If not Ross Lyon....then who?

Art Vandelay · Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:14pm

Who should replace Ross Lyon as coach......????

Dean Laidley (what the guy has managed to do at North with that list and the limited resources he has available is nothing short of amazing. Also, he has passion, something which Ross Lyon hasn't shown a lot of.

Your thoughts, comments?

Ralphy · Post: # 620185Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:15pm

ross lyon wont be leaving he is contracted till the end of 2009

~~~~THE END~~~~~

Art Vandelay · Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:17pm

If you think that contracts cannot be terminated, you obviously also believe in the tooth fairy.

Ralphy · Post: # 620187Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:18pm

nOpe.

but he will be the coach next year.
laidley also wont be leaving north ffs

Ros Lyon · Post: # 620189Post **Ros Lyon** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:23pm

Art Vandelay wrote:Who should replace Ross Lyon as coach......????
Dean Laidley (what the guy has managed to do at North with that list and the limited resources he has available is nothing short of amazing. Also, he has passion, something which Ross Lyon hasn't shown a lot of.

Your thoughts, comments?

Grant Thomas

brown-coat · Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:23pm

Dermet Brereton.

Sobraz · Post: # 620191Post **Sobraz** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:23pm

R. Harvey..

Ralphy · Post: # 620192Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:24pm

wow this is like a troll gathering.... line them up...kill them one by one....

Sobraz · Post: # 620193Post **Sobraz** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:25pm

But in all seriousness.... if we were to drop Ross, i'd go for Aussie Jones...

I know the whole deal about needing to be assistant first, etc...
Ross has shown that aint worth squat... Aussie is a brilliant orator with a great football mind and perception... We must get him in and around our club...

Sobraz · Post: # 620194Post **Sobraz** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:26pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:wow this is like a troll gathering.... line them up...kill them one by one....

can we cull you first...

Ralphy · Post: # 620195Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:26pm

Sobraz wrote:But in all seriousness.... if we were to drop Ross, i'd go for Aussie Jones...

I know the whole deal about needing to be assistant first, etc...
Ross has shown that aint worth squat... Aussie is a brilliant orator with a great football mind and perception... We must get him in and around our club...

hes had this year as a coach of gippsland power, thats sort of a aprentaship

rodgerfox · Post: # 620200Post **rodgerfox** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:31pm

Here's who needs to be involved....

Danny Frawley.
Nathan Burke.
Tony Lockett.
Aussie Jones.
Robert Harvey.
Fraser Gehrig.
Kevin Sheedy.

Ralphy · Post: # 620201Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:32pm

Tony Lockett. wont come back to stkilda hasnt he already said this?

bergsone · Post: # 620215Post **bergsone** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:50pm

Right or wrong,I dont reckon RL will be replaced,But we have 2 retirees
R Harvey mid field coach?
F Gehrig forward coach?

Way we are going 2 positions that must be looked at

Buckets · Post: # 620218Post **Buckets** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:52pm

Didn't know that Lyon had been sacked???????

Some of the suggestions are absolutely ridiculous! Are you guys serious? The majority were against the GT sacking yet are quite happy to see Lyon go and us the laughing stock again??? UNREAL

Buckets · Post: # 620221Post **Buckets** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:54pm

Oh and Sobraz why do you have it in for Ralphy?

Sobraz · Post: # 620222Post **Sobraz** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:55pm

Buckets wrote:Oh and Sobraz why do you have it in for Ralphy?

"

rodgerfox · Post: # 620223Post **rodgerfox** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:55pm

Buckets wrote:Didn't know that Lyon had been sacked???????

Some of the suggestions are absolutely ridiculous! Are you guys serious? The majority were against the GT sacking yet are quite happy to see Lyon go and us the laughing stock again??? UNREAL

Lyon should only go if we have a plan.

If we have someone lined up. Someone specific.

If not, then you're right. You've got to learn from your mistakes. Sacking a coach without any idea who is going to replace them is, well, moronic.

spert · Post: # 620224Post **spert** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:55pm

I toss and turn about RL as a coach, but I think he probably doesn't have the goods. I was at a mate's place and was forced to watch Carlton vs PA on a replay, and honestly I thought Carlscum looked so much better than us -more confidence, more running, and Ratten exudes a lot more confidence and positivity than RL, who could never inspire me if that's how he talks to players.
RL said that we need to be excited more, after the loss last Sat. Sorry Ross.. you need to motivate the team -as if we haven't got reason to be motivated already..a position in the eight up for grabs, Banger retiring jeezzz!!!!

mad saint guy · Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:56pm

The two main people who I think should be involved in some way are Aussie Jones and Aaron Hamill.

Aussie definitely has a future in football, whether it be media or coaching and Aaron just strikes me as the type of person we need around the club right now. He's a St Kilda person, intelligent and well spoken, a good mentor to young players and wouldn't put up with any softc0cks not giving their all.

Ralphy · Post: # 620228Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 12:58pm

Thats why you would go for hamil as our forward coach, piss off barker.
keep silvagni as the backline coach he has done a alright job.

harves or Aussie as our midfield/assistant,

Ralphy · Post: # 620232Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 1:01pm

Sobraz wrote:
Buckets wrote:Oh and Sobraz why do you have it in for Ralphy?
" "

doesnt answer the question.

Buckets · Post: # 620233Post **Buckets** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 1:01pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:Thats why you would go for hamil as our forward coach, piss off barker.
keep silvagni as the backline coach he has done a alright job.

harves or Aussie as our midfield/assistant,

Don't know that Hamill would like to come back to the club! Just listening to him commentate St Kilda matches makes me think that there may be not alot of respect at the present!
May be due to the way he 'retired'.

Ralphy · Post: # 620234Post **Ralphy** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 1:02pm

didnt he get virtually shoved out the door by ross?

plugger66 · Post: # 620238Post **plugger66** » Mon 11 Aug 2008 1:06pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:didnt he get virtually shoved out the door by ross?

Yes so why do you think he will coach us then? And why Saints people. None of them have had success.

If not Ross Lyon....then who?

If not Ross Lyon....then who?

Re: If not Ross Lyon....then who?