Round 18 Team: Ins and Outs

RedWhiteBlack · Thu 31 Jul 2008 5:55pm

Team is listed guys! Six inclusions!

http://www.saints.com.au/Season2008/New ... wsId=64533

degruch · Post: # 612601Post **degruch** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 5:58pm

Very surprised with a Rix inclusion at the cost of M Gardiner! Would have thought this would be a perfect game for Gardy to find some touch, even with Kosi included...whereas, I can't see a reason for Rix at all. Good to see Birss, Geary and Gwilt get runs again (possibly)

mick13 · Post: # 612602Post **mick13** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:00pm

Hmmm.

OUT: Gardi, Max, Armo
IN: Kosi, ???, ???

I'll say Gwilt and Geary or Birss.

Crushed to see Armo dropped, but he hasnt been performing lately I guess.

Ralphy · Post: # 612606Post **Ralphy** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:03pm

IN: J Koschitzke, C Gardiner, S Birss, M Rix, J Geary, J Gwilt
OUT: M Gardiner, D Armitage, M Hudghton (calf)

Great to see Rix getting a chance same as charlie G,
love the team ross good choice!

evertonfc · Post: # 612609Post **evertonfc** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:06pm

I don't care how crap Gardiner played, he's still 10x as good as Rix. Seriously.

Gardy has played some decent games for us, whereas Rix hasn't.

People need to have a little patience with Gardiner. What he has shown in his good games indicates there is something to work with.

Keep him out of Perth, though.

Pleased to see Charlie included - he relieves a lot of pressure on others. Likewise Geary. Gwilt looks like he'll be our FB

unfortunately.

Birss? Meh...offers more than Fiora but needs to have a bigger impact.

Beno88 · Post: # 612610Post **Beno88** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:06pm

Fiora still in. Another last chance i guess.....

Griggsy · Post: # 612611Post **Griggsy** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:06pm

cool, wanted C.Gardiner to have a run.

Winmarvellous · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:06pm

And send Fiora here to stay. How is he still in the squad?

stinger · Post: # 612614Post **stinger** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:09pm

why's ammo an out ffs....

evertonfc · Post: # 612615Post **evertonfc** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:10pm

stinger wrote:why's ammo an out ffs....

Armo's current form isn't that much worse than Fiora, IMO.

And, FFS, one of them has a future and needs nurturing. The other keeps blowing his chances.

stinger · Post: # 612616Post **stinger** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:11pm

evertonfc wrote:
stinger wrote:why's ammo an out ffs....
Armo's current form isn't that much worse than Fiora, IMO.

And, FFS, one of them has a future and needs nurturing. The other keeps blowing his chances.

...actually i though it was better...and i normally stick up for fiora.....

Batnoe · Post: # 612618Post **Batnoe** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:11pm

We need the Ferg Berg to have another run as his time is running out, he does show promise but if he cant get onto the field he is taking up some serious space for a kid

Gilbert=Legend · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:11pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:IN: J Koschitzke, C Gardiner, S Birss, M Rix, J Geary, J Gwilt
OUT: M Gardiner, D Armitage, M Hudghton (calf)

Great to see Rix getting a chance same as charlie G,
love the team ross good choice!

Go sleep with Ross you idiot, Rix is good for the VFl and is not up to afl stanard and birss has proved nothing.

Ralphy · Post: # 612621Post **Ralphy** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:13pm

Gilbert=Legend wrote:
ralphysaints35 wrote:IN: J Koschitzke, C Gardiner, S Birss, M Rix, J Geary, J Gwilt
OUT: M Gardiner, D Armitage, M Hudghton (calf)

Great to see Rix getting a chance same as charlie G,
love the team ross good choice!
Go sleep with Ross you idiot, Rix is good for the VFl and is not up to afl stanard and birss has proved nothing.

oh wait IM NOT ALLOWED TO HAVE MY OPINION THATS RIGHT....
rix deserves his spot so does charlie gardiner so does birrs,

stinger · Post: # 612622Post **stinger** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:14pm

if maxie and gardiner are out ...plus ammo....the inclusions should be kossi, gwilt and birss.......the other three are the emergencies.....

