Official Trade Week Thread...

Post: # 659373Post **n1ck** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 3:53pm

Maybe when you post these 'trades', you could post a source?

LTN16 · Post: # 659375Post **LTN16** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:02pm

Brent Prismall has requested a trade.

Dean Laidley has said if the right offer comes up they will trade Hamish McIntosh.

Source SEN..

Saints Premiers 2008 · Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:04pm

LTN16 wrote:Brent Prismall has requested a trade.

Dean Laidley has said if the right offer comes up they will trade Hamish McIntosh.

Source SEN..

just heard that and bloody hell McIntosh is tempting

joey for McIntosh???

it would give us a great succession plan for ruckmen...king-hmac-kosi-mcevoy

SaintBot · Post: # 659378Post **SaintBot** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:09pm

McIntosh would almost certainly require a first round selection. It would be tempting, I'd be interested to hear the reasons for him being put up for trade.

St Fidelius · Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:09pm

Hasn't McIntosh done his knee??

Batnoe · Post: # 659380Post **Batnoe** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:10pm

St Fidelius wrote:Hasn't McIntosh done his knee??

he did last year but returned for last 2 games of the year

so should be able to do pre season work i would imagine

i dont think he re did it

LTN16 · Post: # 659381Post **LTN16** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:12pm

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
LTN16 wrote:Brent Prismall has requested a trade.

Dean Laidley has said if the right offer comes up they will trade Hamish McIntosh.

Source SEN..
just heard that and bloody hell McIntosh is tempting

joey for McIntosh???

it would give us a great succession plan for ruckmen...king-hmac-kosi-mcevoy

It is very tempting.. Doe's anyone know how old McIntosh is ?

vacuous space · Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:12pm

LTN16 wrote:Dean Laidley has said if the right offer comes up they will trade Hamish McIntosh.

I'd be tenative with McIntosh. Last year Laidley was touting him as the next Dean Cox, this year he's talking possible trade. McIntosh looked awful toward the end of this season. I'd want to know that he was physically and mentally fit to go before giving up quality in a trade for him. He could be a one year wonder.

Saints Premiers 2008 · Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:12pm

Batnoe wrote:
St Fidelius wrote:Hasn't McIntosh done his knee??
he did last year but returned for last 2 games of the year

so should be able to do pre season work i would imagine

i dont think he re did it

he was out fot 10 weeks with a foot issue???

laidley is just talking it up to see the shti that can be stirred i think

redwhite&blackblood · Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:16pm

Who do we rate higher Kosi or HMac?

Hmac is reasonable forward and a lot better in the ruck than Kosi.

Ralphy · Post: # 659388Post **Ralphy** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:16pm

25 next year.

St Fidelius · Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:18pm

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:
Batnoe wrote:
St Fidelius wrote:Hasn't McIntosh done his knee??
he did last year but returned for last 2 games of the year

so should be able to do pre season work i would imagine

i dont think he re did it
he was out fot 10 weeks with a foot issue???

laidley is just talking it up to see the shti that can be stirred i think

It wasn't his foot he had a torn posterior cruciate ligament in his right knee in round 12, but came back and played the last 2 games

Armoooo · Post: # 659392Post **Armoooo** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:22pm

No chance of getting either IMO, with King we can't afford to have another player who can only play ruck..., Prismall would be great but he is too much of a risk, like Maguire he is most valuable to the club he is already at...

FullMonty · Post: # 659413Post **FullMonty** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:54pm

How about pick 14 for Robbie Warnock?

We gave up 6 and 31 from memory for Barry Brooks the dud if I remember correctly.

plugger66 · Post: # 659416Post **plugger66** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 4:57pm

FullMonty wrote:How about pick 14 for Robbie Warnock?

We gave up 6 and 31 from memory for Barry Brooks the dud if I remember correctly.

Excellent reason. Lets do it. He wants to go to Carlton but if we are nice he may come to us.

Eastern · Post: # 659421Post **Eastern** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:03pm

vacuous space wrote:
LTN16 wrote:Dean Laidley has said if the right offer comes up they will trade Hamish McIntosh.
I'd be tenative with McIntosh. Last year Laidley was touting him as the next Dean Cox, this year he's talking possible trade. McIntosh looked awful toward the end of this season. I'd want to know that he was physically and mentally fit to go before giving up quality in a trade for him.

If there are any doubts in either area, North would ONLY deal with Hawthorn. They owe them BIG TIME !!

Batnoe · Post: # 659424Post **Batnoe** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:04pm

it would have to tempt the saints

Harris and Mcintosh and their 2nd round pick for

Our 1st and second pick

Sam23 · Post: # 659437Post **Sam23** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:26pm

We seem to be pretty keen this year.

Already shown interest in Green and HMac

True Blue Sainter · Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:26pm

McIntosh is a quality ruckman. Laidley made the mistake of rushing him back into the seniors in round 21, and thus McIntosh was not able to make a positive impact, as he wasn't match fit. When he is fit and firing, as he showed in 2007, he can be an extremely damaging ruckman - good in the hitouts and excellent around the ground. Definitely worth a first-round pick IMO.

mick13 · Post: # 659447Post **mick13** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:43pm

Turned 24 last month, so he'll be 24 all next year.

I reckon he'd be worth our first round pick.

Set ruck stock for the next 8 years.

st_Trav_ofWA · Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:44pm

Sam23 wrote:We seem to be pretty keen this year.

Already shown interest in Green and HMac

this is st kilda in the media we are interested in any recycled player especially Ruckmen !! i would love to know where the media get the so called info from so far we have been linked to every single player wanting out of their club !!!

Armoooo · Post: # 659451Post **Armoooo** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:48pm

Batnoe wrote:it would have to tempt the saints

Harris and Mcintosh and their 2nd round pick for

Our 1st and second pick

McIntosh and Harris for our second rounder, no more, if they don't take it, so be it...

Who would have thought we would have gotten Schneider and Dempster for our second rounder last year...

saint66au · Post: # 659454Post **saint66au** » Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:51pm

Not sure why the big chase for a "name" ruckman...and if it cost us a 1st rounder I'll scream the place down

We arent one decent ruckman away from a flag, we are at least 2 mids (one with blistering pace) and at least one reliable 3rd forward away.

3rd generation saint · Mon 06 Oct 2008 5:56pm

Of the players we know are definitely looking for new homes, these are the ones I'd be looking at.

Daniel Harris and Farren Rey, both good to quality midfielders, will probably only cost a second round draft pick.

Would prefer Harris ahead of Rey as he is a harder at it player and a bit more consistent.

Advantages to picking them up, more midfield depth, will make it more difficult for opposition to tag our gun players as either are good enough to create a bit of havoc if not given a reasonable amount od respect.

Marc Seaby and Robbie Warnock, mobile ruck forward. Give us the ability to leave another tall in the forward line at all times rotating with King off the bench and Kosi at full forward.

Could supply us with an extra 20 to 30 goals for the season.

Seaby again would probably cost a second round draft choice, Warnock maybe a bit more.

Most importantly, all 4 are on the right side of 25 and could provide 100 plus games to the club.

Also they wouldn't cost us much and improve the depth of the list, giving us a few more options.

Wouldn't trade our number 1 pick at this stage.

But as the week unfolds, more rumours, more possibilities and a lot more bull.

Con Gorozidis · Mon 06 Oct 2008 6:03pm

SaintBot wrote:McIntosh would almost certainly require a first round selection. It would be tempting, I'd be interested to hear the reasons for him being put up for trade.

very tempting. they probably want to leave because laidley is a flaming lunatic.