Teams Round 20

[Stkilda-4Eva]

FREMANTLE v ST KILDA
Fremantle
B: Scott Thornton, Antoni Grover, Michael Johnson
HB: Marcus Drum, Luke McPharlin, Roger Hayden
C: Garrick Ibbotson, Ryan Crowley, David Mundy
HF: Paul Duffield, Kepler Bradley, Chris Mayne
F: Adam Campbell, Matthew Pavlich, Mark Johnson
Foll: Aaron Sandilands, Byron Schammer, Rhys Palmer
I/C (from): Steven Dodd, Jeff Farmer, Clayton Hinkley, Brett Peake, Des Headland, Andrew Browne, Ryan Murphy

In: Farmer, Grover, Headland, Hinkley, Murphy
Out: Chris Tarrant (shoulder), Josh Carr (groin)

St Kilda
B: Sean Dempster, Sam Fisher, Jason Gram
HB: Brendon Goddard, Max Hudghton, Jason Blake
C: Sam Gilbert, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes
HF: Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt, Robert Eddy
F: Clint Jones, Justin Koschitzke, Stephen Milne
Foll: Steven King, Andrew McQualter, Leigh Montagna
I/C (from): Adam Schneider, James Gwilt, Charlie Gardiner, Matthew Ferguson, Shane Birss, Raphael Clarke, Michael Rix

In: Birss, C. Gardiner, R. Clarke, Rix, Ferguson
Out: Aaron Fiora (susp), Jarryn Geary

[Saintschampions08]

Raph & Ferguson in


What's their form for Casey been like recently?

[plugger66]

Geary missed because he had tea. As B4E would fair dinkum what other excuses can we come up with.

[Solar]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

[plugger66]

Raph & Ferguson in


What's their form for Casey been like recently?

Raph good last 2 weeks poor before that. Ferg good last week average before that.

[St DAC]

TEA?

[Stkilda-4Eva]

TEA?

missspelt something all fixed

[Beno88]

All five ins possibly playing for their future at the club....

Despite it being an interstate game, I'd rather see Allen, Steven, Armitage & McEvoy instead of Gardiner, Clarke, Rix & Ferguson.

It was an injection of youth that got us over the line vs Freo last time.

[Quixote]

IN Raph Clarke and Birss
OUT Fiora and Geary

EMG Rix, Ferg, Charlie

?

[plugger66]

I would play either gardiner or ferg as a lead up forward and Birss so 2 changes. cannot see Schneider beig dropped maybe gwilt but I doubt it.

[mad saint guy]

Birss and Ferguson in for me. Ferg gets another chance exclusively playing forward.

[Batnoe]

I would play either gardiner or ferg as a lead up forward and Birss so 2 changes. cannot see Schneider beig dropped maybe gwilt but I doubt it.

IMO they will give Charlie Gardiner at least 2 years at the saints...

they really need to play Ferg while he is not injured to see if he is worthy of being retained, if he doesnt pull up this week i dont think he will get a chance

so play Ferguson and not Gardiner this week

[Quixote]

We definately need another FWD option and preferably I'd like to see Ferg given another go... Have been saying that for a while... just think they'll go with Raph.


If Gwilt is played in the backline again I will pull my fricken hair out. Wing, Middle or Flank only.

[st.byron]

All five ins possibly playing for their future at the club....

Despite it being an interstate game, I'd rather see Allen, Steven, Armitage & McEvoy instead of Gardiner, Clarke, Rix & Ferguson.

It was an injection of youth that got us over the line vs Freo last time.

Agree with you Beno. Would rather see the young guys getting a go than the likes of Raph, Rix and Ferguson. Would think they're playing for their future if they get a game.

[saintsRrising]

I would play either gardiner or ferg as a lead up forward and Birss so 2 changes. cannot see Schneider beig dropped maybe gwilt but I doubt it.

Ditto.

[Sam23]

Simply can't complain about Geary been dropped


done SFA in the last 2 weeks, and his little act in the forward pocket while the game was in the balance was very humorous, luckily probably our 3rd or 4th best player came through and took a big contested mark in BJ

[saintsRrising]

Well looks like we learnt from the Weagles game.

With all that space one needs another mobile marking forward...Charlie or Ferg.

[degruch]

Well looks like we learnt from the Weagles game.

With all that space one needs another mobile marking forward...Charlie or Ferg.

We've needed one the last 3 weeks! About time, hopefully it comes off with some degree of success.

[gosaints]

With Kosi looking to spend more time in the ruck could both Ferg and Charlie play?

[Batnoe]

With Kosi looking to spend more time in the ruck could both Ferg and Charlie play?

They could both play but if Raph plays i want him in the forward line also, maybe even on the wing?

[HarveysDeciple]

Birss is one logical in.

We need another lead up forward for the wide open spaces. I would go Charlie.

Ferguson was alright last week, but turned the ball over a heap.

Charlie gets the nod just.

[realdeal]

Yeah, Geary not quite ready for it this year. Has got his feet wet in the seniors which will hold him in good sted for next year.

Birss and C.Gardiner to come in i'd think..

[mick13]

Good god, just give Birss a gig. Whats the bet he has a quiet day and is dropped the next week? Dammit give the guy a chance lol.

I wanna see Ferg get another go.

IN: Birss, Ferg

[st_Trav_ofWA]

they really need to play Ferg while he is not injured to see if he is worthy of being retained, if he doesnt pull up this week i dont think he will get a chance

i would of though after 5 years we would know if hes good enuff to be retained or delisted

[WayneJudson42]

going through the motions

drop geary while playing the likes of gilbert on small forwards

select delisting headed players in rix, fergi and charlie. Seriously why not name jack just to take him over and be part of it?

Says more about the lack of depth coming through. IMO.