Good run with injury in '09 no accident

[saintsRrising]

So Rodgerfox/Stool...did you LIE about being a neutral support...or did you lie about being a St Kilda Supporter?

You have claimed to be both..so you have to be lie-ing about at least one.

Stop avoiding the question. Which one was the lie?

We are waiting...

Waiting for what?

I thought you were talking to this Violent Stool guy.

RF =VS

Comical that you will not admit as we all know it.

[rodgerfox]

So Rodgerfox/Stool...did you LIE about being a neutral support...or did you lie about being a St Kilda Supporter?

You have claimed to be both..so you have to be lie-ing about at least one.

Stop avoiding the question. Which one was the lie?

We are waiting...

Waiting for what?

I thought you were talking to this Violent Stool guy.

RF =VS

Comical that you will not admit as we all know it.

I think it's comical that you continue with nonsense about Violet Stool. I have no idea what you're talking about.


Care to get back in the horribly large hole you've dug yourself? Or is this your way of conceding you're wrong?

[Mr Magic]

Could someone who knows (Mods/Admins) please confirm that rodgerfox and Violent Stool are the same poster?

I'm pretty certain that at least 1 mod has 'outed' this particular poster previously (saint6au?).

If it is confirmed we can at least dispense with this ridiculous charade that this particular poster seems to take such delight in.

[meher baba]

Could someone who knows (Mods/Admins) please confirm that rodgerfox and Violent Stool are the same poster?

I'm pretty certain that at least 1 mod has 'outed' this particular poster previously (saint6au?).

If it is confirmed we can at least dispense with this ridiculous charade that this particular poster seems to take such delight in.

What does it matter? Reincarnated and someone who posts regularly on here were definitely the same poster. People don't bang on endlessly about that.

Some of the time RF doesn't make much sense to me.

Interestingly, whenever he starts to make a few logical points that the GT-haters have trouble responding to, they immediately switch the debate to the issue of whether or not RF and Violent Stool are the same poster.

It's called "sidetracking".

[stinger]

Could someone who knows (Mods/Admins) please confirm that rodgerfox and Violent Stool are the same poster?

I'm pretty certain that at least 1 mod has 'outed' this particular poster previously (saint6au?).

If it is confirmed we can at least dispense with this ridiculous charade that this particular poster seems to take such delight in.

What does it matter? Reincarnated and someone who posts regularly on here were definitely the same poster. People don't bang on endlessly about that.

Some of the time RF doesn't make much sense to me.

Interestingly, whenever he starts to make a few logical points that the GT-haters have trouble responding to, they immediately switch the debate to the issue of whether or not RF and Violent Stool are the same poster.

It's called "sidetracking".

yep....sure is...pity guys like rf can't comment on footy issues without being attacked personally....he does have some valid points...and i find his views interesting...don't give a f*** about violent stool....don't ever remember reading a post from him even....

[meher baba]

You know full well that Lyon did not hire Misson. You are again just playing your petter RF/VS games...........................Misson was appointed after the then Board had Ross Smith (who is you know a sport scientist) & others review what was required for our player Conditioning Department.....No doubt that Misson knew he could work well with Lyon was factor as well.

According to the media at the time, the main recommendation of the Ross Smith review was to increase the size of the unit to ten staff.

I haven't seen the review report - have you - but I would be surprised if includied among its recommendations was anything like "the club must recruit Dave Misson".

It is a known fact that Misson came to Victoria after his wife won a job as principal of a school. A possible interpretation is that Lyon wanted to bring Misson with him right from the outset and it took the Missons about a year to organise their lives - including her finding a job she was happy with - before this could happen.

However it turned out, the idea that Lyon was not primarily responsible for the decision to recruit Misson seems to me to be pretty naive. Which, in my view, puts him on a par with GT in terms of choosing the head of his fitness department.

Personally, I don't have any problem with Lyon personally choosing his fitness coach, but then I haven't constructed a totally imaginary version of history in which GT got sacked because he insisted on having sole control over issues like appointing the fitness coach.

BTW, having just trawled through all of the articles available online about Misson, I do notice that the guy doesn't hold back in telling everybody about what a total wizz he is, how wonderful his methods are, etc, etc. I also note that the methods used sound like they would cost a fair bit of dosh, which raises plugger66's point about there being a much larger budget for this stuff now than in the GT era.

