Game lost at selection table

Wolfpak · Post: # 781138Post **Wolfpak** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:24pm

With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.
No Gardiner or Goose. Huge problem. Maybe Gilbert will play forward.
Again Stkilda you are going back to your old tricks.. ......
What is wrong with Gardner and Ball and why will you not play Goose.
Please let us supporters know.

saintsrus · Post: # 781149Post **saintsrus** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:34pm

thanks for the tip, i wont go now

geez at 16-0 the club seem to know what they are doing or have we been lucky?

claystreet · Post: # 781150Post **claystreet** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:34pm

Wolfpak wrote:With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.
No Gardiner or Goose. Huge problem. Maybe Gilbert will play forward.
Again Stkilda you are going back to your old tricks.. ......
What is wrong with Gardner and Ball and why will you not play Goose.
Please let us supporters know.

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

Loser

Wolfpak · Post: # 781151Post **Wolfpak** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:34pm

i am, you just never know

VietNam_Saint · Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:37pm

claystreet wrote:
Wolfpak wrote:
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.

Loser

Shouldn't that be a looser

vacuous space · Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:39pm

Wolfpak wrote:With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.

Just like last time, eh?

InkerSaint · Post: # 781164Post **InkerSaint** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:40pm

Wolfpak wrote:With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.
No Gardiner or Goose. Huge problem. Maybe Gilbert will play forward.
Again Stkilda you are going back to your old tricks.. ......
What is wrong with Gardner and Ball and why will you not play Goose.
Please let us supporters know.

I'll humour you.

Goose is unproven in our current team structure.

Gardiner is out injured.

Ball is not hitting the indicators for his team role.

All on public record.

Why is it that we all know these things and you don't?

Bulldogs supporter perhaps?

St Fidelius · Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:41pm

Wolfpak wrote:With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.
No Gardiner or Goose. Huge problem. Maybe Gilbert will play forward.
Again Stkilda you are going back to your old tricks.. ......
What is wrong with Gardner and Ball and why will you not play Goose.
Please let us supporters know.

Goose has simply not being playing that well for Sandi...

If Goose is to be selected he would have to be near on BOG for about 3 weeks.

Having said that he is an emergency maybe just in case Max does not get up

saint66au · Post: # 781167Post **saint66au** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:42pm

Wolfpak wrote:With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.
No Gardiner or Goose. Huge problem. Maybe Gilbert will play forward.
Again Stkilda you are going back to your old tricks.. ......
What is wrong with Gardner and Ball and why will you not play Goose.
Please let us supporters know.

Off you go to Facebook with all the other clueless fans

James · Post: # 781169Post **James** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:46pm

As we know, two superstar smalls, a superstar tall and a cast of half a dozen players rotating through is not enough.

If we play well, we'll find avenues to goal.

Scratching my head over why Gwilt continues to get a game with all the quality in our reserves.

vacuous space · Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:50pm

Here's the changes for both teams since last time:

St Kilda:
IN: R. Clarke, Dempster, Hudghton, King, McEvoy
OUT: Ball, Dawson, Gardiner, Geary, Koschitzke

Bulldogs:
IN: Ward, Welsh, Williams
OUT: Addison, Everitt, Giansiracusa

Considering the last result, can anybody really say that this game has been 'lost' at the selection table?

EDIT: got it woefully wrong first go. Thanks to 'perfectionist' for living up to his name and picking it up.

st.byron · Post: # 781174Post **st.byron** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:51pm

James wrote:
Scratching my head over why Gwilt continues to get a game with all the quality in our reserves.

Must be because when he's in he does what Lyon asks him to. As for the OP,

saintbrat · Post: # 781178Post **saintbrat** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 6:56pm

Game lost at selection table

have I missed the weekend?

I dont have to work another 5 days straight do I?

saintsRrising · Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:00pm

James wrote:

Scratching my head over why Gwilt continues to get a game with all the quality in our reserves.

1/ Gwilt has played many games forward this year...and while he did not star...he did not play poorly either...he did ok.

2/ He has a mature body. Being hard and tough is one aspect that we need to do to win. Someone like Lynch is promising...but he does not have a mature body.

Munga · Post: # 781182Post **Munga** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:01pm

16-0, yep they're really dudding their supporters!

St Fidelius · Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:06pm

Munga wrote:16-0, yep they're really dudding their supporters!

Yep, I just have a feeling that the OP is a "c**k with ears"

BallBanger · Post: # 781191Post **BallBanger** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:17pm

St Fidelius wrote:
Wolfpak wrote:With the absence of Kosi, we only now have one tall forward being in Roo.
The bulldogs will double tag Roo and we will loose game.
No Gardiner or Goose. Huge problem. Maybe Gilbert will play forward.
Again Stkilda you are going back to your old tricks.. ......
What is wrong with Gardner and Ball and why will you not play Goose.
Please let us supporters know.
Goose has simply not being playing that well for Sandi...

