Good Call Bad Call

[#1GILL]

Time to lighten to mood a bit, and since we don't play for another 6 days let's give Good Call Bad Call a go.

So someone asks a question, and whoever answers asks the next one.

I'll go first:

Kosi will not be in the side come finals, good call bad call?

[Thinline]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

[FQF]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

bad call. too risky of a call. not a ross lyon call.

he was recruited as a forward and we will hardly start experimenting with second game forwards in our back half.

[#1GILL]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

bad call. too risky of a call. not a ross lyon call.

he was recruited as a forward and we will hardly start experimenting with second game forwards in our back half.

You need to throw up a new call.

[FQF]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

bad call. too risky of a call. not a ross lyon call.

he was recruited as a forward and we will hardly start experimenting with second game forwards in our back half.

You need to throw up a new call.

adam schneider as our qualifying final match winner.

[SainterK]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

bad call. too risky of a call. not a ross lyon call.

he was recruited as a forward and we will hardly start experimenting with second game forwards in our back half.

You need to throw up a new call.

adam schneider as our qualifying final match winner.

Good call, thoughtful call, inspired call

Playing some of his best footy the latter half of this year, the bursts in the midfield really suiting him.

Mick Sheahan will be talking an awful lot about Collingwood tonight OTC

[#1GILL]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

bad call. too risky of a call. not a ross lyon call.

he was recruited as a forward and we will hardly start experimenting with second game forwards in our back half.

You need to throw up a new call.

adam schneider as our qualifying final match winner.

Good call, thoughtful call, inspired call

Playing some of his best footy the latter half of this year, the bursts in the midfield really suiting him.

Mick Sheahan will be talking an awful lot about Collingwood tonight OTC

Good Call, obvious call, far too easy call. He will be all over it, although they will find pletny of time to discuss our poor form with Roo coming on.



Lenny deserves a flag just as much as Banger did, good call bad call?

[boneless23]

Bad call because I'm too much of a soft c**k to say otherwise.

Lynch to the backline?

bad call. too risky of a call. not a ross lyon call.

he was recruited as a forward and we will hardly start experimenting with second game forwards in our back half.

You need to throw up a new call.

adam schneider as our qualifying final match winner.

Good call, thoughtful call, inspired call

Playing some of his best footy the latter half of this year, the bursts in the midfield really suiting him.

Mick Sheahan will be talking an awful lot about Collingwood tonight OTC

Good Call, obvious call, far too easy call. He will be all over it, although they will find pletny of time to discuss our poor form with Roo coming on.



Lenny deserves a flag just as much as Banger did, good call bad call?

Good call...heart and soul of the footy club, would love to see him on the podium.

Jimmy Gwilt: the most improved player in the comp.

[FQF]

Good Call, obvious call, far too easy call. He will be all over it, although they will find pletny of time to discuss our poor form with Roo coming on.



Lenny deserves a flag just as much as Banger did, good call bad call?

Bad call, too early call.

Banger went for countless more years without a flag, played in far worse stkilda sides, won two brownlows and yet didn't end up with the ultimate glory.

Lets hope Lenny ends up with all those accolades plus the prized medallion.

Ross Lyon needs to have a few extra tricks in the bag in games that aren't going our way.

[#1GILL]

Good Call, obvious call, far too easy call. He will be all over it, although they will find pletny of time to discuss our poor form with Roo coming on.



Lenny deserves a flag just as much as Banger did, good call bad call?

Bad call, too early call.

Banger went for countless more years without a flag, played in far worse stkilda sides, won two brownlows and yet didn't end up with the ultimate glory.

Lets hope Lenny ends up with all those accolades plus the prized medallion.

Ross Lyon needs to have a few extra tricks in the bag in games that aren't going our way.

Good Call. We don't seem to have much of a plan B..I like how the game opened up in the last 1/4 on Friday, whether that was Ross's doing or just because Essendon went home early, we looked dangerous.

Zac Dawson is a required team member for the finals campaign, GC BC?

[boneless23]

Ross Lyon needs to have a few extra tricks in the bag in games that aren't going our way.

Bad call. Ross has the tricks but I dont think he wants to play them until he needs to.

Mini is vital to our chances in September if he can recapture his '09 forward line pressure

[SaintSimmo]

Mini is vital to our chances in September if he can recapture his '09 forward line pressure

Bad Call, we need more than a one-dimensional small forward in our team, and what he showed in the 2's on the weekend shows that he is a long way off that 09 form.

Our backline is our weakness this year?

[Statsman]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

[SaintPav]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call. Stanley's not ready and Kosi is not fit enough to ruck more.

The saints have relaxed since Roo has come back and thought it would all jus fall into place?

