It was a team effort.
Everyone gave their all, we didn't rely on any superstar efforts besides Gardiner dragging us over the line. Yes, we wouldn't have won without his pearler but usually we rely on 4 or 5 total superstars and little else from anyone. Only having to need one player stand up is very promising - when Gardiner isn't up to it, it might be Riewoldt or Kosi or Milne... see what I mean?
Apart from the best three in Hayes, Gilbert and Gardiner, I can't split who was the best out their today. Everyone was great. We had 5+ goals in difference squeezed out of the game by the umpires today, so this wasn't the struggle it looked like. We were better than them by miles.
Keep going Saints.
Best part about today...
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
-
busso mick
- Club Player
- Posts: 1212
- Joined: Wed 17 Mar 2004 8:57pm
- Been thanked: 10 times
-
desertsaint
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 10431
- Joined: Sun 27 Apr 2008 2:02pm
- Location: out there
- Has thanked: 190 times
- Been thanked: 713 times
geary, yeah. mcevoy beaten. maybe also ray? milne? that's about as far as i can get.desertsaint wrote:okay - name them, i can't! geary was quiet, but 1/2 dozen?BigMart wrote:I disagree.....I believe we had half a dozen passengers today (easy to name).....but some herculian efforts by others.....Lenny Hayes for one...awesome player.......machine..
Geary spent at least a major portion of the first three quarters sacrificing his game, running up the ground to drag harley out of defense. Notice how uncongested our forward fifty was?? how they didnt have Harley drifitng across to chop out and two team our forwards???bergholt wrote:geary, yeah. mcevoy beaten. maybe also ray? milne? that's about as far as i can get.desertsaint wrote:okay - name them, i can't! geary was quiet, but 1/2 dozen?BigMart wrote:I disagree.....I believe we had half a dozen passengers today (easy to name).....but some herculian efforts by others.....Lenny Hayes for one...awesome player.......machine..
Given this oppotunity, Roo and Kosi smashed their respective opponents, and Geary did have valuable possessions and tackles up the ground.
Sometimes, hell a lot of times, footy isn't just scored on a stats sheet, its the things yo do when you don't have the ball that determine the outcome of many games.
I'm sorry, you've gone through all the trouble to find out what this actually says and it really is quite insignificant.
-
St Chris
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2153
- Joined: Wed 05 Apr 2006 2:20pm
- Has thanked: 4 times
- Been thanked: 41 times
I reckon Bartel and Selwood will get the 3 and the 2. Both awesome players and almost on par with Hayes for grit and determination. Would love to see them in a saints jumper.James wrote:Top three will be Gilbert, Hayes and Gardiner in any order. It was an entirely even field past those three.saintDal wrote:Brownlow votes for this game will be interesting. A lot of good players but not a lot of standouts.
Probably one for either Lenny or Gilbert.
-
Moods
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4951
- Joined: Fri 05 Jun 2009 3:05pm
- Has thanked: 343 times
- Been thanked: 497 times
I reckon everyone contributed today. Rapt that some on here have pointed out what Geary was doing - on MMM harley was voted third worst on the ground. His influence was crucial to negate due to the fact that our power fwds are our strength. Milney was a bit quiet but still had 10 possies and a crucial goal in the last 1/4 meant he contributed. McEvoy did what he could for a 19 year old kid playing his 7th of 8th game.
If anything I thought Luke Ball was poss our quietest and least effectual player. He was on Selwood for most of the game wasn't he? I thought Selwood ha a great game.
If anything I thought Luke Ball was poss our quietest and least effectual player. He was on Selwood for most of the game wasn't he? I thought Selwood ha a great game.
He couldnt have been on him to long. He only played 48% of the game.Moods wrote:I reckon everyone contributed today. Rapt that some on here have pointed out what Geary was doing - on MMM harley was voted third worst on the ground. His influence was crucial to negate due to the fact that our power fwds are our strength. Milney was a bit quiet but still had 10 possies and a crucial goal in the last 1/4 meant he contributed. McEvoy did what he could for a 19 year old kid playing his 7th of 8th game.
If anything I thought Luke Ball was poss our quietest and least effectual player. He was on Selwood for most of the game wasn't he? I thought Selwood ha a great game.
Moods wrote:I reckon everyone contributed today. Rapt that some on here have pointed out what Geary was doing - on MMM harley was voted third worst on the ground. His influence was crucial to negate due to the fact that our power fwds are our strength. Milney was a bit quiet but still had 10 possies and a crucial goal in the last 1/4 meant he contributed. McEvoy did what he could for a 19 year old kid playing his 7th of 8th game.
If anything I thought Luke Ball was poss our quietest and least effectual player. He was on Selwood for most of the game wasn't he? I thought Selwood ha a great game.
had a virus i think....
.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will
"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"
However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"
However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
-
milney044
- Club Player
- Posts: 1704
- Joined: Fri 31 Mar 2006 9:20pm
- Location: Level 1, next to the race -social club
- Has thanked: 2 times
- Been thanked: 9 times
Hmm the best thing about the game... i could list many!
1. Geelong continuing to contradict themselves post match. "It's good to have a loss, we will benefit from this" "We're not bothered by the loss" and yet they go on and on about that one missed umpiring decision. If the game meant so little to you, what's with all the complaining!? Laughable.
