Reincarnated asks...

[reincarnated]

How on earth did Kosi receive 11 votes compared to Roo's 13?

Kosi played well in a few games and was our best forward in those games but to come close to Riewoldt who has kicked double the goals and has infuence almost all matches is a little strange

Fevola too. If Kosi somehow received 11 then Fevola's season was worth double. Riewoldt triple on that

Thoughts?

For what it is worth Reincarnated is proud of the boys and 6-7 of them receiving 11+ votes and most getting in the top 10/15

Our boys have the quality and quantity

[Iceman234]

Iceman234 thinks you are funny.

Reincarnated is at the Brownlow Medal one minute but shortly after has to log on to SS to question the votes between our twin towers, Fevola ...

LOLOLOLOL.

.PWNED

ROFLMFAO.

But yes we have the quality and quantity to win this week, so agree on that.

But fair dinkum, your persona as a nuff-nuff is gold.

[reincarnated]

Iceman234 thinks you are funny.

Reincarnated is at the Brownlow Medal one minute but shortly after has to log on to SS to question the votes between our twin towers, Fevola ...

LOLOLOLOL.

.PWNED

ROFLMFAO.

But yes we have the quality and quantity to win this week, so agree on that.

But fair dinkum, your persona as a nuff-nuff is gold.

Cannot take a joke old chum?

Jokes aside, How did Riewoldt only receive two more votes in comparison to Kosi. Fevola one more than the blonde bombshell

[Milan Faletic]

How on earth did Kosi receive 11 votes compared to Roo's 13?

Kosi played well in a few games and was our best forward in those games but to come close to Riewoldt who has kicked double the goals and has infuence almost all matches is a little strange

Fevola too. If Kosi somehow received 11 then Fevola's season was worth double. Riewoldt triple on that

Thoughts?

For what it is worth Reincarnated is proud of the boys and 6-7 of them receiving 11+ votes and most getting in the top 10/15

Our boys have the quality and quantity

Good post. How can Kosi get 11 to Roo's 13? Astounding.

[Iceman234]

Because it's a midfielder's award.

Maybe folks are miguided thinking Roo is the Umpire's pet.

Kosi had a pretty good year impact-wise I thought.

Days of big forwards polling mid 20's are gone.

Apart from Jono Brown, but didn't notice the games he scored votes in.

[herni the second]

playing a handful of outstanding games will get you more votes than a year of consistency. Riewoldt has rarely lowered his colours this year but not so often been THE dominant force on the field.

[reincarnated]

Because it's a midfielder's award.

Maybe folks are miguided thinking Roo is the Umpire's pet.

Kosi had a pretty good year impact-wise I thought.

Days of big forwards polling mid 20's are gone.

Apart from Jono Brown, but didn't notice the games he scored votes in.

So if it is a midfielders award that has what to do with Kosi and Roo almost getting the same amount of votes?

Kosi has played a great year - however in Brownlow votes he pales (or should have) paled into minority compared to Riewoldts

[bigred]

umpires....

What do you expect.

[Iceman234]

Because it's a midfielder's award.

Maybe folks are miguided thinking Roo is the Umpire's pet.

Kosi had a pretty good year impact-wise I thought.

Days of big forwards polling mid 20's are gone.

Apart from Jono Brown, but didn't notice the games he scored votes in.

So if it is a midfielders award that has what to do with Kosi and Roo almost getting the same amount of votes?

Kosi has played a great year - however in Brownlow votes he pales (or should have) paled into minority compared to Riewoldts

Well midfielders pretty much always clean it up, big forwards are lucky to get more than 15 votes and backs are lucky to get a vote at all.

Doesn't mean they impact less or more, just means that the mids are under the Umpires noses all the time.

Your opinion on Kosi's year means nothing compared to my opinion and the Umpires' opinion.

Clearly the Umps see Kosi as having a fair impact.

Do you have an issue with Kosi maybe?

[SainterK]

Because it's a midfielder's award.

Maybe folks are miguided thinking Roo is the Umpire's pet.

Kosi had a pretty good year impact-wise I thought.

Days of big forwards polling mid 20's are gone.

Apart from Jono Brown, but didn't notice the games he scored votes in.

So if it is a midfielders award that has what to do with Kosi and Roo almost getting the same amount of votes?

Kosi has played a great year - however in Brownlow votes he pales (or should have) paled into minority compared to Riewoldts

His games were amazing though, purely for impact....he can impose himself on a game like no other. Also, remember Roo started the season off slowly...

[reincarnated]

Because it's a midfielder's award.

Maybe folks are miguided thinking Roo is the Umpire's pet.

Kosi had a pretty good year impact-wise I thought.

Days of big forwards polling mid 20's are gone.

Apart from Jono Brown, but didn't notice the games he scored votes in.

So if it is a midfielders award that has what to do with Kosi and Roo almost getting the same amount of votes?

Kosi has played a great year - however in Brownlow votes he pales (or should have) paled into minority compared to Riewoldts

Well midfielders pretty much always clean it up, big forwards are lucky to get more than 15 votes and backs are lucky to get a vote at all.

Doesn't mean they impact less or more, just means that the mids are under the Umpires noses all the time.

Your opinion on Kosi's year means nothing compared to my opinion and the Umpires' opinion.

Clearly the Umps see Kosi as having a fair impact.

Do you have an issue with Kosi maybe?

Kosi is a gun and a great full forward when we have another forward like Riewoldt getting the stats he is. To suggest Reincarnated has an issue with Kosi is clutching at straws and an attempt at a slanging match about nothing again

Kosi would kick 60/70+ playing in a team where he is the big number 1 forward

Again this has nothing to do with midfielders if both (well three including Fevola) are being judged on each other here and their annual performances respectively.

Your opinion also means nothing to Reincarnated however you posting that Reincarnateds opinion means nothing really was not necessary

[SENsei]

Nothing of substance.






Deal in team awards, not individual one's. And who gives a flying toss what votes umpires give?

[Milton66]

Nothing of substance.






Deal in team awards, not individual one's. And who gives a flying toss what votes umpires give?

Be careful... you might awaken Plugger66 and force him to defend the umpires.

[reincarnated]

Nothing of substance.






Deal in team awards, not individual one's. And who gives a flying toss what votes umpires give?

If one of our boys won the Brownlow you like everyone else would have been thrilled as and posting through joy

[SENsei]

Nothing of substance.






Deal in team awards, not individual one's. And who gives a flying toss what votes umpires give?

If one of our boys won the Brownlow you like everyone else would have been thrilled as and posting through joy

Yeah but not bitching about whether one player got 11 and one got 13!!

.FFS

[undecided]

Why the puck do you talk normal on bigfooty but not here

[reincarnated]

Why the puck do you talk normal on bigfooty but not here

Reincarnated asks what is bigfooty?