[markp]

RF is a visionary.

[Mr Magic]

Could someone who knows (Mods/Admins) please confirm that rodgerfox and Violent Stool are the same poster?

I'm pretty certain that at least 1 mod has 'outed' this particular poster previously (saint6au?).

If it is confirmed we can at least dispense with this ridiculous charade that this particular poster seems to take such delight in.

What does it matter? Reincarnated and someone who posts regularly on here were definitely the same poster. People don't bang on endlessly about that.

Some of the time RF doesn't make much sense to me.

Interestingly, whenever he starts to make a few logical points that the GT-haters have trouble responding to, they immediately switch the debate to the issue of whether or not RF and Violent Stool are the same poster.

It's called "sidetracking".

Sorry, have to agree to disagree.

AFAIK Reincarnated never denied he was another poster, unlike rodgerfox.

And isn't this particular poster, that you seem willing to defend on this issue, the same poster that seems to continually draw attention to Milton66 being WayneJudson42?

I haven't noticed you jumping to Milton's defence over the same issue?

And please feel free to point out where rodger/stool has made 'logical points' and the debate has been 'side-tracked'.

[joffaboy]

So what exactly is it that Ross Lyon has done that makes him so wonderful?

Gave us a shot at a flag, something your hero Thomas couldn't NEVER do.

Lyon has achieved more at the Saints in the last two years that Thomas EVER did.

F.A.C.T.

How did Lyon give us a shot at a flag?

[rodgerfox]

Sorry, have to agree to disagree.

AFAIK Reincarnated never denied he was another poster, unlike rodgerfox.

And isn't this particular poster, that you seem willing to defend on this issue, the same poster that seems to continually draw attention to Milton66 being WayneJudson42?

I haven't noticed you jumping to Milton's defence over the same issue?

And please feel free to point out where rodger/stool has made 'logical points' and the debate has been 'side-tracked'.

A couple of things...

I'm not this 'Violet Stool' person.

Please stay on topic. Your chiming in due to your bizarre man-love of me is a clear example of hijacking a thread.
Please cease as I'm waiting for some questions to be answered.


Thank you.

[matrix]

"how did lyon give us a shot at the flag"

[Mr Magic]

Could someone who knows (Mods/Admins) please confirm that rodgerfox and Violent Stool are the same poster?

I'm pretty certain that at least 1 mod has 'outed' this particular poster previously (saint6au?).

If it is confirmed we can at least dispense with this ridiculous charade that this particular poster seems to take such delight in.

What does it matter? Reincarnated and someone who posts regularly on here were definitely the same poster. People don't bang on endlessly about that.

Some of the time RF doesn't make much sense to me.

Interestingly, whenever he starts to make a few logical points that the GT-haters have trouble responding to, they immediately switch the debate to the issue of whether or not RF and Violent Stool are the same poster.

It's called "sidetracking".

yep....sure is...pity guys like rf can't comment on footy issues without being attacked personally....he does have some valid points...and i find his views interesting...don't give a f*** about violent stool....don't ever remember reading a post from him even....

Great to see you feel rodgerfox is worth defending. That's your opinion and you're entitled to have it.
As are I and others who feel he is nothing more than a 'baiting troll'.

Just a question for you though:-
Is it ok for him to post personal attacks on other posters with impugnity?

[joffaboy]

"how did lyon give us a shot at the flag"

I know, really it was so pathetic, and so poorly contrived, that it wasn't worth answering.

Really, if it wasn't so sad, it would be quite amusing

[joffaboy]

Just a question for you though:-
Is it ok for him to post personal attacks on other posters with impugnity?

Oh SNAP MM.

Someone just got PWNED.

[Mr Magic]

Sorry, have to agree to disagree.

AFAIK Reincarnated never denied he was another poster, unlike rodgerfox.

And isn't this particular poster, that you seem willing to defend on this issue, the same poster that seems to continually draw attention to Milton66 being WayneJudson42?

I haven't noticed you jumping to Milton's defence over the same issue?

And please feel free to point out where rodger/stool has made 'logical points' and the debate has been 'side-tracked'.

A couple of things...

I'm not this 'Violet Stool' person.