2. Riewoldt's goal from 50. Superb. Riewoldt's marking in crucial stages. Riewoldt's engine. Ok, just Riewoldt, the guy is a freak! A few years back i almost thought he was overrated, now, i reckon he's the best captain in the game and we are bloody lucky to have him.
3. Mooney's free against in the final stages of the game sealed it for me. I hate the loony and it was great to watch him suffer.
4.Gardiner's influence. What a season he is having, I'm really appreciating Rossy Lyon for giving him some time.
5. Lenny Hayes. Game breaker. That last quarter he really stood up, do we not have the best Captain- Vice Captain combo in the comp??
Now, the only thing that would bring this game down is to lose in September. Keep up the streak boys.
1. Geelong continuing to contradict themselves post match. "It's good to have a loss, we will benefit from this" "We're not bothered by the loss" and yet they go on and on about that one missed umpiring decision. If the game meant so little to you, what's with all the complaining!? Laughable.
2. Riewoldt's goal from 50. Superb. Riewoldt's marking in crucial stages. Riewoldt's engine. Ok, just Riewoldt, the guy is a freak! A few years back i almost thought he was overrated, now, i reckon he's the best captain in the game and we are bloody lucky to have him.
3. Mooney's free against in the final stages of the game sealed it for me. I hate the loony and it was great to watch him suffer.
4.Gardiner's influence. What a season he is having, I'm really appreciating Rossy Lyon for giving him some time.
5. Lenny Hayes. Game breaker. That last quarter he really stood up, do we not have the best Captain- Vice Captain combo in the comp??
Now, the only thing that would bring this game down is to lose in September. Keep up the streak boys.
Destiny. It's in our hands.
Harder. Better. Faster. Stronger.
Jarryn Geary 2/10 - 4 possesions.......two points on Harley - Mini had him early doors and smashed him, and he spent a lot of the second half on the pine.
Ben McEvoy 2.5/10
Steven Milne 2.5/10
Farren Ray 3/10
Jason Gram 3/10
Luke Ball 3.5/10
Raph Clarke 4/10
High End - all played well or better
Sam Gilbert - 9/10
Lenny Hayes - 9/10
M.Gardner - 8.5/10
N.Riewoldt - 8/10
J.Blake - 7.5/10
B.Goddard - 7/10
N.Dal Santo - 7/10
J.Koschitzke - 7/10
S.Fisher - 7/10
A.McQualter - 7/10
L.Montagna - 6.5/10
A.Schnieder - 6.5/10
Z.Dawson - 6/10
C.Jones - 6/10
S.Baker - 5.5/10
Ben McEvoy 2.5/10
Steven Milne 2.5/10
Farren Ray 3/10
Jason Gram 3/10
Luke Ball 3.5/10
Raph Clarke 4/10
High End - all played well or better
Sam Gilbert - 9/10
Lenny Hayes - 9/10
M.Gardner - 8.5/10
N.Riewoldt - 8/10
J.Blake - 7.5/10
B.Goddard - 7/10
N.Dal Santo - 7/10
J.Koschitzke - 7/10
S.Fisher - 7/10
A.McQualter - 7/10
L.Montagna - 6.5/10
A.Schnieder - 6.5/10
Z.Dawson - 6/10
C.Jones - 6/10
S.Baker - 5.5/10
-
Moods
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4951
- Joined: Fri 05 Jun 2009 3:05pm
- Has thanked: 343 times
- Been thanked: 497 times
I meant he was on Ball whilst he was on the ground. Well if that's the case Plugger (that he only played 48% of the game) I sure hope that Stinger is right about Ball having a virus. Why, in our biggest game of the year would we have one of our toughest, most experienced players sitting on the pine for over half the game? I know what his role is, and it's a bruising role. How come Lenny manages to play more of the game though? (the guy that Ball often rotates with)plugger66 wrote:He couldnt have been on him to long. He only played 48% of the game.Moods wrote:I reckon everyone contributed today. Rapt that some on here have pointed out what Geary was doing - on MMM harley was voted third worst on the ground. His influence was crucial to negate due to the fact that our power fwds are our strength. Milney was a bit quiet but still had 10 possies and a crucial goal in the last 1/4 meant he contributed. McEvoy did what he could for a 19 year old kid playing his 7th of 8th game.
If anything I thought Luke Ball was poss our quietest and least effectual player. He was on Selwood for most of the game wasn't he? I thought Selwood ha a great game.
I do agree it seems very low. Also means other play more than they actually want them to. He may have had a virus.Moods wrote:I meant he was on Ball whilst he was on the ground. Well if that's the case Plugger (that he only played 48% of the game) I sure hope that Stinger is right about Ball having a virus. Why, in our biggest game of the year would we have one of our toughest, most experienced players sitting on the pine for over half the game? I know what his role is, and it's a bruising role. How come Lenny manages to play more of the game though? (the guy that Ball often rotates with)plugger66 wrote:He couldnt have been on him to long. He only played 48% of the game.Moods wrote:I reckon everyone contributed today. Rapt that some on here have pointed out what Geary was doing - on MMM harley was voted third worst on the ground. His influence was crucial to negate due to the fact that our power fwds are our strength. Milney was a bit quiet but still had 10 possies and a crucial goal in the last 1/4 meant he contributed. McEvoy did what he could for a 19 year old kid playing his 7th of 8th game.
If anything I thought Luke Ball was poss our quietest and least effectual player. He was on Selwood for most of the game wasn't he? I thought Selwood ha a great game.