Sandringham Vs Willi Sat- Ladder/ review

[saintbrat]

Williamstown vs. Sandringham
Saturday 24th April Burbank Oval at 2:00 PM
Round 3 Teams
http://www.sportingpulse.com/club_info. ... onID=56266
Seniors
B Howard Johnson Fisher
HB Gaertner Walsh Hunter
C Gallagher Hutchings Smith
HF K.Geary Pattison Bruno
F Heyne Lourey Tregear
R Stanley Magner Steven
Int Nash McEvoy Cahill Archer Fleming R.Eddy Irving

In: Stanley Archer Fleming
Out: Sautner (Suspended)


Williamstown vs. Sandringham (Reserve Grade)
Saturday 24th April Burbank Oval at 11:00 AM

Reserves
B Stapleton Gower S-Cameron
HB Shakallis Simpkin O'Sullivan
C Johnston Paterakis Andrews
HF Worner Cahill McConnell
F Cleeve Boland Barnes
R Jones Hardiman Ferraro
Int McBain Johnston Rowlands Murnane Archer Allan Cathcart Ambrose Fleming [/b]

[Dr Spaceman]

Good to see Simpkin back

[Saint4Eva]

great young team! nice to see hutchings forced his way in, heard good things about him last year

[Spinner]

Awesome, ill be going hopefully!

Anyone else?



Spewing I wont be able to see lynch play.

[bobmurray]

Why has Cahill been dropped to the magoos..is he crap...is he a list clogger

[ace]

Finally we see Tom Simpkin named in the Sandringham reserves team.

Simpkin has missed the entire season so far but according to the St Kilda club website was not injured.
Speculation is that he was on strike because he had not been promoted to the senior list.

Welcome back Tom.

[bergholt]

Why has Cahill been dropped to the magoos..is he crap...is he a list clogger

crap comment.

he's a tall kid on the fringes of the sandy side in his second year on the list. has played a nab cup game so they obviously see something in him. will take time to develop as all kids do, and is hurt by the fact that we have a lot of fringe talls at the moment. stanley, mcevoy, gaertner, pattison, walsh, archer, lynch, johnson, simpkin - j smith and winmar almost there as well. and of course sautner at sandy, when he's on the park.

give him some time to prove one way or the other.

[joffaboy]

Around the corner from where I live.

Will probably get down there for a look.

[Bernard Shakey]

Williamstown vs. Sandringham
Saturday 24th April Burbank Oval at 2:00 PM
Round 3 Teams
http://www.sportingpulse.com/club_info. ... onID=56266
Seniors
B Howard Johnson Fisher
HB Gaertner Walsh Hunter
C Gallagher Hutchings Smith
HF K.Geary Pattison Bruno
F Heyne Lourey Tregear
R Stanley Magner Steven
Int Nash McEvoy Cahill Archer Fleming R.Eddy Irving

In: Stanley Archer Fleming
Out: Sautner (Suspended)


Williamstown vs. Sandringham (Reserve Grade)
Saturday 24th April Burbank Oval at 11:00 AM

Reserves
B Stapleton Gower S-Cameron
HB Shakallis Simpkin O'Sullivan
C Johnston Paterakis Andrews
HF Worner Cahill McConnell
F Cleeve Boland Barnes
R Jones Hardiman Ferraro
Int McBain Johnston Rowlands Murnane Archer Allan Cathcart Ambrose Fleming [/b]

Why is Rob Eddy not highlighted, have you dumped him?

[GrumpyOne]

Why has Cahill been dropped to the magoos..is he crap...is he a list clogger

Already been castigated here for my opinion of Cahill. A developing tall with very little else going for him ATM IMHO.

[Batnoe]

I know Cahill is a devoloping tall, but we have many... why hold onto him if he is just developing and we have others.. Why clog the list.

I think he will be in trouble to hold his spot on the list if he doesnt break into the team. He is now in the sandy reserves, thats a long way from the SAINTS

I dont want to talk about delistings, but isnt he the obvious choice considering it is his 2nd year on list, is now in sandy reserves and shows little to say why he should be retained.

Have a look at our list, who else would you prefer to get rid of instead of him?

He is my first gone IMO

[Red]

You can only have 12 Saints players in the senior team in any game.

