could milne get dropped

gosainters66 · Mon 21 Sep 2009 3:23pm

could milne get dropped because of his poor history in finals
armo could give a bit of grunt

matrix · Post: # 827417Post **matrix** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 3:23pm

be real

Mr Magic · Post: # 827420Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 3:24pm

gosainters66 wrote:could milne get dropped because of his poor history in finals
armo could give a bit of grunt

Are you JABBER under another name?

2 threads (including this one) you have started in a very similar posting style 2 him/her.

Justified sainter · Mon 21 Sep 2009 3:31pm

No way, although milne has not performed he's best in this finals series, i still think he's that x factor that could bob up and kick a few goals. Also if the weathers abit wet which they are predicting then he could be a handy crum since the forwards might struggle to take a clean grab.

DWOODROW · Post: # 827461Post **DWOODROW** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 3:51pm

If Armo did come in it wouldn't be for Milne. That's a strange one.

spert · Post: # 827473Post **spert** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 3:57pm

On form in finals- yes..he is primarily in the team a goal sneak, and too many tiimes the ball has hit the deck and he has been in the wrong position to crumb the loose ball. I bet Armo in the pocket would hit the pack a bit harder and probably slot a few.

ace · Post: # 827489Post **ace** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:03pm

Milne gets dropped by a Harley chopper.
Free to St Kilda.
Milne goals.
Saints win premiership.

Milton66 · Post: # 827492Post **Milton66** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:04pm

Derek Kickett send his regards.

kosifantutti23 · Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:05pm

Mr Magic wrote:
gosainters66 wrote:could milne get dropped because of his poor history in finals
armo could give a bit of grunt
Are you JABBER under another name?

2 threads (including this one) you have started in a very similar posting style 2 him/her.

I've heard Milne will be replaced by Alistair Smith

Milton66 · Post: # 827499Post **Milton66** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:06pm

It might just be the wake up call he needs for next year's NAB Cup

bergholt · Post: # 827532Post **bergholt** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:26pm

gosainters66 wrote:could milne get dropped because of his poor history in finals
armo could give a bit of grunt

kicked a pretty important one on friday night and had some useful touches flooding up the ground. i reckon he's playing his role ok, though not perfect, and definitely keeps his spot. schneider ahead of him in the queue for dropping - but neither will go.

InkerSaint · Post: # 827552Post **InkerSaint** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:40pm

Milne won't lose his spot off the back of a couple of quiet games. Ross has said he and Schneider need to lift... that's about as far as it will go.

Eddy is probably the only player on the fringe... may go out for Dempster or Gwilt... but my guess is... no change.

SaintHomer · Post: # 827555Post **SaintHomer** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:43pm

St. Luke · Post: # 827561Post **St. Luke** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:46pm

Just gotta roll the dice with Milney - he may just turn it on and be a match winner in a game like this! Too much of a risk dropping him IMHO

saintDal · Post: # 827565Post **saintDal** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 4:49pm

I reckon give him one last chance. If he screws up I wouldn't be surpised to see him get dropped for the next week

Darrel Baldock · Mon 21 Sep 2009 5:11pm

Silly

Grimfang · Post: # 827822Post **Grimfang** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 7:35pm

Does anyone remember how Stephen Milne first came to the attention of the Saints?

He killed us in the 1999 Reserves Grand Final, playing for Essendon.

I think he's due for a repeat performance, this time against the Cats!

JABBER · Post: # 827831Post **JABBER** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 7:43pm

Mr Magic when have i said Milne should be dropped the only player i think will be dropped is Eddy and i would bring in Dempster. Milne done great work last week up the ground to help out in defence

bozza1980 · Post: # 827853Post **bozza1980** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 7:50pm

Milton66 wrote:It might just be the wake up call he needs for next year's NAB Cup

Fair call, we should probably make a few more moves to get us ready for the NAB Cup.

Quite a few players haven't played for a month already, if we want them to be match fit this is the last chance to play them.

bozza1980 · Post: # 827868Post **bozza1980** » Mon 21 Sep 2009 8:00pm

spert wrote:On form in finals- yes..he is primarily in the team a goal sneak, and too many tiimes the ball has hit the deck and he has been in the wrong position to crumb the loose ball. I bet Armo in the pocket would hit the pack a bit harder and probably slot a few.

Milne v Armitage??

One is arguably the best goal sneak in the AFL, unquestionably ours.

One is probably ranked 25-30 on our list.

One hasn't played for a month and really hasn't knocked down the door.

One is our 3rd leading goal scorer.

I know which one I'd plump for, too be fair I can't believe they are even being compared.

could milne get dropped

could milne get dropped

Re: could milne get dropped

Re: could milne get dropped

Re: could milne get dropped

could milne get dropped this week