Will Milney be de-listed at the end of the year??

[St. Luke]

I'd like to think so

[Legendary]

Geez, this is a stupid thread.

What other club would have a guy who will probably kick 50 goals for the year as a possible delisting?

Milne is responsible for 30-35% of our team score.

Where are we gunna get 50 goals and 20-30 goal assists from next year?


Stephen Milne is not the reason we are 8th.

[Sam23]

To add a bit of perspective to this thread I know that not one Collingwood player is un-tradeable.

Make of that what u will.

I can't get over how stupid this post is, i actually cannot believe it.

[bozza1980]

I would be suprised if Milne was traded.

[Ralphy]

I would be suprised if Milne was traded.

milne wont be going.
he has been up for trade that many times in his career and hasnt had a offeer made of him, he will stay a saint.

[kalsaint]

What are the chances of milney being on the ST Kilda list at the end of the year?

A lot of the media have said he should go i disagree
I think we should keep him

No chance in my opinion. He is still one of the better small forwards in the competition.

Yes he misses tackles and sometiimes doesnt apply enough forward pressure but there are several others like this who need to go before Milney.

[Stkilda-4Eva]

no chance he will be delisted at the end of the year.

[saintbrat]

Drain would not be drawn on rating the quality of St Kilda's list, saying that the playing personnel would be assessed at the end of the season. But he did foreshadow the club would stick by out-of-form ruckman Michael Gardiner and hot-and-cold goalsneak Stephen Milne.

"We'd like to think Michael Gardiner playing well has got a place on the St Kilda list," he said.

"Milney's kicked 40 goals so it's been a reasonably good year, but he needs some more consistency in the really crunch games.

"We see those guys – historically and even now – as really important parts of our club and important parts of our list, and important parts of us performing this week."

http://saints.com.au/tabid/5315/Default ... wsid=65418

[kos]

yeah lets delist milney and ill pull 40+ goals out of my ass for the side!!

[saintjake]

you wouldnt delist him would you?
im sure someone would trade for him.
we can do with some more steak knifes

[Red]

He's too inconsistent and doesn't work hard enough when he hasn't got

the ball. If he has value trade him.

[HarveysDeciple]

He's too inconsistent and doesn't work hard enough when he hasn't got

the ball. If he has value trade him.

once again the consistent line.....small forwards are never consistant. It comes with the territory.

[realdeal]

No doubting he has his frustrating deficiencies but thats the lot of a small forward generally.

Its about putting others in the foraward line to balance that out. He kicks 50+ goals a year and is leading our goal kicking.. i think we struggle to kick enough as it is without ditching him too.

The shocking disposal into our forward line is more of a concern. Where have our skills gone?

[WayneJudson42]

Will he win u a flag?

[kos]

ifs milnes inconsistant what do you call
rhan hooper
eddie betts
leon davis
leroy jetta
jeff farmer
cyril rioli
travis varcoe
lindsay thomas
matt campbell
austin wonaeamirri
richard tambing
these are just a few names of players who play a similar roll to milne.
they have kicked no where near as many goals as milne.
i am not racist, but if milne was black would we still be so critical?
be happy we have such a player who when gone will be missed, he may have cost us goals during games but he has won us many games of his own boot.

[desertsaint]

ifs milnes inconsistant what do you call..
.

almost every single player on our list!

[spert]

Kicks a lot of goals but never in the important games against tough opposition, and rarely interstate - a bit of a curly one for the coach.