Max out for Freo game ?????????

[howlinwolf]

Ouch. This hurts.We needed him for Pav

[Mr Magic]

I thought he was in teh selected team but named as CHB?

[Armoooo]

[Bernard Shakey]

Club email says Max is playing.

[saintsRrising]

Ouch. This hurts.We needed him for Pav

What is your source???

[westy]

WTF The club email shows hom at CHB bout also lists him as out! I hope it is just a typo.

[westy]

Geeze, I've got to learn to proof read or something

[saint66au]

Mate ive edited your title to reflect its unconfirmed nature

In future please DONT post these statements as fact without a 100% public source

[Raven]

We can only assume it's a typo - the club email names him in the starting team then says he's out, and all other sources say he's in. So it must be just that one mistake. I wouldn't read too much into it.

[perfectionist]

Scarlett in?

[howlinwolf]

No worries with editing the title.

I was busy at work and opened up the team list email and had a really quick look. Mainly at the INS and OUTS.

Saw Max in the OUTS and closed it off.
Sorry, I didn't look at the actual team.

Let's hope it is an error.

[howlinwolf]

On second thoughts.

There's something curious about this it seems.
How often has Max been named at CHB ?

Rarely I would think. And then he's named in OUTS as well.

Maybe the Club is playing Ducks and Drakes trying to keep Freo guessing ?

[casey scorp]

According to saints.com.au:

IN: S Birss, C Gardiner, R Clarke, M Rix, M Ferguson
OUT: A Fiora (susp), J Geary

http://www.saints.com.au/AFL2008/News/A ... wsid=65537

[maverick]

Saints team list has him at CHB and out.
I reckon he may be out given its a Perth game, and the person sending the email out accidently let us all know in advance!!

[saintsRrising]

On second thoughts.

There's something curious about this it seems.
How often has Max been named at CHB ?

Rarely I would think. And then he's named in OUTS as well.

Maybe the Club is playing Ducks and Drakes trying to keep Freo guessing ?

No guess needed.

Max will take on Pav...hence why he is named at CHB...but wherever in the forward line Pav lines up, Max will line up.

Againts the Hawks Max took on Buddy.

[Dis Believer]

The biggest clue may be to count the number of "ins". HOw many extra's are normally named on the extended bench for a Sunday game? I think it's 3, so with Fiora and Geary out there needs to be 5 "ins", with Max out as well there would need to be 6 "ins".

There are 5.

[perfectionist]

Something very suspicious about all this. I think it's a good sign!

[saint66au]

Something very suspicious about all this. I think it's a good sign!

Your Max-bashing is becoming damned annoying

[st_Trav_ofWA]

i would say max will play

[saintspremiers]

Something very suspicious about all this. I think it's a good sign!

depends really.

Max possibly wasnt fit enough last week.

He's like an old engine.....takes a bit of warming up, but when going, is terrific.

I think you have a short memory.....Max has been in decent form recently, and I expect he'll earn his keep this week.

[Scott13bt]

4 a while now ive read all the comments on here and wondered if im reading comments of st kilda supporters.uve all got your opinions on who shood play and who shoodnt and i agree wit sum. ross lyon and staff didnt just pik names out of a hat, rather than criticize and have the attitutde that weve been beaten b4 the boys pull on the boots.f****** SUPPORT THEM. im as frustrated as the next one eyed supporta. the coaching staff didnt decide to e involved in football yesterday. theres theory behind it. i mite be stating the obvious. im just sick of reading blokes whinging and not SUPPORTING