Gardiner

[Wolfpak]

Well as i said yesterday that Gardiner was not going to play. And yet many people questioned my rumor. Well gee looks like SEN came through with the goods. Oh another rumor, Kosi wont play next week.

[iwantmeseats]

we donty give a s*** about whatever the hell you claim nimrod. Just get on board, and stop trying to pathetically one up yourself. FFS

[The Saintsational Man]

Calm down rookie.

[saintsRrising]

Well as i said yesterday that Gardiner was not going to play. And yet many people questioned my rumor..

You actually did not say that at all. You said someone on SEN said so and then refused to add any additinional information as to whom the source was.


You were asked about who made the comment on SEN.


Forumites were not having a go at you...that just wanted to know who the source was.


That you cannot understand such a simple request and concept is your lack and not the forums.

If you loom later in the thread you will see that othe forumites added additional information.

[Wolfpak]

yes but was i right that is the question

[Mr Magic]

yes but was i right that is the question

Well to answer your question:-

Heard on sen that GArdiner could be out of Stklida Team. Any confirmations?

No you were wrong.
You asked if anybody could confirm what you heard on SEN asd nobody could.

What exactly are you looking for - A 'gold star'?

[mick13]

yes but was i right that is the question

Want a cookie?

[SainterK]

I personally appreciate any info, and after all it was right....

[Mr Magic]

I personally appreciate any info, and after all it was right....

What info - he posted that he heard on SEN that Gardiner wasn't playing and could anybody else confirm it?

He never posted that he knew Gardiner wasn't going to play.

He also posted (I believe,or was that someone else?) that Van Berlo wasn't going to play from the same source (heard it on SEN). Is anybody claiming 'credit' for that rumour as well?

[66 Saints]

there's some high horses that ride in these parts...

really depends on how you want to play the words.

the rumour was right.

If a mate told me he'd heard a rumour about something which turned out to be true, the next time I saw him I'd say 'hey you were right about such and such..."

reckon Wolfpak's OP was reasonable. stated rumour and asked if anyone else could confirm. if he had a credible source would he have stated it was a rumour and asked for confirmation?

[mustangjack]

Thanks wolf for the info and yes I did believe you, as if anyone who seen the gard on the bench last week wouldnt know something was up . Keep me informed mate . I listen to sen missed that one though good work

[Mr Magic]

there's some high horses that ride in these parts...

really depends on how you want to play the words.

the rumour was right.

If a mate told me he'd heard a rumour about something which turned out to be true, the next time I saw him I'd say 'hey you were right about such and such..."

reckon Wolfpak's OP was reasonable. stated rumour and asked if anyone else could confirm. if he had a credible source would he have stated it was a rumour and asked for confirmation?

I would agree with you if that is what actually happened.
But it's not.
Posters asked him/her a simple question - was it a presenter or caller who floated the rumour?
He/she chose not to respond to those, IMO, reasonable requests.

Now he/she comes back on looking for a 'slap on the back' for his 'inside info' that Gardiner wasn't playing.

[Winmar]

And why make a new thread about it instead of posting in the existing one?

[VietNam_Saint]

Well as i said yesterday that Gardiner was not going to play. And yet many people questioned my rumor. Well gee looks like SEN came through with the goods. Oh another rumor, Kosi wont play next week.

What ,, are you twelve ? Give that boy a gold star.

[VietNam_Saint]

there's some high horses that ride in these parts...

really depends on how you want to play the words.

the rumour was right.

If a mate told me he'd heard a rumour about something which turned out to be true, the next time I saw him I'd say 'hey you were right about such and such..."

reckon Wolfpak's OP was reasonable. stated rumour and asked if anyone else could confirm. if he had a credible source would he have stated it was a rumour and asked for confirmation?

And you must be his mother I reckon.

[SainterK]

I don't get to listen to the radio an awful lot, so if something like that is floating around I would like to know.

This isn't about back patting the OP, not at all....but I would still like people to post any potential news on here.

[Moccha]

yes but was i right that is the question

You weren't right, the caller on SEN was

[66 Saints]

And you must be his mother I reckon.

[/quote]

yawn

[Shaggy]

I personally appreciate any info, and after all it was right....

What info - he posted that he heard on SEN that Gardiner wasn't playing and could anybody else confirm it?

He never posted that he knew Gardiner wasn't going to play.

He also posted (I believe,or was that someone else?) that Van Berlo wasn't going to play from the same source (heard it on SEN). Is anybody claiming 'credit' for that rumour as well?

Thanks to wolf I didn't expect Gards to play today. Thanks Wolf for helping me get prepared . Its nice to be informed with an element of scepticsm .

[Mr Magic]

I don't get to listen to the radio an awful lot, so if something like that is floating around I would like to know.

This isn't about back patting the OP, not at all....but I would still like people to post any potential news on here.

Fine,
On SEN tonight I heard the following:-
Kosi has a broken hand
Kosi has split webbing
Kosi will be rubbed out
Kosi won't be rubbed out
Ball was dropped
Ball was rested
Ball was injured
Gardiner was rested
Gardiner was injured

Which one(s) of these rumours do you want to believe?

Unfortunately, like the op, I'm not prepared to tell you if it was just callers spreading the rumours or if it was someone from SEN.

There are many rumours every day on SEN, some from teh presenters, many from listeners. Unless the person poting those rumours on here wants to tell teh rest of us the sources (presenters or listeners) we have no way of knowing how accurate those rumours are likely to be?

[Sainternist]

Well as i said yesterday that Gardiner was not going to play. And yet many people questioned my rumor. Well gee looks like SEN came through with the goods. Oh another rumor, Kosi wont play next week.

don't worry, jimmy olsen. one day you'll get your opportunity to make into the editorial

[ace]

Answer the big question - will Gardiner play against the Mongrels this coming weekend.

[SainterK]

So it's a calf injury? Does anyone know how serious it is, or if it was just a precautionary week off for the big guy?

I think if he is right to come back in, they may move McEvoy forward if Kosi is not playing....

[matrix]

i thought they were icing a hammie
maybe it was a calf

[plugger66]

From what I gather MG has a very slight calf strain and could have played if it was a GF so must be a big chance on Saturday night. He wasnt rested though as RL has said. I would just expect in the next 6 weeks players with injuries that they would usually play with will not play.