Which past player would you choose?

[bigcarl]

plugga in his prime.
hands down.

G a reasonably close second.

we need a FF NOW.

yep.

plugger + riewoldt > franklin + roughhead.

franklin + roughhead > riewoldt + kosi.

it's the one area where hawthorn has a clear edge over us and the benefits to them are huge.

while we chip it around waiting for the right option, they bang it in quickly knowing their gun forwards will get it and kick a goal

[samoht]

Rod Owen.

a sensational mid sized goal kicking forward that we desperately lack in our one dimensional forward line..

sadly only played 50 odd games due to injury.

Winmar on one half forward flank and Rod Owen on the other would complete a nice dream.

[st.byron]

Plugger for mine. No contest.
An absolute freak. Really quick over twenty yards, had a leap that a 195cm 105 kg guy should not have had. Awesome hands. Deadly kick and lots of mongrel. Best player I've ever seen on a field in the flesh.

[jay young]

Im 43 and have been watching the saints for the last 30yrs one of the best in my time is DAVID GRANT always played his guts out for us . A true underated champion.