The NOT sh*t list

Thinline · Post: # 912115Post **Thinline** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:08am

Gilbert
Montagna
Fisher
Gwilt
Baker

The rest... As awful a performance as I have witnessed in what seems like a very long time. Second to the contest all night. Turn it around fast or we are looking at a 10 goal drubbing against the dogs.

Who the F*** was on Rodan?

Maybe a kick in the arse won't be such a bad thing. Farkin hope not.

Shoot Kosi all you like, but he was well starved of opportunities by most un-Saintly like behaviour in the centre.

Vomit worthy. Wasteful, ill-disciplined and stand offish. Urrrrrgggghhh.

Wipe. Reload. Fire up.

Sam23 · Post: # 912120Post **Sam23** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:09am

I think Gilbert was probably our best.

Montagna, Schneider, Fisher all tried hard.

Baker was OK I agree.

SaintSimmo · Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:09am

Add Schnieder to the Not SH*T LIST

SaintWodonga · Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:09am

I thought RL should have done something about Rodan before half time. I would have put a hard tag on him.

Saints43 · Post: # 912161Post **Saints43** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:17am

I thought Eddy was good - watching on telly.

wraiyth · Post: # 912165Post **wraiyth** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:18am

Thought Jones had a decent night

Thinline · Post: # 912172Post **Thinline** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:20am

wraiyth wrote:Thought Jones had a decent night

You mean Aussie same round 1995?

CJ had a horror night...

saintsRrising · Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:20am

Eddy played Ray's role and was I thought generally ok. his disposal was acutally better that it was last year when he played.

wraiyth · Post: # 912184Post **wraiyth** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:23am

Thinline wrote:
wraiyth wrote:Thought Jones had a decent night
You mean Aussie same round 1995?

CJ had a horror night...

CJ held Boak alright, Boak didnt have a massive impact. Got plenty of it and used it decently.

St. Luke · Post: # 912185Post **St. Luke** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:23am

Sam23 wrote:I think Gilbert was probably our best.

That's what I was thinking also.

CeilidhSaint · Sun 25 Apr 2010 1:18am

Intensity, effort, ball handling, decision making, skills all on the sh1t list.
Think I agree largely with your list (I am sure that means alot to you!) but we bring that rubbish to the table regularly and we won't be worried about 12 being available for finals.

SainterK · Post: # 912335Post **SainterK** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 1:19am

Yep, Schneider was much improved this week.

Blake tried hard.

CeilidhSaint · Sun 25 Apr 2010 1:30am

Almost more like "least worst".

35...LEGEND · Sun 25 Apr 2010 1:38am

SainterK wrote:Yep, Schneider was much improved this week.

Blake tried hard.

Yep,had a bit of a dig at Schnads last week(said he needed to lift).
Much better tonight,in an overall poor performance.

3rd generation saint · Sun 25 Apr 2010 1:53am

Cannot understand why Jones was not put onto Rodan. Let's face it, we stank tonight, it seemed like we we're trying to save the game after the first quarter, we did notr want to attack.
One mark in the forward 50 which was taken by Kosi with the only decently delivered ball to him all night.
All night we'd go forward but have no one in our forward 50 to kick it too, or whoever was there was hopelessly outnumbered.
What happened to Goddard playing forward like he did last week?
Once again we seemed to have our Port Adelaide phobia, we have played well once against this mob in 10 years and I am sick of losing to them and playing terrible football against them.
They better come out to play next week or they will get absolutely trampled by the Dogs.

3rd generation saint · Sun 25 Apr 2010 1:57am

Actually thought Zac had his best game tonight, he matched up well on Tredea, got a few kicks and spoilt well.
Our defence wasn't the problem tonight, they played well and did their job, unfortunately you couldn't complain about our forweard line tonight because we didn't have one to complain about.

NoMore · Post: # 912484Post **NoMore** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 8:35am

It would please me alot if i never ever have to watch Kosi, Geary and Eddy play for our club again.

Geary and Edddy are never going to make it. Time to start getting a couple of our younger guys in to replace these two useless hacks

Kosi is a lost cause. Dops sitters. Can't make a desiccion when he gets it. We should have traded him for Fevola last year. ZHe will get suspended again the clumsy oaf.

Ghost Like · Post: # 912488Post **Ghost Like** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 8:54am

NoMore wrote:It would please me alot if i never ever have to watch Kosi, Geary and Eddy play for our club again.

You can ensure that's the case.

The football played by the Saints last night was deplorable, we played on when we shouldn't have, we held the ball when we should have run with it, we fumbled, we second guessed ourselves, our kicking and handballing was second rate, we were second to the ball, the only thing that went right for us was Port's poor kicking for goal & unfortunately that had nothing to do with us.

