jabbers phantom draft 2009

JABBER · Post: # 853169Post **JABBER** » Tue 27 Oct 2009 11:07pm

1.TOM SCULLY
2. JACK TRENGOVE
3. GARY ROHAN
4. BEN CUNNINGHAM
5. DUSTIN MARTIN
6. JOHN BUTCHER
7.JACK CARLISLE
8. KANE LUCAS
9. LUKE TAPSCOTT
10. TROY TAYLOR
11. LUKE BALL (SORRY)
12. ANDREW MOORE
13. ANTHONY MORABITO
14. MATHEW PANOS
15. DANIEL PANOS
16. JACK FITZPATRICK
17. MITCHELL DUNCAN

32. RYAN HARWOOD
60. SAM SHAW
64 NICHOLAS WINMAR
80. ADAM BENTICK

JABBER · Post: # 853173Post **JABBER** » Tue 27 Oct 2009 11:21pm

15. DANIEL TALIA

Batnoe · Post: # 853188Post **Batnoe** » Tue 27 Oct 2009 11:56pm

Dustin Martin number 3 to Tigers

they need a good mid

Saintersss · Wed 28 Oct 2009 12:21am

No offense, but the draft will not look anything like that.

sax · Post: # 853209Post **sax** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 7:57am

Trengove will go no. 1

Animal Enclosure · Wed 28 Oct 2009 8:15am

and it's Cunnington not Cunningham.

robbie muir · Wed 28 Oct 2009 9:37am

Winmar will go before pick 64 and St.Kilda will not use pick 80.

JABBER · Post: # 853244Post **JABBER** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 10:55am

I done it before any one else based on reports from u/18 games this year i see how many of my top 17 go in the first round i will be happy to get 14

SainterK · Post: # 853245Post **SainterK** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 10:58am

Good on you, you will have to let us know how many you get right...

Quixote · Post: # 853261Post **Quixote** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 11:51am

I thought you might have had Alistair Smith in there somewhere...

JABBER · Post: # 853304Post **JABBER** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 1:59pm

Quixote I didn't know we have delisted Allister Smith or he has asked to leave.

but we will find out before Friday otherwise you can't draft him if he is on the list.

Also lets see your top 17 picks and our picks to see who is closer to the mark.

danners · Post: # 853312Post **danners** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 2:19pm

melbourne will not use pick 11 for luke ball

MCG-Unit · Post: # 853315Post **MCG-Unit** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 2:26pm

Saintersss wrote:No offense, but the draft will not look anything like that.

Why don't you put forward your top 10 then

Martin should go at 3 - Butcher and Matthew Panos could slide, otherwise the top 5 or 6 look okay don't they ?

HarveysDeciple · Wed 28 Oct 2009 3:04pm

If Martin is available at pick 3...100% certainty to go to Richmond.

Lock it in close the book.

Saintersss · Post: # 853324Post **Saintersss** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 3:20pm

MCG-Unit wrote:
Saintersss wrote:No offense, but the draft will not look anything like that.
Why don't you put forward your top 10 then

Martin should go at 3 - Butcher and Matthew Panos could slide, otherwise the top 5 or 6 look okay don't they ?

Just a few reasons why the draft is not great:
Morabito way too high, Martin will defiently go to Richmond, Fitzpatrick way too low. Melbourne will defiently not take Ball with 11 and probably not even 18 and who the hell is Daniel Panos.

Here's mine... (not saying its perfect)

1. Tom Scully
No brainer
2. Jack Trengove
No brainer
3. Dustin Martin
3rd best midfielder in the draft.
4. Anthony Morabito
Could possibly be anything, from WA and Freo will most likely pick him up.
5. Ben Cunnington
Probably the 4th best midfielder, fits North nicely.
6. Gary Rohan
Exiciting prospect, there are some doubts, but Sydney will take the chance.
7. Kane Lucas
From the WA, and West Coast need to add to the midfield with their KPP pretty much all set.
8. John Butcher
Replacement for Tredrea.
9. Luke Tapscott
Very good, tough player with probably the best kick in the draft.
10. Koby Stevens
Essendon need another inside midfielder to help out Watson.
11. Jake Carlisle
Need another KPP to help out Watts.
12. Aaron Black
Carlton need a KPF and have a good one in here. Late bolter.
13. Brad Shepard
HBF who will replace Mcleod, Goodwin.
14. Daniel Talia
With Bolton ageing, will probably take the best KPD and they have him right here.
15. Andrew Moore
Not really sure who the Bulldogs will take here, so I gave them a utility.
16. Jake Melksham
Best available midfielder.
17. Nathan Vardy
With Mumford gone, Ottens nearly gone and Blake no good, will take the best ruckman available.

