we would have won, but take your point, we won't talk about anything else other than the Saints or what you think is OK.

Not sure I ever mentioned what others can talk about. I think I only mentioned what is important to me.

You got anymore holidays coming up ...? So many more interesting chats when you went away ...

[plugger66]

Nothing in the Chapman incident. Not forceful enough contact.

none of bakers were either

Probably not but 2 wrongs doesnt make a right.

cheers Mahatma.

You keep fighting for the "common good of man" but dont mind the rest of us for pointing out what can only be described as disgraceful hypocrisy.

Yes it must you feel better thinking the world is against us. Well i'd worry about things the Saints can control like winning the GF.

Well if Chapman missed last year's GF we would have won, but take your point, we won't talk about anything else other than the Saints or what you think is OK.

Not sure I ever mentioned what others can talk about. I think I only mentioned what is important to me.

You got anymore holidays coming up ...? So many more interesting chats when you went away ...

No.