I wish Riewoldt was as good a kick for goal as Buddy.

[kosifantutti23]

Discuss.

[ralphsmith]

hahhaha

He's 10 times the player Buddy is.

Buddy may be freakish, but he lacks the heart, spirit, the motivation.

[meher baba]

They're both great players IMO. But Riewoldt was king tonight.

Even though his last goal was touched off the boot IMO....

[ausfatcat]

Discuss.

pfft look up who is more accurate before making those statements.


4.1 tonight and you bring this up buddy would've kicked 2.3 or 1.4. Buddy is a terrible kick for goal (unless it gets him some good photo's).

[Launcestonsaint]

Roo kicked 4.1, how many did Franklin kick?

[SainterK]

But he isn't as good, he is actually trending better at the business end of the season

[golden hawk]

hahhaha

He's 10 times the player Buddy is.

Buddy may be freakish, but he lacks the heart, spirit, the motivation.

now come on they are both great players in their right !!!! if you saw replay that ball was touched same time as it was kicked ball did not deviate and as commentators said that can happen all the time it was called a goal and is a goal would not have mattered if it was not i think you still would have won just by a closer margin

[kosifantutti23]

Don't be so defensive.

Recognise sarcasm when you see it. Sorry if I didn't use an emoticon.

There was a huge thread with that title last year. I think it got locked eventually. I was just feeling some nostalgia for it.

Roo was brilliant. Kicked the winner and the sealer.

[SaintDebi]

Even though his last goal was touched off the boot IMO....

So glad it was a seven point win. Nobody can take it away from us. Touched or not it would have still been a win.

[golden hawk]

Discuss.

pfft look up who is more accurate before making those statements.


4.1 tonight and you bring this up buddy would've kicked 2.3 or 1.4. Buddy is a terrible kick for goal (unless it gets him some good photo's).

buddy has not been good for half the year due to the surgery that he had on his hand and shoulder the main problem was the hand there was an interview that even said as much earlier !
if fit and firing buddy can and will kick a bag full ! same goes with nick !

in my books they are both great players they bring crowds to the game just to watch them play , yes buddy's year has been crap but he did kick over 60 goals this year with a bung hand at that ! !

[OneEyedSainter77]

There are either some gullible idiots on this thread or people are playing along with the OP.

Either way, I don't care because we are in the farking Grand Final BABY, YEAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!

[golden hawk]

Even though his last goal was touched off the boot IMO....

So glad it was a seven point win. Nobody can take it away from us. Touched or not it would have still been a win.

it may have been a 2 point win if they called it touched which i myself am glad they did not the hand and boot hit same time ball did not deviate at all but hey if ump saw it he would have to be the one to decide !

[stkfc_obsessed]

Rooey > you

[golden hawk]

Don't be so defensive.

Recognise sarcasm when you see it. Sorry if I didn't use an emoticon.

There was a huge thread with that title last year. I think it got locked eventually. I was just feeling some nostalgia for it.

Roo was brilliant. Kicked the winner and the sealer.

he did and i am happy he did too god that was such a nail biter

[Enrico_Misso]

I've said it before.
Nick Riewoldt is well on the way to becoming the greatest player in our history.

Greater than the Doc, Stewart, Smith, Breen Harvey, etc. etc.

He's not there yet.
But he's taken some massive steps this month.

Destiny awaits.

[Milan Faletic]

Nick Riewoldt is the best player I have ever seen. I said that in 2004.

[Winmar]

He is more than slightly inspirational.