Guess at this weeks ins and outs

plugger66 · Post: # 751173Post **plugger66** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:24pm

In Milne, McEvoy

Out Gardiner, Raph

Sobraz · Post: # 751175Post **Sobraz** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:28pm

in: McEvoy
out: Gard

.... Ross hasn't made an unforced change all year i dont think...

Go Sainters Go · Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:42pm

In : Milne, McEvoy and Maxy.

Out : Gardiner, Gilbo (inj) and Raph.

Iceman234 · Post: # 751184Post **Iceman234** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:43pm

plugger66 wrote:In Milne, McEvoy

Out Gardiner, Raph

As above

SaintBot · Post: # 751185Post **SaintBot** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:46pm

In: Milne
Out: Gardiner

Would prefer your suggestion though plugger.

True Blue Sainter · Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:47pm

Ins: Milne McEvoy Max
Outs: Gardiner Gilbo Raph

saintsrus · Post: # 751187Post **saintsrus** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:48pm

Raph will keep his spot for at least one more week, he needs a few games to get his touch back

In Mac, Milne

Out Gards only announced tonite (plus another tomorrow not Raph)

saintly · Post: # 751188Post **saintly** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:52pm

saintsrus wrote:Raph will keep his spot for at least one more week, he needs a few games to get his touch back

In Mac, Milne

Out Gards only announced tonite (plus another tomorrow not Raph)

have to pick the 22 tonight.

must have another out if mac and milne come in.

plugger66 · Post: # 751190Post **plugger66** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:55pm

saintsrus wrote:Raph will keep his spot for at least one more week, he needs a few games to get his touch back

In Mac, Milne

Out Gards only announced tonite (plus another tomorrow not Raph)

What does that actually mean? When has 23 been able to be named.

bergholt · Post: # 751191Post **bergholt** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 2:57pm

IN: McEvoy, Milne
OUT: Gardiner (susp), Gram

Not saying I agree, but I reckon that's what will happen.

ausfatcat · Post: # 751203Post **ausfatcat** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:06pm

I think it will be:

In McEvoy
Out Gardiner

It should be:

In McEvoy, Maxy
Out Gwilt, Gardiner

Call me a softy but i would give Raph anther week.

saintlee · Post: # 751205Post **saintlee** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:07pm

ausfatcat wrote:I think it will be:

In McEvoy
Out Gardiner

It should be:

In McEvoy, Maxy
Out Gwilt, Gardiner

Call me a softy but i would give Raph anther week.

So I take it that you think Raph has done more to stay in the team than Gwilt? I don't see how myself....

bigcarl · Post: # 751211Post **bigcarl** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:15pm

milne must come in if fit, imo, and a tall (possibly mcevoy) to replace gardiner.

raph and gwilt would be the vulnerable ones.

Quixote · Post: # 751215Post **Quixote** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:20pm

OUT: MG (susp), Raph

IN: McEvoy, Milne

Should note: I'm all for Raph staying in the 22, think he belongs there. Just don't know who else goes (Blake..?) and the above is how I see Lyon playing it.

Does it leave us too small?

Milton66 · Post: # 751217Post **Milton66** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:27pm

Quixote wrote:
Does it leave us too small?

Depends on how cold it is in the change rooms

claystreet · Post: # 751221Post **claystreet** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:32pm

Sobraz wrote:in: McEvoy
out: Gard

.... Ross hasn't made an unforced change all year i dont think...

I agree

Quixote · Post: # 751223Post **Quixote** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:36pm

^^^ Actually he does, but he doesn't do it in a way that is instantly recognisable.

mightysainters · Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:38pm

Raph will stay in because I think gilbert might be a late withdrawal

Thinline · Post: # 751229Post **Thinline** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 3:50pm

Monkhorst for Gardiner.
Delaney for Raph.
Wulf for Milne who needs another week.

saintly · Post: # 751236Post **saintly** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 4:11pm

claystreet wrote:
Sobraz wrote:in: McEvoy
out: Gard

.... Ross hasn't made an unforced change all year i dont think...
I agree

will milne not get bakc in this week?

Hurricane · Post: # 751247Post **Hurricane** » Thu 04 Jun 2009 4:27pm

In: McEvoy Maguire
Out: Gardiner (susp) Gilbert (inj)

Milne will take another week to get right
Ruckman for ruckman is common sense
Goose has earned a recall
Gilbo will get the cautious approach with his leg

BANG BANG

desertsaint · Thu 04 Jun 2009 4:50pm

milne (if fit) is an automatic ("but we won - no one deserves to be dropped blah blah blah...") in.

If lyon is true to his word max will play (otherwise look out X)

And probably would replace gards with mcevoy.

If milne and gilbo are injured, plus gardy out - then max and mcevoy come in.

Beats me who goes out - but i'd like to see lyon keep on plan with maxy!

marksnsparks · Thu 04 Jun 2009 4:52pm

OUT: Guessing who is in and out.

IN: Waiting for the team announcement in the members e-mail on Friday night.

Get a life you snores

Saintschampions08 · Thu 04 Jun 2009 4:55pm

desertsaint wrote:milne (if fit) is an automatic ("but we won - no one deserves to be dropped blah blah blah...") in.

If lyon is true to his word max will play (otherwise look out X)

And probably would replace gards with mcevoy.

If milne and gilbo are injured, plus gardy out - then max and mcevoy come in.

Beats me who goes out - but i'd like to see lyon keep on plan with maxy!

Theirs a small difference between telling the media a player will play before the break and telling a player directly that they will not be delisted.

mad saint guy · Thu 04 Jun 2009 4:58pm

I'd prefer to see

OUT: Gardiner (susp), Gilbert (caution), Gwilt
IN: McEvoy, Hudghton, Milne

Guess at this weeks ins and outs

Guess at this weeks ins and outs

Re: Guess at this weeks ins and outs