Sen Radio overnight Nathan Brown Medical with saints

[bigred]

GT was a visionary.

[Iceman234]

Wrote about 20 lines and lost it...

Damn. Really should type big spiels in word and cut and paste...

Anyway my support is 100% behind Ross and the decisions made by them, as guided in his wisdom by his graciousness Teflon.

PS Cousins is a rat

[vacuous space]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

[SainterK]

Sorry to interrupt, but it's actually a really good question to pose in light of this thread...

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

This will probably answer if this is a worthwile pickup not....

Please feel free to continue

I can answer that - would Nathan Browne have ensured that Sneider, Milne kick straight?

AND had Nathan Browne played....would Sneider/Milne played or one gawn....

or...when Bartel shut down Hayes and Ling Dal Santo to 17 touches could we have used an additional midfielder that also kicks goals and frees up a Goddard?

That's not an answer, it's just more questions

[Teflon]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

[Iceman234]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Iceman234 won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e from Brown - is it that difficult?

[Richter]

I can answer that - would Nathan Browne have ensured that Sneider, Milne kick straight?

AND had Nathan Browne played....would Sneider/Milne played or one gawn....

or...when Bartel shut down Hayes and Ling Dal Santo to 17 touches could we have used an additional midfielder that also kicks goals and frees up a Goddard?

Would have taken Dempster's place...... who also missed a sitter than NB might have jagged. Also gives a LOT more offensively than Dempster in terms of disposals garnered, goals scored and goal assists...... question mark would clearly be over his ability to give forward pressure..... another Lyon "trademark".

[Richter]

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Neither would any other club touch Michael Gardiner..... and look how he's turned out...... no absolutes in this business gentlemen.....

[Iceman234]

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Neither would any other club touch Michael Gardiner..... and look how he's turned out...... no absolutes in this business gentlemen.....

Disagree. MG was very remorseful and showed a character that was redeeming and one which wanted to prove himself.

MG and BC were worlds - thousands and thousands of miles - apart and were chalk and cheese when it came to commitment to a team environment and making good for past indiscretions.

[Teflon]

I can answer that - would Nathan Browne have ensured that Sneider, Milne kick straight?

AND had Nathan Browne played....would Sneider/Milne played or one gawn....

or...when Bartel shut down Hayes and Ling Dal Santo to 17 touches could we have used an additional midfielder that also kicks goals and frees up a Goddard?

Would have taken Dempster's place...... who also missed a sitter than NB might have jagged. Also gives a LOT more offensively than Dempster in terms of disposals garnered, goals scored and goal assists...... question mark would clearly be over his ability to give forward pressure..... another Lyon "trademark".

No hope in Nathan Browne playing Dempsters role GF day - fanciful.

Browne HAS NO defensive side to his game whatsoever and can play only 1 position - fwd.

So who goes out....Milne? Sneider? or we play 3 midgets?

Geelong didnt.

Neither would we.

[Teflon]

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Neither would any other club touch Michael Gardiner..... and look how he's turned out...... no absolutes in this business gentlemen.....

True - but Gardiners a rare commodity - mobile, taslented ruckman who was what........27? when drafted?

Brownes 32, got a stuffed leg and has never been able to get anywhere near what he was prior to his horrific injury.

We aint comparing apples...

[rexy]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Iceman234 won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e from Brown - is it that difficult?

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

[Teflon]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Iceman234 won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e from Brown - is it that difficult?

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

hmmmm.....there goes the code of ethics Iceman...

[Iceman234]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Iceman234 won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e from Brown - is it that difficult?

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

hmmmm.....there goes the code of ethics Iceman...

I thought dropping an e would be more up Benny's alley...

[Teflon]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Iceman234 won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e from Brown - is it that difficult?

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

hmmmm.....there goes the code of ethics Iceman...

I thought dropping an e would be more up Benny's alley...

Bennys gone....you need to move on Ice........we up for a new E fight?

[Richter]

won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

hmmmm.....there goes the code of ethics Iceman...

Surely you mean Icman?

Re. Brown, I'd entertain playing 3 smalls. All 3 can rotate (particularly Brown and Schneider) through the midfield. Point is, IMO, we need someone who can actually HURT the opposition in the final available spot in the 22.