Please stay on topic. Your chiming in due to your bizarre man-love of me is a clear example of hijacking a thread.
Please cease as I'm waiting for some questions to be answered.


Thank you.

Dodgy
first of all it's not Violet Stool it's VioleNt Stool, and you know it. It's just another case of you playing little games so that you can deny later.

My best guess is that posters may answer your questions, once you actually answer all those questions posed of you.
All those questions that you seem to avoid answering, thread after thread.

[rodgerfox]

"how did lyon give us a shot at the flag"

Well he had no input into the fitness of the list.

He had no input into the availability of the list.

He only briefs the recruiters on the types of players he needs - he has no input into the actual players we recruit.

All he does is coach on match day.


So how is it Lyon that gave us a shot at a flag? I think it's a very valid question.

[Milton66]

"how did lyon give us a shot at the flag"

Well he had no input into the fitness of the list.

He had no input into the availability of the list.

He only briefs the recruiters on the types of players he needs - he has no input into the actual players we recruit.

All he does is coach on match day.


So how is it Lyon that gave us a shot at a flag? I think it's a very valid question.

McCallum given you the day off, have they?

[Milton66]

Great to see you feel rodgerfox is worth defending. That's your opinion and you're entitled to have it.
As are I and others who feel he is nothing more than a 'baiting troll'.

Of course he does. Any defender of GT is a friend of MB.

Sadly, MB is blinded by his obsessive need to defend GT's legacy that he'll sell his sould to the devil to achieve his objectives.

And to think that RF accuses you of having a man-crush.

Interesting that all of RF's insults and name calling are quickly forgotten abd his "views" are held with such esteem when it suits someone's agenda.

[SainterK]

Hmmm, this is getting stranger and stranger.


So Lyon has no responsiblity for the fitness of the availability of the list.

He doesn't do recruitment either.


So what exactly is it that Ross Lyon has done that makes him so wonderful?

Because thinking Ross Lyon is a good coach is an exclusive view only held by St Kilda supporters?

Waiting for my answer?

[rodgerfox]

Hmmm, this is getting stranger and stranger.


So Lyon has no responsiblity for the fitness of the availability of the list.

He doesn't do recruitment either.


So what exactly is it that Ross Lyon has done that makes him so wonderful?

Because thinking Ross Lyon is a good coach is an exclusive view only held by St Kilda supporters?

Waiting for my answer?

What is the question?

I only see a statement with a question mark.

[SainterK]

Hmmm, this is getting stranger and stranger.


So Lyon has no responsiblity for the fitness of the availability of the list.

He doesn't do recruitment either.


So what exactly is it that Ross Lyon has done that makes him so wonderful?

Because thinking Ross Lyon is a good coach is an exclusive view only held by St Kilda supporters?

Waiting for my answer?

What is the question?

I only see a statement with a question mark.

Really? Here I was thinking you could actually offer up a yes or no answer to the above "statement"

[rodgerfox]

Really? Here I was thinking you could actually offer up a yes or no answer to the above "statement"

??

[joffaboy]

Well he had no input into the fitness of the list.

He had no input into the availability of the list.

He only briefs the recruiters on the types of players he needs - he has no input into the actual players we recruit.

All he does is coach on match day.

C- Must try harder in class.

Fair Dinkum, how anyone can take your stuff seriously is incredible

[rodgerfox]

Well he had no input into the fitness of the list.

He had no input into the availability of the list.

He only briefs the recruiters on the types of players he needs - he has no input into the actual players we recruit.

All he does is coach on match day.

C- Must try harder in class.

Fair Dinkum, how anyone can take your stuff seriously is incredible

Perhaps have a read of the discussion before you chime in with this type of post.

It's a bit embarrassing for you.

[joffaboy]

Great to see you feel rodgerfox is worth defending. That's your opinion and you're entitled to have it.
As are I and others who feel he is nothing more than a 'baiting troll'.

Of course he does. Any defender of GT is a friend of MB.

Sadly, MB is blinded by his obsessive need to defend GT's legacy that he'll sell his sould to the devil to achieve his objectives.

And to think that RF accuses you of having a man-crush.

Interesting that all of RF's insults and name calling are quickly forgotten abd his "views" are held with such esteem when it suits someone's agenda.

It wasn't mb, Milton, it was your fellow banned poster, you know the bloke