Gilbert=Legend · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:17pm

ralphysaints35 wrote:
Gilbert=Legend wrote:
ralphysaints35 wrote:IN: J Koschitzke, C Gardiner, S Birss, M Rix, J Geary, J Gwilt
OUT: M Gardiner, D Armitage, M Hudghton (calf)

Great to see Rix getting a chance same as charlie G,
love the team ross good choice!
Go sleep with Ross you idiot, Rix is good for the VFl and is not up to afl stanard and birss has proved nothing.
oh wait IM NOT ALLOWED TO HAVE MY OPINION THATS RIGHT....
rix deserves his spot so does charlie gardiner so does birrs,

You are, but say things of value

Have you noticed that you love all of the saints c@#$ players, Rix (3-4 years, has done nothing) same with Raph, Birss (3 years, nothing)

If your gonna say something, chose the good players and not old wanna bes.

The future is with players that can RUN, like armo, geary, allan, eddy, mac, not jog like the players you chose to love.

Quixote · Post: # 612626Post **Quixote** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:17pm

Is the consensus --

OUT Max, Gardi, Armo
IN Jimmy, Kosi, Birss

?

Don't mind Armitage getting dropped - what he does when he gets it is great, but needs to remember how to get it more.

Gilbert=Legend · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:19pm

Quixote wrote:Is the consensus --

OUT Max, Gardi, Armo
IN Jimmy, Kosi, Birss

?

Don't mind Armitage getting dropped - what he does when he gets it is great, but needs to remember how to get it more.

Maybe he would get it more if he played had more gametime

goodie · Post: # 612630Post **goodie** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:20pm

Fiora and Schneider should count themselves lucky

Agree with the consensus, it'll probably be Kosi, Gwilt and Birss/Geary in. I would've liked to have seen both of the latter get a game

Quixote · Post: # 612631Post **Quixote** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:23pm

Gilbert=Legend wrote:
Quixote wrote:Is the consensus --

OUT Max, Gardi, Armo
IN Jimmy, Kosi, Birss

?

Don't mind Armitage getting dropped - what he does when he gets it is great, but needs to remember how to get it more.
Maybe he would get it more if he played had more gametime

How much more than the 93% last week for 6 possessions would you want?

terry smith rules · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:24pm

relax everybody

would think that given a sunday game that it just about naming 7 players on the i/c, therefore rix gets a nod

as for armo, he needs some time back with casey and just get some ball.

he had lots of game time last week, on a big ground as a young player, he needs to freshen up

fqf

AlpineStars · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:24pm

[quote="goodie"]Fiora and Schneider should count themselves lucky

Very Very Very Very Lucky.
Schneider 1 decent game all year not good enough shape up or Retire.

Snakeman66 · Post: # 612637Post **Snakeman66** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:26pm

St Kilda v Port Adelaide
Telstra Dome @ 2.10pm

ST KILDA
B: Sean Dempster, Sam Fisher, Jason Gram
HB: Brendon Goddard, Sam Gilbert, Jason Blake
C: Andrew McQualter, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes
HF: Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt, Robert Eddy
F: Clint Jones, Justin Koschitzke, Stephen Milne
Foll: Steven King, Luke Ball, Leigh Montagna
Int (from): Adam Schneider, James Gwilt, Aaron Fiora, Michael Rix, Charlie Gardiner, Jarryn Geary, Shane Birss

In: Koschitzke, C Gardiner, Birss, Rix, Geary, Gwilt
Out: Michael Gardiner, David Armitage, Max Hudghton (calf)

PORT ADELAIDE
B: Michael Pettigrew, Alipate Carlile, Nick Lower
HB:Jacob Surjan, Toby Thurstans, Nathan Lonie
C: Domenic Cassisi, Kane Cornes, Travis Boak
HF: Greg Bentley, Tom Logan, Danyle Pearce
F: Justin Westhoff, Daniel Motlop, Brett Ebert
Foll: Dean Brogan, Shaun Burgoyne, David Rodan
Int (from): Fabian Deluca, Mitch Farmer, Nick Salter, Paul Stewart, Adam Thomson, Damon White, Ryan Williams

In: Farmer, Salter, Stewart, Thomson, White, Williams
Out: Tredrea (shoulder), Salopek (Achilles), Chaplin (ankle)

4ever_saint · Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:38pm

you would think that geary would finally get another go.

afterall, its not right that players like gwilt, gardiner and birss get another go, when they have proved to be nothing more than average, when a young player like geary, who has been bog for three consecutive weeks at casey, continues to miss out.

stinger · Post: # 612647Post **stinger** » Thu 31 Jul 2008 6:40pm

terry smith rules wrote:relax everybody

would think that given a sunday game that it just about naming 7 players on the i/c, therefore rix gets a nod

as for armo, he needs some time back with casey and just get some ball.

he had lots of game time last week, on a big ground as a young player, he needs to freshen up

fqf

yep....sensible post....