[FQF]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call.

Mcevoy has had somewhat of a breakout year, and if Kosi can force him out of the team based only on reputation then the message it sends to the playing group could be disastrous.

Tommy Walsh will be a key member of our 2012 side.

[#1GILL]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call. Stanley's not ready and Kosi is not fit enough to ruck more.

The saints have relaxed since Roo has come back and thought it would all jus fall into place?

Good call. I think this is one of the main reasons of our form slump. Too many have just relaxed now that Roo is back. I think Friday was a big wakeup call for them, and we will see real improvement from now on.

We'll go with FQF's quesiton:
"Tommy Walsh will be a key member of our 2012 side."

[dcstkfc]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call.

Mcevoy has had somewhat of a breakout year, and if Kosi can force him out of the team based only on reputation then the message it sends to the playing group could be disastrous.

Tommy Walsh will be a key member of our 2012 side.

Good call, signs very good for a bloke so new to our game call

Nick Dal Santo still doesn't do enough, good call bad call

[#1GILL]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call.

Mcevoy has had somewhat of a breakout year, and if Kosi can force him out of the team based only on reputation then the message it sends to the playing group could be disastrous.

Tommy Walsh will be a key member of our 2012 side.

Good call, signs very good for a bloke so new to our game call

Nick Dal Santo still doesn't do enough, good call bad call

Good call, he does enough, but is still not fulfilling his potential. We could get more out of him.

We cannot win the premiership this year if we don't win atleast 3 if not 4 of our next 4 games.
GC/BC?

[Winmarvellous]

Good call. And he's not alone in our midfield atm.

Gilbert and Fisher have been worked out, and at least one needs to move further afield for a couple of weeks at least.

[SaintPav]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call.

Mcevoy has had somewhat of a breakout year, and if Kosi can force him out of the team based only on reputation then the message it sends to the playing group could be disastrous.

Tommy Walsh will be a key member of our 2012 side.

Good call, signs very good for a bloke so new to our game call

Nick Dal Santo still doesn't do enough, good call bad call

Good call, he does enough, but is still not fulfilling his potential. We could get more out of him.

We cannot win the premiership this year if we don't win atleast 3 if not 4 of our next 4 games.
GC/BC?

Good call. We need to hit the finals in top form.

The filth will choke in the finals. Good call bad call?

[dcstkfc]

Bad call. Our backline is under undue pressure because the midfield is being smashed in the clearances.

Kosi as backup ruck, Stanley to the forward line and McEvoy out. Good call or bad call?

Bad call.

Mcevoy has had somewhat of a breakout year, and if Kosi can force him out of the team based only on reputation then the message it sends to the playing group could be disastrous.

Tommy Walsh will be a key member of our 2012 side.

Good call, signs very good for a bloke so new to our game call

Nick Dal Santo still doesn't do enough, good call bad call

Good call, he does enough, but is still not fulfilling his potential. We could get more out of him.

We cannot win the premiership this year if we don't win atleast 3 if not 4 of our next 4 games.
GC/BC?

Good call. We need to hit the finals in top form.

The filth will choke in the finals. Good call bad call?

Bad call, they are a hardened finals team who haven't choked in previous years, simply weren't good enough- this year they are and will be highly competitive if not premiers

[dcstkfc]

Sorry need a new one myself- Jason Blake is being found out in one-on-ones

[Beej]

Sorry need a new one myself- Jason Blake is being found out in one-on-ones

Bad call, premature call, don't be so quick to judge call.

Blake is better than your average defender in one-on-one situations. Defenders are also at the mercy of the accountability of the midfield.

Milne will be an All-Australian this year. Good call, bad call?

[midas_touch]

Sorry need a new one myself- Jason Blake is being found out in one-on-ones

Bad call, premature call, don't be so quick to judge call.

Blake is better than your average defender in one-on-one situations. Defenders are also at the mercy of the accountability of the midfield.

Milne will be an All-Australian this year. Good call, bad call?

Bad Call, rose coloured glasses Call. Didak and LeCras to take the small forward positions.

Do the Saints have less talent on the park than the other major contenders, good call bad call?

[dcstkfc]

Sorry need a new one myself- Jason Blake is being found out in one-on-ones

Bad call, premature call, don't be so quick to judge call.

Blake is better than your average defender in one-on-one situations. Defenders are also at the mercy of the accountability of the midfield.

Milne will be an All-Australian this year. Good call, bad call?

Bad call, Mark Le Cras will take the only all-Australian small forward spot this year- and Betts' pressure puts him ahead of Milney as well.

Jack Steven should be run through the midfield as we have a dearth of midfield rotation options- good call, bad call?