MCG-Unit · Post: # 853332Post **MCG-Unit** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 4:06pm

^^^

Good effort, I had almost the same - only gone up to pick 10 so far....

- I think the OP had many of the top few, just in a different order to some
- OP meant Daniel Talia, not Panos

1 Melbourne - Tom Scully
2 Melbourne - Jackson Trengove
3 Richmond - Dustin Martin
4 Docker - Anthony Morabito
5 Kangas - Ben Cunnington
6 Swans - Gary Rohan
7 Eagles - Kane Lucas
8 Port - Daniel Talia / John Butcher
9 Port - Luke Tapscott
10 Essendon - Jake Melksham

Mathew Panos could slide, who knows

32 Saints - Alex Carey / Mitch Duncan / Andrew Moore / Ryan Harwood yes they're mainly mids

64 Saints - Joseph Dare
80 Saints - Pass

#1GILL · Post: # 853342Post **#1GILL** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 5:19pm

I think Saintersss effort is pretty much on the money

borderbarry · Wed 28 Oct 2009 6:31pm

MCG Unit, we will use pick 60.

danners · Post: # 853356Post **danners** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 6:54pm

i think if melbourne only had pick 1 then it would take scully but considering they have 2 aswell id say they will take trengrove at 1 because he seems to display the qualities to be able to handle the title of being the first player selected

i may be wrong though...

JABBER · Post: # 853375Post **JABBER** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 7:37pm

Round2
18.KOBY STEVENS
19. ALEX CAREY
20. DAVID ASTBURY
21.JAKE MELKSHARD
22.AARON BLACK
23.NATHAN VARDY
24.NAT FYFE
25. RYAN BASTINAC
26. BRADLEY SHEPPARD
27. TRAVIS COLYIER
28. JORDEN GYSBERTS
29. JAMES CRAIG
30. SAM REID
31. JOSPH GROENEWAGON
32. RYAN HARWOOD
33. AYDEN KENNEDY

MCG-Unit · Post: # 853404Post **MCG-Unit** » Wed 28 Oct 2009 9:15pm

borderbarry wrote:MCG Unit, we will use pick 60.

Yes I had selection 64 'Best Available'

and they might Pass at pick 80

Do you mean they will use pick 80 ??

JABBER · Post: # 858261Post **JABBER** » Fri 13 Nov 2009 4:56pm

Jon Ralph in the Hearld sun thinks Melbourne will use pick 11 for Luke Ball
so i might be close on this one Also with the young Western Australia player opting to play cricket instead I still think we will pick up (if left)

32. Ryan Harwood or Mark Hutchings
60. Sam Shaw
64. Nicholas Winmar
80. or psd draft player from other club or L fisher

Armoooo · Post: # 858262Post **Armoooo** » Fri 13 Nov 2009 5:00pm

Melbourne would be crazy to use pick 11 on Luke Ball, who else will take him before pick 18?

They will go Trengrove/Scully and Butcher or Black assuming he doesn't last that long. (All my opinion of course, will very likely be wrong.)

sax · Post: # 858269Post **sax** » Fri 13 Nov 2009 5:19pm

Armoooo wrote:Melbourne would be crazy to use pick 11 on Luke Ball, who else will take him before pick 18?

They will go Trengrove/Scully and Butcher or Black assuming he doesn't last that long. (All my opinion of course, will very likely be wrong.)

Port with pick 16! They are definately keen on him according to today's Adelaide Advertiser!

goodie · Post: # 858273Post **goodie** » Fri 13 Nov 2009 5:26pm

sax wrote:
Armoooo wrote:Melbourne would be crazy to use pick 11 on Luke Ball, who else will take him before pick 18?

They will go Trengrove/Scully and Butcher or Black assuming he doesn't last that long. (All my opinion of course, will very likely be wrong.)
Port with pick 16! They are definately keen on him according to today's Adelaide Advertiser!

I think it'll depend who's available, picks fall a certain way and Melbourne might decide to pull the trigger at 11