M.Gardiner

[Munga]

Obviously has a few old mates who had $$$ on the eagles. Absolute rubbish today. Two kicks and three frees against.
Shouldn't have been picked.

[battye]

Useless. Either he wasn't fit to play, or he's past it.

To be honest, I think he's past it.

[tezza1]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

[dcstkfc]

awful. utterly awful. and king was crap too. just awful. awful. awful.

[fonz_#15]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

did u see that our second ruckman was put this week?

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

[vacuous space]

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

He couldn't have done worse than Gardiner.

[Selhurst Saint]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

did u see that our second ruckman was put this week?

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

MG was a waste of an air fare

I would think Geary or Birss would have won a lot more ball than MG.

[fonz_#15]

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

He couldn't have done worse than Gardiner.

as a like for like replacement for kosi??

this game wasn't lost at the selection table thats for sure..

[fonz_#15]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

did u see that our second ruckman was put this week?

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

MG was a waste of an air fare

I would think Geary or Birss would have won a lot more ball than MG.

they would have, but how do they go in the ruck?

[tezza1]

well Blake was used as the back up ruckman last week .
Surely Allen would have been a better option up forward than a Gardiner who obviously wasnt match fit (or if he was well time to hang up the boots)

[maverick]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

did u see that our second ruckman was put this week?

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

MG was a waste of an air fare

I would think Geary or Birss would have won a lot more ball than MG.

they would have, but how do they go in the ruck?

Not sure, but did Gardiner play there?
I didn't notice if he did

[fonz_#15]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

did u see that our second ruckman was put this week?

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

MG was a waste of an air fare

I would think Geary or Birss would have won a lot more ball than MG.

they would have, but how do they go in the ruck?

Not sure, but did Gardiner play there?
I didn't notice if he did

he played there in parts and was rubbish, i am not denying that..

but we replaced our second ruck kosi, with another ruckman so ross did the right thing

gardy was just no good.

[vacuous space]

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

He couldn't have done worse than Gardiner.

as a like for like replacement for kosi??

Yes. Geary would have done better as a ruckman. A blind midget would have done a better job than Gardiner.

[fonz_#15]

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

He couldn't have done worse than Gardiner.

as a like for like replacement for kosi??

Yes. Geary would have done better as a ruckman. A blind midget would have done a better job than Gardiner.

ever considered changing your name from vacous space to waste of space??

you have no idea.

[saintsRrising]

Yep...Gardi had a shocker. No way around it was awful.

[maverick]

Should have been made to earn his place back with good performances with Casey?

did u see that our second ruckman was put this week?

i suppose geary should have come in to replace kosi as a ruckman

MG was a waste of an air fare

I would think Geary or Birss would have won a lot more ball than MG.

they would have, but how do they go in the ruck?

Not sure, but did Gardiner play there?
I didn't notice if he did

he played there in parts and was rubbish, i am not denying that..

but we replaced our second ruck kosi, with another ruckman so ross did the right thing

gardy was just no good.

Disagree, we swapped our FF for gardiner, last week Blake played 2nd ruck...MG cannot play forward, he scored negative 19 champion data points, never seen that low before....

We lost this game mentally and in team selection nothing surer...

[fonz_#15]

blake got thrown into the ruck for 10-15 minutes in the third last week and was good i admit.

who plays in defence if he plays ruck though?

and max went down so he was never going to ruck.

gardy was the right option, and to lay the blame soley on him is wrong.

having said that he has effectively bought to a close his career at st.kilda with that awful display.

[JeffDunne]

It really staggers me that some people have the nerve to blame previous list decisions.

MG has been a complete and utter waste of time and resources.

Should be the last game he ever plays in a St Kilda jumper. That waste of space from Sydney should be shown the door too.

[vacuous space]

ever considered changing your name from vacous space to waste of space??

you have no idea.

Says the guy sticking up for Michael Gardiner after a 2 disposal, 7 clanger performance.

[fonz_#15]

ever considered changing your name from vacous space to waste of space??

you have no idea.

Says the guy sticking up for Michael Gardiner after a 2 disposal, 7 clanger performance.

how am i sticking up for him??

he was pathetic, but the selection was the correct one.

if anything i am sticking up for ross.

[maverick]

blake got thrown into the ruck for 10-15 minutes in the third last week and was good i admit.

who plays in defence if he plays ruck though?

and max went down so he was never going to ruck.

gardy was the right option, and to lay the blame soley on him is wrong.

having said that he has effectively bought to a close his career at st.kilda with that awful display.

Not solely blaming HIM, far from it, probably not even having a crack at him, was asked to play a role he just couldn't do...

[maverick]

That waste of space from Sydney should be shown the door too.

Narrow it down please....

[fonz_#15]

blake got thrown into the ruck for 10-15 minutes in the third last week and was good i admit.

who plays in defence if he plays ruck though?

and max went down so he was never going to ruck.

gardy was the right option, and to lay the blame soley on him is wrong.

having said that he has effectively bought to a close his career at st.kilda with that awful display.

Not solely blaming HIM, far from it, probably not even having a crack at him, was asked to play a role he just couldn't do...

i can definately agree with you on that..

he was out of his depth, but i still think the selection was right on thursday, but he just produced a stinker.

[mick13]

How can you have 7 clangers from 2 disposals?

[JeffDunne]

if anything i am sticking up for ross.

Yeah . . . go Ross.