Didak case thrown out...

[Sam23]

Not even looked at, so it has nothing to do with Kosi having carry over points.


Plugger - explain this one too me.


Kosi gets a week, Didaks case gets thrown out.


Just a joke.

[chook23]

Not even looked at, so it has nothing to do with Kosi having carry over points.


Plugger - explain this one too me.


Kosi gets a week, Didaks case gets thrown out.


Just a joke.

You said not even looked at..............wrong......was but deemed more of a pushing action and force below required that to warrant a charge.....

[Dan Warna]

I rofled when that came up on the news.

along with the baker stop and prop and letting someone run into you.

just smiled, I know kosi would get 1 to 2 weeks, and I knew didak would get off.

Im just suprised Goddard hasn't been charged with something for abusing the umpire after that stupid free kick and the punch (ROFL) he threw after the 50 was given against him.

I guess when they saw the replay and found they penalised goddard twice already for their mistake, punishing him a third time for their mistake was rich even by their warped standards.

[saintsrus]

I nearly hit another car when I heard this, what a joke.
Kosi deserved his penalty but when you see it happen again and gets thrown out, its just typical

[perfectionist]

The two incidents were completely different. One involved a team in red, white and black looming as a real chance for the top four and the other involved a team in only white and black and in danger of dropping out of the battle for a top four position.

[saintbrat]

staker off for hitting Fiora

Ch ten just showed the kosi and Didak jumper punches- sorry I couldn't see much differance

[Mr Magic]

I've just seen the Didak one on CH 10 (the first time I've seen the incident) and I cannot understand why this is seen as different to the Kosi one? Didak's was at least the equal of Kosi's if not a 'cleaner strike' to his opponent's jaw.

The Davis one should have been thrown out because it was a joke.

As for Brent Harvey, he confirmed why I despise him as a player. Took 2 dives in 30 seconds just to 'milk' free kicks from an opponent.
He, IMHO, should be charged with bringing the game into direpute for the second one (where he pretended he was hit on the jaw).

[perfectionist]

Agree some action should be taken, especially given his after match comments.

[Ralphy]

Wheres the Consistancy AFL!

didak was reported for a jumper punch almost idenitcal. to what kosi done the week ago and kos got a week
didak does the same f****** thing and gets away with it

!!!!

[bergsone]

After watching that all I can say is one set of rules for one,one for another.Can someone somewhere show the difference,cause i am stuffed if I can see it

[Solar]

vision says enough

joke, complete joke....

[saintDal]

Agree some action should be taken, especially given his after match comments.

What did he say?

[oh when]

Did you really expect anything else ?

[tweedaletomanning]

When will people wake up and realize, that Collingwood RUN the AFL, and dimwit is eddies puppet...

- No clash jumper,

- Minimum interstate games

- Anzac day

[stinger]

Not even looked at, so it has nothing to do with Kosi having carry over points.


Plugger - explain this one too me.


Kosi gets a week, Didaks case gets thrown out.


Just a joke.

You said not even looked at..............wrong......was but deemed more of a pushing action and force below required that to warrant a charge.....

it was a punch to the jaw ...with a fist...holding a handful of jumper ffs.....

[perfectionist]

Agree some action should be taken, especially given his after match comments.

What did he say?

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/d ... 59784.html

[markp]

Collingwood double chance= $$$$$$ for AFL.

[saintsRrising]

If Westaway had balls he would DEMAND that the AFL explain the difference betwen Didak's and Kosi's.

He can use the appropriate channell's of course...but I am getting throughly pissed off that we kept getting right royally done over up our channel.

While we played poorly no doubt, if Kosi had played I am sure that we would have 4 more points than we do now.

[jk23]

I just got home and my son told me .......................Double standards....
I cannot believe it didak did the exact same thing ....................i just want to scream.........did you all hear that

[Raven]

What an absolute farce.

[BallBanger]

If Westaway had balls he would DEMAND that the AFL explain the difference betwen Didak's and Kosi's.

He can use the appropriate chal's of course...but I am getting throughly pissed off that we kept getting right royally down over up our cahnnel.

While we played poorly no doubt, if Kosi had played I am sure that we would have 4 more points than we do now.

He had better..I am my kids/grandkids all mad saints fans brothers/sisters etc reserve seats social club. If we don't do anything now I'm not joining again and this will flow on through my family...enough is enough...my arse can only take so much

We are so weak

Complain and we get fined 60k and malthouse/mcguire complain and they get great exposure no fine.

Why all the **** time

[Solar]

If Westaway had balls he would DEMAND that the AFL explain the difference betwen Didak's and Kosi's.

He can use the appropriate chal's of course...but I am getting throughly pissed off that we kept getting right royally down over up our cahnnel.

While we played poorly no doubt, if Kosi had played I am sure that we would have 4 more points than we do now.

He had better..I am my kids/grandkids all mad saints fans brothers/sisters etc reserve seats social club. If we don't do anything now I'm not joining again and this will flow on through my family...enough is enough...my arse can only take so much

We are so weak

Complain and we get fined 60k and malthouse/mcguire complain and they get great exposure no fine.

Why all the **** time

complaign and things get worse... don't you remember whispers in the sky.....

[Batnoe]

Kosi's game was because he got reported last year and had 70 points on his case and it was 11 months 29 days and 23 hours earlier, the 70 points carried over because it wasnt exactly 1 year

If we had played the following year, Kosi's would have been thrown out, would be interested if Didak had been reported in the last 365 days?

[Solar]

Kosi's game was because he got reported last year and had 70 points on his case and it was 11 months 29 days and 23 hours earlier, the 70 points carried over because it wasnt exactly 1 year

If we had played the following year, Kosi's would have been thrown out, would be interested if Didak had been reported in the last 365 days?

would have been happy if didak got the same points, understand the carry over. But to get nothing..... hmmmm says everything

on top of 29-10 frees.... mmmmm

[BallBanger]

Kosi's game was because he got reported last year and had 70 points on his case and it was 11 months 29 days and 23 hours earlier, the 70 points carried over because it wasnt exactly 1 year

If we had played the following year, Kosi's would have been thrown out, would be interested if Didak had been reported in the last 365 days?

Is that a guess because you have faith in the system?
Nothing personal but you're wrong, didak had carryovers toooo, bbbut he was not cited.
Being cited has nothing to do with carryovers..