Changes for Round 16

mohannair · Post: # 955571Post **mohannair** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 10:10am

With Kosi & BJ certain to return against the Pies who will make way? May be Blakey will (if MRP thinks so). Its a tough choice between Patto & McEvoy.

Also becasue it is at the 'G' Raph Clarke may get a good look in (if he is fit) then may be Zac will miss.

Bardon Saint · Mon 12 Jul 2010 10:16am

How did armo go for sandy? A chance of a recall?

saint66au · Post: # 955580Post **saint66au** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 10:19am

Armo not named in best and Sandy got flogged...so Id think the only changes would be those returning from injury

In: BJ, Kosi

Out: Pattinson, (one of) Steven, Geary, McQualter

saint75 · Post: # 955602Post **saint75** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 11:08am

They won't introduce to many new players. Minimal changes I would think.

INS: BJ, Kosi (depending on the ankle)
OUTS: Pattison, Steven

ThePunter · Post: # 955604Post **ThePunter** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 11:10am

Don't bank on Kosi being back.

Geary, McQualter, Steven, Dempster and Peake seem the most likely to be replaced by Goddard.

sainter104 · Mon 12 Jul 2010 11:21am

In: BJ
Out Dempster/ Dawson

JABBER · Post: # 955612Post **JABBER** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 11:41am

Ins Goddard Kosi

Outs Gram Pattison

borderbarry · Mon 12 Jul 2010 11:44am

If you are going to drop Gram after his first game back, why not Roo as well?

For me Pattison and Steven.

saintspremiers · Mon 12 Jul 2010 12:39pm

borderbarry wrote:If you are going to drop Gram after his first game back, why not Roo as well?

For me Pattison and Steven.

Agree.

Dunno where JABBER jabs his thing, but obviously in the wrong spot

starsign · Post: # 955652Post **starsign** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 12:59pm

might see Dawson out if no Cloke and Blakeys in the clear, in a "horses for courses"
Patto will be pretty stiff but will have to make way for Koz and BJ

MCG-Unit · Post: # 955675Post **MCG-Unit** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:31pm

ThePunter wrote:Don't bank on Kosi being back.

Geary, McQualter, Steven, Dempster and Peake seem the most likely to be replaced by Goddard.

Why do you think Peake will be tipped out every week

Thought he was one of their better players, again

stinger · Post: # 955676Post **stinger** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:35pm

in bj out blake.....suspended.....

imho,,,

stinger · Post: # 955677Post **stinger** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:35pm

MCG-Unit wrote:
ThePunter wrote:Don't bank on Kosi being back.

Geary, McQualter, Steven, Dempster and Peake seem the most likely to be replaced by Goddard.
Why do you think Peake will be tipped out every week

Thought he was one of their better players, again

yes he was....

Ralphy · Post: # 955678Post **Ralphy** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:36pm

mohannair wrote:With Kosi & BJ certain to return against the Pies who will make way? May be Blakey will (if MRP thinks so). Its a tough choice between Patto & McEvoy.

Also becasue it is at the 'G' Raph Clarke may get a good look in (if he is fit) then may be Zac will miss.

Personally think that OUT ben,Gardy(rest) , In BJ & King
Kosi wont come up, hell we play better without him. (watch me get Abused for that statement) ill stick by it.

35...LEGEND · Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:39pm

JABBER wrote:Ins Goddard Kosi

Outs Gram Pattison

Why Gram out

another scoop

JABBER · Post: # 955682Post **JABBER** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:43pm

Gram come in for Goddard i dont think he done enough against Brisbane.
He is easlily in our best 22 but whats wrong in him playing for Sandi for the next couple of weeks.

35...LEGEND · Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:51pm

JABBER wrote:Gram come in for Goddard i dont think he done enough against Brisbane.
He is easlily in our best 22 but whats wrong in him playing for Sandi for the next couple of weeks.

Thought he wenrt ok after half time..............very much doubt he will be dropped.

