Qualifying Final team - facebook

doggerel · Post: # 810248Post **doggerel** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:07pm

Qualifying Final St Kilda Team: IN - M Gardiner, L Ball, J Geary, M Hudghton OUT - B McEvoy. A final 22 will be named on Friday.

SainterK · Post: # 810251Post **SainterK** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:07pm

Great, I have about as much as idea as I did 5 minutes ago....

35...LEGEND · Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:08pm

nice bunch of in's

in; gardi,bally,geary

out ; big mac,eddy,ray/dempster.

d roit · Post: # 810254Post **d roit** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:08pm

ohwhenthesaints! wrote:Great, I have about as much as idea as I did 5 minutes ago....

Tell me about it...

saint75 · Post: # 810257Post **saint75** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:08pm

As there is only one out, it will still mean that Max and Bally are still no certainty. I really want to see both of them in the side.

Saintschampions08 · Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:09pm

saint75 wrote:As there is only one out, it will still mean that Max and Bally are still no certainty. I really want to see both of them in the side.

I'm inclined to think Bally is, but not so sure about Max.

SainterK · Post: # 810259Post **SainterK** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:10pm

I guess it will keep everyone guessing, and that's the idea really....

Best of luck to everyone involved.

Unforgiven · Post: # 810265Post **Unforgiven** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:12pm

Saintschampions08 wrote:
saint75 wrote:As there is only one out, it will still mean that Max and Bally are still no certainty. I really want to see both of them in the side.
I'm inclined to think Bally is, but not so sure about Max.

I would agree with this one.

plugger66 · Post: # 810267Post **plugger66** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:13pm

Yep outs tomorrow Eddy, max and geary.

thirty-seven!? · Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:13pm

Unforgiven wrote:
Saintschampions08 wrote:
saint75 wrote:As there is only one out, it will still mean that Max and Bally are still no certainty. I really want to see both of them in the side.
I'm inclined to think Bally is, but not so sure about Max.
I would agree with this one.

Will have more info when we see team sheets and who is on the bench!
Hopefully Eddy is out... Dempster could also be in jeopardy of losing his spot to Gears...

SainterK · Post: # 810274Post **SainterK** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:17pm

Whoever misses out, hope they keep their chin up....I am proud that we have a team where the decision is such a difficult one.

thirty-seven!? · Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:20pm

ST KILDA
B: Farren Ray, Zac Dawson, Steven Baker
HB: Sam Fisher, Jason Blake, Sam Gilbert
C: Brendon Goddard, Lenny Hayes, Nick Dal Santo
HF: Andrew McQualter, Justin Koschitzke, Clint Jones
F: Stephen Milne, Nick Riewoldt, Jason Gram
Foll: Steven King, Leigh Montagna, Adam Schneider
Int (from): Luke Ball, Raphael Clarke, Sean Dempster, Robert Eddy, Michael Gardiner, Jarryn Geary, Max Hudghton

In: M.Gardiner, L.Ball, J.Geary, M.Hudghton
Out: B.McEvoy

MilneyMagic · Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:25pm

Ripper team!!

Could not be more confident!!!!!

Go you Sainters!!

hotdish · Post: # 810299Post **hotdish** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 6:34pm

MY FINAL CHANGES:

In: M Gardiner, L Ball
Out: McEvoy, Eddy

Ball must be chomping at the bit to play finals - IT HAS BEEN 3 YEARS SINCE L BALL HAS PLAYED A FINAL!!! V Melbourne in GT's last game...

eppo67 · Post: # 810332Post **eppo67** » Thu 03 Sep 2009 7:15pm

Legand 35 are you kidding!!
Ray one of you prefered outs? WTF

midas_touch · Thu 03 Sep 2009 7:17pm

agree with hotdish. bally in, max to miss out.

35...LEGEND · Fri 04 Sep 2009 8:04am

eppo67 wrote:Legand 35 are you kidding!!
Ray one of you prefered outs? WTF

Out of him and Dempster ,would rather Ray in the side .

Was only last week i was pumping him up.....but to take on the roll of "lead up forward',to which i think he'd be suited.

Just think he's been a bit quiet for a while('cruise mode','comfort zone' )Seem's to go missing for long periods during games and need's to be challenged (woken up a bit) with either a different role or a week on the sidelines.....worked for Dal and Milney and hopefully Bally too.

Nothin worse than having guys in the side that think they are a shoe in for a game every week.

Just my opinion............which means Jack at the end of the day.

Hurricane · Post: # 810602Post **Hurricane** » Fri 04 Sep 2009 10:17am

hotdish wrote:MY FINAL CHANGES:

In: M Gardiner, L Ball
Out: McEvoy, Eddy

Ball must be chomping at the bit to play finals - IT HAS BEEN 3 YEARS SINCE L BALL HAS PLAYED A FINAL!!! V Melbourne in GT's last game...

Agree 100% with this

Bally and MG have experiance in finals and it will be invaluable on Sunday

BANG BANG

BaysideSaint · Fri 04 Sep 2009 1:02pm

yeah, interesting isn't it. great team, no gwilt (which makes a lot of people happy) but yeah, no gwilt. thanks for your service jimmy, just doesn't seem to be in the best 22 (naturally) just interesting, no jimmy from here on in one feels.

meher baba · Post: # 810815Post **meher baba** » Fri 04 Sep 2009 2:17pm

BaysideSaint wrote:yeah, interesting isn't it. great team, no gwilt (which makes a lot of people happy) but yeah, no gwilt. thanks for your service jimmy, just doesn't seem to be in the best 22 (naturally) just interesting, no jimmy from here on in one feels.

Who says he's finished for the year?

I wouldn't have selected Jimmy against the Pies: when you look at the backline we are up against, I don't reckon Jimmy is needed.

However, he could be pretty useful against the Dogs and perhaps even the Cats.

meher baba · Post: # 810826Post **meher baba** » Fri 04 Sep 2009 2:23pm

P.S. I have a sinking feeling that the final 22 will be either

IN: Gardi
OUT: McEvoy

or

IN: Ball, Gardi
OUT: McEvoy, Raph

I hope it isn't the case, but I strongly suspect that we will be watching both Eddy and Dempster running around on the MCG on Sunday.

The idea with the second option would be for Ball to replace Eddy in the middle, Eddy to play as a sort of lead-up forward, and Dempster to play down back where Raph has been.

It is my suspicion that Ross is intending to for us to switch to being much more defensive for the finals than we have been in the home and away. A bit more lock-down and a bit less attacking the ball and ball carrier.

I really hope I'm wrong about this, but I feel it "in my waters".