Kosi was not good but our delivery into the forward line was even worse, it was not quick, it was not accurate nor was it purposeful.

Changes will be made next week but if they serve up that same intensity and style of football we'll get smashed. Back to basics Saints, hold your structures, don't fumble and get your hands on the pill first, then run and challenge the defenders, don't hesitate...no defence likes pressure!

squiz · Post: # 912490Post **squiz** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 9:08am

Gwilt is not going to make it as a forward.
To me it looked like he had lead boots on.
Port was rebounding easy some times because
Gwilt, Kosi a McQaulter who is in poor form, were
just about invisable.
Why didn't Ross try somthing? anything!

fugazi · Post: # 912508Post **fugazi** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 9:47am

Why is everyone saying BJ had a bad game...I thought he did a heap of good things, without his usual stats, but set-up Schneider twice.

Saint Bev · Post: # 912511Post **Saint Bev** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 10:10am

3rd generation saint wrote:Actually thought Zac had his best game tonight, he matched up well on Tredea, got a few kicks and spoilt well.
Our defence wasn't the problem tonight, they played well and did their job, unfortunately you couldn't complain about our forweard line tonight because we didn't have one to complain about.

Yes totally agree, special mention to Geary to, he tries very hard and is tough, I really like the look of him and think he will be a great player for us.

Saintsfan · Post: # 912517Post **Saintsfan** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 10:35am

Thinline wrote:Gilbert
Montagna
Fisher
Gwilt
Baker

The rest... As awful a performance as I have witnessed in what seems like a very long time. Second to the contest all night. Turn it around fast or we are looking at a 10 goal drubbing against the dogs.

Who the F*** was on Rodan?

Maybe a kick in the arse won't be such a bad thing. Farkin hope not.

Shoot Kosi all you like, but he was well starved of opportunities by most un-Saintly like behaviour in the centre.

Vomit worthy. Wasteful, ill-disciplined and stand offish. Urrrrrgggghhh.

Wipe. Reload. Fire up.

You are losing the plot and this trend has been developing over the past few weeks

na exa · Post: # 912525Post **na exa** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 11:04am

You are losing the plot and this trend has been developing over the past few weeks

que ? ... Miss Faulty.

Thinline · Post: # 912543Post **Thinline** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 11:47am

Saintsfan wrote:
Thinline wrote:Gilbert
Montagna
Fisher
Gwilt
Baker

The rest... As awful a performance as I have witnessed in what seems like a very long time. Second to the contest all night. Turn it around fast or we are looking at a 10 goal drubbing against the dogs.

Who the F*** was on Rodan?

Maybe a kick in the arse won't be such a bad thing. Farkin hope not.

Shoot Kosi all you like, but he was well starved of opportunities by most un-Saintly like behaviour in the centre.

Vomit worthy. Wasteful, ill-disciplined and stand offish. Urrrrrgggghhh.

Wipe. Reload. Fire up.
You are losing the plot and this trend has been developing over the past few weeks

How so, oh hallowed standard bearer?

With what do you disagree?

That I don't simply isolate the usual subjects and twist in a knife to make myself feel better?

Here's a suggestion: Don't like what I type? Ignore it. I'll extend the same courtesy your way.

That way we don't have to tolerate each other.

We stank to high heaven last night. Thankfully we stink rarely.

But stink like that next week and we'll cop a serious towelling.

westy · Post: # 912558Post **westy** » Sun 25 Apr 2010 12:06pm

Thinline wrote:
Saintsfan wrote:
Thinline wrote:Gilbert
Montagna
Fisher
Gwilt
Baker

The rest... As awful a performance as I have witnessed in what seems like a very long time. Second to the contest all night. Turn it around fast or we are looking at a 10 goal drubbing against the dogs.

Who the F*** was on Rodan?

Maybe a kick in the arse won't be such a bad thing. Farkin hope not.

Shoot Kosi all you like, but he was well starved of opportunities by most un-Saintly like behaviour in the centre.

Vomit worthy. Wasteful, ill-disciplined and stand offish. Urrrrrgggghhh.

Wipe. Reload. Fire up.
You are losing the plot and this trend has been developing over the past few weeks
How so, oh hallowed standard bearer?

With what do you disagree?

That I don't simply isolate the usual subjects and twist in a knife to make myself feel better?

Here's a suggestion: Don't like what I type? Ignore it. I'll extend the same courtesy your way.

That way we don't have to tolerate each other.

We stank to high heaven last night. Thankfully we stink rarely.

But stink like that next week and we'll cop a serious towelling.

Quite right Thinline. And another thing that a few people have overlooked is that we could use the services of an effective Ruck combination

The NOT sh*t list

The NOT sh*t list

Re: The NOT sh*t list

Re: The NOT sh*t list

Re: The NOT sh*t list