All opinions.

ThePunter · Post: # 955686Post **ThePunter** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:53pm

I don't think Peake should be dropped, but in trying to name someone I put his name in there. We had no players with fewer than 11 disposals on Saturday night. We may not have been super, but we're all of a sudden incredibly even.

Someone will come out for Goddard; he's our most important player.

It won't be a KP/ruckman (Riewoldt, Gardiner, McEvoy, Pattison (he'll come out for Kosi if fit), S Fisher).

Blake may be suspended, but otherwise he stays. Zac Dawson may come out, but only under a horses for courses policy - despite four goals from Fev, Dawson was good.

That leaves Gram, Steven, Jones, Hayes, Montagna, Schneider, Geary, Gilbert, Ray, Dempster, Dal Santo, Peake, McQualter, Gwilt & Milne.

It won't be any of Jones, Hayes, Montagna, Schneider, Gilbert, Ray, Dal Santo, Gwilt or Milne. And it would be silly to drop Gram after one game back.

That leaves Steven, Geary, Dempster, McQualter and Peake. On Saturday's form it would be Steven, but he has the "big game performer" DNA and should be left in. McQualter's in the leadership group and has a good record against Collingwod. That leaves a small defender or Peake.

All a good problem to have.

saint3d · Post: # 955687Post **saint3d** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 1:56pm

JABBER wrote:Gram come in for Goddard i dont think he done enough against Brisbane.
He is easlily in our best 22 but whats wrong in him playing for Sandi for the next couple of weeks.

What's wrong with him playing in the seniors?

MCG-Unit · Post: # 955690Post **MCG-Unit** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 2:03pm

ThePunter wrote:I don't think Peake should be dropped, but in trying to name someone I put his name in there. We had no players with fewer than 11 disposals on Saturday night. We may not have been super, but we're all of a sudden incredibly even.......

That leaves Steven, Geary, Dempster, McQualter and Peake.....

Fair enough then, out of that group it might be Steven, Dempster or McQualter, although he never seems to get tipped out

OneEyedSainter77 · Mon 12 Jul 2010 2:03pm

JABBER wrote:Gram come in for Goddard i dont think he done enough against Brisbane.
He is easlily in our best 22 but whats wrong in him playing for Sandi for the next couple of weeks.

Thank f*** you don't select our team.

saintly · Post: # 955708Post **saintly** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 2:41pm

mohannair wrote:With Kosi & BJ certain to return against the Pies who will make way? May be Blakey will (if MRP thinks so). Its a tough choice between Patto & McEvoy.

Also becasue it is at the 'G' Raph Clarke may get a good look in (if he is fit) then may be Zac will miss.

it was monetioned in either the age or hearldsun that kosi might be again out this week.

if that is the case Pattison should stay in.

skeptic · Post: # 955731Post **skeptic** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 3:57pm

would rather keep Jack then Mini

bigcarl · Post: # 955743Post **bigcarl** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 4:52pm

saint75 wrote:They won't introduce to many new players. Minimal changes I would think.

INS: BJ, Kosi (depending on the ankle)
OUTS: Pattison, Steven

Like to find a way to keep Steven in. Going to be a gun. Those three goals against Geelong have won me and he's only going to get better. We need every goal-kicker we can get.

plugger66 · Post: # 955749Post **plugger66** » Mon 12 Jul 2010 5:06pm

Doesnt look like Kosi is playing so it is BJ in for either Dempster, Steven or Zac but only id 2 talls are rubbed out tonight.

I know we all have our own opinions but how the hell do some people think Gram could be dropped or even worse both Ben and MG. Opinions are like arseholes we all have them but some arseholes stink more than others.

Changes for Round 16

Changes for Round 16

changes for round 16

Re: Changes for Round 16

Re: changes for round 16

changes for round 16

Re: changes for round 16

Re: changes for round 16

Re: changes for round 16

Re: Changes for Round 16