[GrumpyOne]

You can only have 12 Saints players in the senior team in any game.

So why is he number 13?

[bergholt]

You can only have 12 Saints players in the senior team in any game.

nah, that's only when you're playing a non-afl-aligned side, which are:

frankston
port melbourne
gold coast (maybe?)

not sure if north ballarat and werribee also fall into that category. willie are aligned with footscray so it's definitely not them - we can have as many as we want.

[Dr Spaceman]

You can only have 12 Saints players in the senior team in any game.

So why is he number 13?

He's also named as one of the interchange players for the seniors.

Let's not just assume because he's been named at CHF in the Reserves that he will actually play in that team - just as I won't assume Blakey will play at CHF for the Saints on Saturday night just because he's named there!

[saintbrat]

Why is Rob Eddy not highlighted, have you dumped him?

NO but this touch pad mouse may get dumped....
Fixed

[plugger66]

I know Cahill is a devoloping tall, but we have many... why hold onto him if he is just developing and we have others.. Why clog the list.

I think he will be in trouble to hold his spot on the list if he doesnt break into the team. He is now in the sandy reserves, thats a long way from the SAINTS

I dont want to talk about delistings, but isnt he the obvious choice considering it is his 2nd year on list, is now in sandy reserves and shows little to say why he should be retained.

Have a look at our list, who else would you prefer to get rid of instead of him?

He is my first gone IMO

Was his last 16 rounds of 2010 any good?

[Mr Magic]

I know Cahill is a devoloping tall, but we have many... why hold onto him if he is just developing and we have others.. Why clog the list.

I think he will be in trouble to hold his spot on the list if he doesnt break into the team. He is now in the sandy reserves, thats a long way from the SAINTS

I dont want to talk about delistings, but isnt he the obvious choice considering it is his 2nd year on list, is now in sandy reserves and shows little to say why he should be retained.

Have a look at our list, who else would you prefer to get rid of instead of him?

He is my first gone IMO

I would have thought that Jarryd Allen is first cab off the rank to be delisted at year's end, closely followed by Leigh Fisher?

[Wigsy]

Why has Cahill been dropped to the magoos..is he crap...is he a list clogger

crap comment.

he's a tall kid on the fringes of the sandy side in his second year on the list. has played a nab cup game so they obviously see something in him. will take time to develop as all kids do, and is hurt by the fact that we have a lot of fringe talls at the moment. stanley, mcevoy, gaertner, pattison, walsh, archer, lynch, johnson, simpkin - j smith and winmar almost there as well. and of course sautner at sandy, when he's on the park.

give him some time to prove one way or the other.

Problem is Archer is a first year rookie listed player, Pattison back up following the humiliation of being delisted from the worst list since Fitzroy, Lynch being injured and not named, Simpkin returning from injury through the scoobs, and Jesse Smith and Winmar not playing either.

Why do people get so defensive about certain players. Can you not look at the TV or live games and make reasonable judgements on players without a huge chip on the shoulder? These same arguments have been made through the years about the likes of Schwartze, Moyle, Knowles, and so on. He'll have his chance, but he'd probably want to get moving from the Seniors. If he shows enough, he'll get a third year. But a third year has to be it.

[Con Gorozidis]

Good to see Simpkin back

hey i was going to say that. it is great news. johnson playing well at fb too.
so puts positive pressure on the zac attack.

also good how hutchings has gone straight into vfl footy pretty well. he could be a real good rookie/smoky.

[Con Gorozidis]

I know Cahill is a devoloping tall, but we have many... why hold onto him if he is just developing and we have others.. Why clog the list.

Have a look at our list, who else would you prefer to get rid of instead of him?

He is my first gone IMO

I would have thought that Jarryd Allen is first cab off the rank to be delisted at year's end, closely followed by Leigh Fisher?

yep

l fisher
j allen
l miles
s king

thats 4 gone.

[Spinner]

Anyone know who was the travelling emergency?


Will I get to see Steven today?????

[CeilidhSaint]

L Miles?
Why when he has just been promoted I thought?

[saintbrat]

Simpkin and Cahill in reserves
information is Both Stanley and McEvoy playing in Sandy seniors

Half Time
Sandy 4.2
Williamstown 7.3

[InkerSaint]

Any reports on Walsh yet? How's his kicking going?