Okay pick this side

[3rd generation saint]

Who are , in your humble opinions, the worse St.Kilda players, the ones we couldn't wait to be delisted, the ones that you feel you could have been better than.
This should be interesting.

[#1GILL]

#1. Michael Rix

[Milan Faletic]

Who are , in your humble opinions, the worse St.Kilda players, the ones we couldn't wait to be delisted, the ones that you feel you could have been better than.
This should be interesting.

Wait for it...whipping boy time...and the winner is?

Don't get me wrong 3rd g s. Good thread. Just waiting for a current player to be whipped again.

Cain Ackland was a big one for me. Fiora was another.

Plapp was another.

[Eastern]

#1. Michael Rix

#2. Jodi Arnol

!!

[Life Long Saint]

Stephen Newport
Dean Anderson

[sainter104]

got to be Barry Brooks

the King Island Cheese Is harder

[plugger66]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

[Milton66]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

Why not? They no longer play for us.

[plugger66]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

Why not? They no longer play for us.

Yep doesnt matter how much they tried when they played for us but once they leave it seems they are fair game.

[Milton66]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

Why not? They no longer play for us.

Yep doesnt matter how much they tried when they played for us but once they leave it seems they are fair game.

Are you losing your sense of humour?

It seems that some are fair game even whilst they are still playing for us.

[plugger66]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

Why not? They no longer play for us.

Yep doesnt matter how much they tried when they played for us but once they leave it seems they are fair game.

Are you losing your sense of humour?

It seems that some are fair game even whilst they are still playing for us.

You said i had no humour so its a new me. Serious me.

[Milton66]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

Why not? They no longer play for us.

Yep doesnt matter how much they tried when they played for us but once they leave it seems they are fair game.

Are you losing your sense of humour?

It seems that some are fair game even whilst they are still playing for us.

You said i had no humour so its a new me. Serious me.

Well I wasn't sure, because you're annoying sense of sarcasm appears as strong as ever.

Remember... I'm there for you.

[Iceman234]

Great positive thread. Getting stuck into ex Saints players.

Why not? They no longer play for us.

Yep doesnt matter how much they tried when they played for us but once they leave it seems they are fair game.

Are you losing your sense of humour?

It seems that some are fair game even whilst they are still playing for us.

You said i had no humour so its a new me. Serious me.

Well I wasn't sure, because you're annoying sense of sarcasm appears as strong as ever.

Remember... I'm there for you.

We all are, when he decides the time is right...

[Bernard Shakey]

Ian Stewart. He deserted us and won another Charley.

[Batnoe]

Players that actually played? or just on the list?
I would have to say Phil Raymond for those that never got a game

Otherwise a list could never stop
Tim Elliott
Chris Oliver
Sweeney

[plugger66]

Players that actually played? or just on the list?
I would have to say Phil Raymond for those that never got a game

Otherwise a list could never stop
Tim Elliott
Chris Oliver
Sweeney

And you saw Sweeney play how many games from your Brisbane home?

[ace]

Ian Stewart. He deserted us and won another Charley.

I was a naive teenager at the time, but there were two rumours about Stewart that I still remember.

One was a joke that he only played well once he had been primed with a fews drinks of beer.
The underlying suggestion being that he was a drunk.

The second was far more serious.
Alan Jeans the coach at time was a policeman and was called as a character witness, a role he did not like.
In particular, court cases that no-one wants to even be associated with.
The cases were the sort that those found guilty of still deserve to be stoned to death.


Can anyone confirm or deny these.?

[Mr Magic]

Ian Stewart. He deserted us and won another Charley.

I was a naive teenager at the time, but there were two rumours about Stewart that I still remember.

One was a joke that he only played well once he had been primed with a fews drinks of beer.
The underlying suggestion being that he was a drunk.

The second was far more serious.
Alan Jeans the coach at time was a policeman and was called as a character witness, a role he did not like.
In particular, court cases that no-one wants to even be associated with.
The cases were the sort that those found guilty of still deserve to be stoned to death.


Can anyone confirm or deny these.?

I think you'll find that there were a couple of celebrated cases, including 1 involving a trffic incident in the CBD.

As I recall, the cases seemed to be more of unusual behaviour rather than anything really untoward.

[markinUSA]

From Wikipedia (and take that as you may)

Just a few weeks into the season, Stewart quit the club, citing a heart attack. Speculation was rife that he had actually suffered a nervous breakdown, a view that was supported by the fact that he had been charged by the police (under the name of Ian Cervi) for exposing himself to daytime shoppers in Glenhuntly Road Elsternwick, when parked opposite to the Elsternwick Post Office, but it is certain that he quit before he was sacked.

[Bernard Shakey]

From Wikipedia (and take that as you may)

Just a few weeks into the season, Stewart quit the club, citing a heart attack. Speculation was rife that he had actually suffered a nervous breakdown, a view that was supported by the fact that he had been charged by the police (under the name of Ian Cervi) for exposing himself to daytime shoppers in Glenhuntly Road Elsternwick, when parked opposite to the Elsternwick Post Office, but it is certain that he quit before he was sacked.

That was when he was Carlton coach in 1978.

[Spinner]

From Wikipedia (and take that as you may)

Just a few weeks into the season, Stewart quit the club, citing a heart attack. Speculation was rife that he had actually suffered a nervous breakdown, a view that was supported by the fact that he had been charged by the police (under the name of Ian Cervi) for exposing himself to daytime shoppers in Glenhuntly Road Elsternwick, when parked opposite to the Elsternwick Post Office, but it is certain that he quit before he was sacked.

Was that his real name? Italian?

[Batnoe]

Players that actually played? or just on the list?
I would have to say Phil Raymond for those that never got a game

Otherwise a list could never stop
Tim Elliott
Chris Oliver
Sweeney

And you saw Sweeney play how many games from your Brisbane home?

Does it matter? the heading says choose a team of people we have delisted and i think this guy is on my list of players that should never have gotten game. Whether i saw him or not... i answered the question

So living in Brisbane is a negative? How's the weather down there?

I like it here, i get to see the games... I can travel down, but you are still stuck on shitty winters mate

[fisher_fan]

Michael Rix for mine to, close second Barry Brooks

[B W and R all over]

From Wikipedia (and take that as you may)

Just a few weeks into the season, Stewart quit the club, citing a heart attack. Speculation was rife that he had actually suffered a nervous breakdown, a view that was supported by the fact that he had been charged by the police (under the name of Ian Cervi) for exposing himself to daytime shoppers in Glenhuntly Road Elsternwick, when parked opposite to the Elsternwick Post Office, but it is certain that he quit before he was sacked.

I've heard that when Stewart and Baldock first came to the mainland from Tassie, Doc would keep an eye on Stewie when they went out to parties because he had a tendency to do that sort of stuff.

So as soon as Stewie started to show a few signs that he was on the way, Doc would slip a mickey into his drink that would then make him pass out on a couch and nip any potential 'public disgraces' in the bud.

Not sure if that's true but it's pretty interesting.

[Bernard Shakey]

From Wikipedia (and take that as you may)

Just a few weeks into the season, Stewart quit the club, citing a heart attack. Speculation was rife that he had actually suffered a nervous breakdown, a view that was supported by the fact that he had been charged by the police (under the name of Ian Cervi) for exposing himself to daytime shoppers in Glenhuntly Road Elsternwick, when parked opposite to the Elsternwick Post Office, but it is certain that he quit before he was sacked.

Was that his real name? Italian?

His mother's maiden name.