Unwatchable due to umpiring

jonesy · Post: # 791113Post **jonesy** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:39pm

Absolute disgrace.

Good too see these beaten up at school for lunch money flogs got on the mid week plunge also

plugger66 · Post: # 791118Post **plugger66** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:41pm

jonesy wrote:Absolute disgrace.

Good too see these beaten up at school for lunch money flogs got on the mid week plunge also

We have 2 from frees they have one.

Spinner · Post: # 791135Post **Spinner** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:45pm

jonesy wrote:Absolute disgrace.

Good too see these beaten up at school for lunch money flogs got on the mid week plunge also

Yep, bent over that quarter.

Animal Enclosure · Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:47pm

plugger66 wrote:
jonesy wrote:Absolute disgrace.

Good too see these beaten up at school for lunch money flogs got on the mid week plunge also
We have 2 from frees they have one.

What's the count now Plugger? One of those two should have been the most obvious advantage but no, bring it back make Schneider kick it from 45.

Your fair dinkum let yourself down with your umpire protection at times.

Disgusting umpiring. Worse commentating. Kelli U the only bright spot!

backit · Post: # 791149Post **backit** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:47pm

The umpiring so far is very ordinary, one minute they protect the man over the ball getting hit next time they don't, at the moment the umpiring is inconsistent. More free kicks were paid in that qtr than in some games this year. Hawks Renouf received a gift 50 metres closer to being 75 metres resulting in a goal.

plugger66 · Post: # 791152Post **plugger66** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:48pm

Animal Enclosure wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
jonesy wrote:Absolute disgrace.

Good too see these beaten up at school for lunch money flogs got on the mid week plunge also
We have 2 from frees they have one.
What's the count now Plugger? One of those two should have been the most obvious advantage but no, bring it back make Schneider kick it from 45.

Your fair dinkum let yourself down with your umpire protection at times.

Disgusting umpiring. Worse commentating. Kelli U the only bright spot!

Dont know the count but we are in front. Do you watch the footy or the umpires.

jonesy · Post: # 791153Post **jonesy** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:49pm

backit wrote:The umpiring so far is very ordinary, one minute they protect the man over the ball getting hit next time they don't, at the moment the umpiring is inconsistent. More free kicks were paid in that qtr than in some games this year. Hawks Renouf received a gift 50 metres closer to being 75 metres resulting in a goal.

It's the new compensation rule ...hawks kicking into breeze,so we'll give them an extra 25 meters

Iceman234 · Post: # 791158Post **Iceman234** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:53pm

Example then - Hodge had no right after being told the free was against him, to continue after the ball when BB was trying to pick it up - then Hodge picked it up and was told to give it up immediately.

Should have been 50 - Hodge clearly knew it wasn't his free

Moorabbin Saints · Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:53pm

My god these commentators are appalling!

Who's winning the game?

Iceman234 · Post: # 791162Post **Iceman234** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:56pm

Okay defenders of umpires - explain the Rioli one!!!

backit · Post: # 791163Post **backit** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 3:57pm

If Sam Mitchell is not the umpires pet today. He has been caught twice and disposed of the ball illegally without penalty.

Rioli took two on got caught and it was a ball up, go figure. Even the commentators are struggling unerstanding the umpiring out there.

Splayd · Post: # 791170Post **Splayd** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:00pm

Rioli can do what he wnts as well.

has 30 mins and takes on 3 players and tackled - ball up.

Effing disgrace.

mullet · Post: # 791171Post **mullet** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:00pm

perhaps the big plunge bets early in the week came from afl house

Splayd · Post: # 791185Post **Splayd** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:06pm

mullet wrote:perhaps the big plunge bets early in the week came from afl house

like it. Dodgy B*st*rds

cowboy18 · Post: # 791194Post **cowboy18** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:09pm

Are the AFL resting their star umpires this week?

mullet · Post: # 791213Post **mullet** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:13pm

cowboy18 wrote:Are the AFL resting their star umpires this week?

umm they would, but they dont have any

Spinner · Post: # 791271Post **Spinner** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:31pm

Splayd wrote:Rioli can do what he wnts as well.

has 30 mins and takes on 3 players and tackled - ball up.

Effing disgrace.

They should cut that vision onto tape and send it to the umpires association in an envelope titled 'player favoritism'.

That piece was a disgrace but what is more despicable is how often that sort occurs when a player named Judd, Ablett, Rioli etc is the main feature.

backit · Post: # 791274Post **backit** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:31pm

mullet wrote:
cowboy18 wrote:Are the AFL resting their star umpires this week?
umm they would, but they dont have any

Yes they do just ask them, they believe they are the centre of attention every game. It's about them not the players or the game.

saint66au · Post: # 791276Post **saint66au** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:32pm

plugger66 wrote:
Animal Enclosure wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
jonesy wrote:Absolute disgrace.

Good too see these beaten up at school for lunch money flogs got on the mid week plunge also
We have 2 from frees they have one.
What's the count now Plugger? One of those two should have been the most obvious advantage but no, bring it back make Schneider kick it from 45.

Your fair dinkum let yourself down with your umpire protection at times.

Disgusting umpiring. Worse commentating. Kelli U the only bright spot!
Dont know the count but we are in front. Do you watch the footy or the umpires.

See all you do in these match threads is hover around taking pot shots at others opinions and commenting at anything lucky going St Kildas way

Im all for trying to keep both eyes open but the least likely place to find that is while a Saints game is on lol

claystreet · Post: # 791279Post **claystreet** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:33pm

Umpires want the Dawks in

it easy to see

although the Dawks deserved a few early ones coz the lads were smakin em about a bit

matrix · Post: # 791282Post **matrix** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:33pm

Splayd wrote:Rioli can do what he wnts as well.

has 30 mins and takes on 3 players and tackled - ball up.

Effing disgrace.

yup and then buddy got the dish and pushed past one and got tackled

nuffin

degruch · Post: # 791297Post **degruch** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:39pm

Disgrace...as predicted. If it wasn't for Simon Taylor, we'd barely have a kick. And why the hell wasn't that appalling bounce King 'roved' off Taylor not called back?

HOWEVER, encouraging to see finally Mitchell called holding a couple times...although there seems to be an armistice on Dawks players trying to break packs and being caught.

joffaboy · Post: # 791300Post **joffaboy** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:39pm

We started to get the frees as we got on top though.

But is there now a 75 metre penalty? Sure the Hawks got one in the 1st qtr.

degruch · Post: # 791305Post **degruch** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:41pm

degruch wrote:Disgrace...as predicted. If it wasn't for Simon Taylor, we'd barely have a kick. And why the hell wasn't that appalling bounce King 'roved' off Taylor not called back?

HOWEVER, encouraging to see finally Mitchell called holding a couple times...although there seems to be an armistice on Dawks players trying to break packs and being caught.

HA! Just recalled one that advantaged the Saints!

ben_fff · Post: # 791330Post **ben_fff** » Sat 08 Aug 2009 4:57pm

ump's have been poor for both sides today.

Unwatchable due to umpiring

Unwatchable due to umpiring

Re: Unwatchable due to umpiring

Re: Unwatchable due to umpiring

Re: Unwatchable due to umpiring

Re: Unwatchable due to umpiring

Re: Unwatchable due to umpiring