If Goose is to be selected he would have to be near on BOG for about 3 weeks.

Having said that he is an emergency maybe just in case Max does not get up

Agree that goose has to show better form but gwilt was dropped because of consistant bad form then he was worst for sandy in the last 2 games

Why would you promote him then?
At their best goose is far superior alternatively goose is not as bad when at the bottom end

Like Eddy, Gwilt must be extremely fit and hard trainer...
Good to reward players for effort but surely ability has also its advantages...

perfectionist · Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:21pm

vacuous space wrote:Here's the changes for both teams since last time:

St Kilda:
IN: Eddy, Hudghton, McEvoy
OUT: Dawson, Gardiner, Geary

Bulldogs:
IN: Ward, Welsh, Williams
OUT: Addison, Everitt, Giansiracusa...

Nope.

St Kilda:
In: Max Hudghton, Ben McEvoy, Sean Dempster, Steven King, Raph Clarke
Out: Luke Ball, Kosi, Michael Gardiner, Jarryn Geary, Zac Dawson

vacuous space · Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:23pm

perfectionist wrote:Nope.

Did I at least get the doggies right?

Either way, I don't see any cause for concern at the selection table.

degruch · Post: # 781201Post **degruch** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:37pm

Nice to see some of our supporters taking stock of the team's wonderful efforts this season, the superb coaching and our talented line-up leading up to the contest with the Bulldogs.

BigMart · Post: # 781212Post **BigMart** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:45pm

I agree.......a poor selection...

Gwilt <GOP
Eddy <GOP
McEvoy <GOP (at this stage) but a fair inclusion as a second ruck....

No exposure for the accomplished Lynch, or the talented Armitage is not getting an opportunity?????.....

And Goose should just not bother training and start his pre-season early at Carlton...

Riewoldt may have three opponents....his, plus eddy's and Gwilts to contend with.....because they will pay about as much respect to them as England pay to our <GOBowlingAttack

claystreet · Post: # 781218Post **claystreet** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 7:52pm

Wolfcrack go back to where it is you crawled out from

I feel a bit looser now

ace · Post: # 781225Post **ace** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 8:01pm

saintbrat wrote:
Game lost at selection table
have I missed the weekend?

I dont have to work another 5 days straight do I?

No but if you work for Visy your boss may require you to do five days work in one.
That's because 11 employees who play for Carlton don't do any work.
And they would all be paid more than you.

Devilhead · Post: # 781231Post **Devilhead** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 8:11pm

BigMart wrote:I agree.......a poor selection...

Gwilt <GOP
Eddy <GOP
McEvoy <GOP (at this stage) but a fair inclusion as a second ruck....

No exposure for the accomplished Lynch, or the talented Armitage is not getting an opportunity?????.....

And Goose should just not bother training and start his pre-season early at Carlton...

Riewoldt may have three opponents....his, plus eddy's and Gwilts to contend with.....because they will pay about as much respect to them as England pay to our <GOBowlingAttack

Hear Hear BigM knows his s***

Sack that gumby coach Lyon and appoint BigMart

Lyon knows jackshite about coaching and football

BigMart is a proven tactian and has the runs on the board

s*** while we are at it lets sack Trevor Cooley and bring in BM as Australia's bowling coach what do we have to lose

BigMart knows his s*** cause he is the s***

Cheers to BM cheers to our hack coach Lyon cheers to England's batting attack cheers to the Bulldogs smashing us on Saturday night cheers to Firthy cheers to Eastern's wallet cheers to not resting players cheers to playing players that will more than likely play a part in finals than other players who will not get a look in cheers to not playing those players because they probably wont play a part in finals cheers to bagging out the selection team cheers to 16 zip cheers to 170% cheers to top 2 cheers to cheers

plugger66 · Post: # 781232Post **plugger66** » Thu 23 Jul 2009 8:11pm

BigMart wrote:I agree.......a poor selection...

Gwilt <GOP
Eddy <GOP
McEvoy <GOP (at this stage) but a fair inclusion as a second ruck....

No exposure for the accomplished Lynch, or the talented Armitage is not getting an opportunity?????.....

And Goose should just not bother training and start his pre-season early at Carlton...

Riewoldt may have three opponents....his, plus eddy's and Gwilts to contend with.....because they will pay about as much respect to them as England pay to our <GOBowlingAttack

Goose< GOP this year
Armitage hasnt played for 3 weeks and not even sure this week
Lynch young up and comer not quite ready for the big league.

McEvoy has to play as MG is fit. Eddy is in because Bally isnt fit enough and Gwilt did nothing wrong when playing in the ones.

It is the best side we can put on the park or do you think RL wants to lose.

Game lost at selection table

Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table

Re: Game lost at selection table