Only man from within who could conceivably do it is X Clarke, and he hasn't played consistently at the level required for over 12 months - be nearly 2 years by the time next season comes along.[/quote]

[asiu]

its a pity i have to watch elsewhere

night gentlefellows



side note: i would have loved the little drug fiend playing for us...benny i mean

[rexy]

Do you reckon Nathan Brown would have been a useful addition to our GF forward last week?

With the benefit of hindsight and a time machine, there are some other things I'd try before bringing in Brown.

spot on.

to be honest if we went that path IMO it smacks of absolute desperation.

NO other AFL club would entertain Browne....besides Im not sure he'd meet all the criteria in Icemans "Good Guide to Moral Values"handbook...

Iceman234 won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e from Brown - is it that difficult?

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

hmmmm.....there goes the code of ethics Iceman...

I thought dropping an e would be more up Benny's alley...

Ben is a word that cant really be spelt without the e

Bit like Ice

[Teflon]

won't respond until Teflon drops the farking e

My biggest concern with Brown may actually be the dropping of the E.

hmmmm.....there goes the code of ethics Iceman...

Surely you mean Icman?

Re. Brown, I'd entertain playing 3 smalls. All 3 can rotate (particularly Brown and Schneider) through the midfield. Point is, IMO, we need someone who can actually HURT the opposition in the final available spot in the 22.

Only man from within who could conceivably do it is X Clarke, and he hasn't played consistently at the level required for over 12 months - be nearly 2 years by the time next season comes along.

[/quote]

Brown at 32 can also play midfield?

Funny havent seen him in there much the past 3 yrs.

Nor Sneider for that matter.

Nup. Dreaming.

Geelong dropped a small...didnt add them...

[Iceman234]

Probably not the greatest Internet name to be taking the moral high ground...

[Iceman234]

TBH Id rather Russel Robertson(?)..FFS at least he can STILL move and bagged 5 and a few 3's this year.

Brown is absolutely lazy, doesnt tackle, soft, and looks good on the end of everyones hard work......IF that doesnt eventuate hes the kinda player you wonder where hes been hiding on the park.

NO WAY.

Hes finished IMO.

Very on himself and the fool shouldnt have left the Dogs folllowing the Tan Man.

Still can't believe we didn't pick up BC myself.

I reckon NB would pull his head in, train his arse off and burn for any club that would pick him up for a one-year deal, ala Stuie Dew.

Nah no need for a goal kicking in the GF..... leave it all to Lenny hey?

Brownes a spud.

"Dew dilligence"completed.

You just need to move on Teflon, it will do you good.

BC wasn't ours. And he won't be.

It's okay, you can do it. Take it easy.

Nite pal. Don't be too hard on yourself.

IC

[Milan Faletic]

Nathan Brown

You've got to be kidding.

Just got home and saw this thread.

Yer, let's get rid of 25yo Matt Maguire and draft 32yo Nathan Brown.

Oh, did they have the same injury?

Got one thing to say, Go Storm!!

Lots of people work for SEN.

[bigcarl]

I just hope that we dont fall in the trap carlton fell into after their 99 GF appearence by constantly topping up the list and forgetting about the youth...

Lets not forget that our list is more than adequate, it was our finishing that cost us severely, we must develop from within.

agree. we have some promising young players such as stanley, lynch. and steven among others who i'd like to see considered ahead of a veteran outsider such as brown.

[Milan Faletic]

I just hope that we dont fall in the trap carlton fell into after their 99 GF appearence by constantly topping up the list and forgetting about the youth...

Lets not forget that our list is more than adequate, it was our finishing that cost us severely, we must develop from within.

agree. we have some promising young players such as stanley, lynch. and steven among others who i'd like to see considered ahead of a veteran outsider such as brown.

we have good young players. i agree with big carl. any kids big carl? i'm pushing for dimitri faletic to get a game or even svetlana

[HarveysDeciple]

What I understand it to be at this stage is that Browny has met with the club, and they sent him away for a medical to assess his various ailments before deciding whether to pursue him.

Brown is in LA at the minute with Richo and a couple of the other tigers so not sure what the result of that is.

It's a possibility, but a lot to happen and a lot of unknown factors.

Guy that told me that has had a lot to do with Nathan Brown.