Official Teams ROUND 17 Vs West Coast

Ralphy · Post: # 608887Post **Ralphy** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 6:57pm

WEST COAST v ST KILDA
WEST COAST v ST KILDA
West Coast
B: Mark Nicoski, Eric Mackenzie, Tyson Stenglein
HB: Adam Selwood, Beau Wilkes, Andrew Embley
C: Michael Braun, Matt Priddis, Brent Staker
HF: David Wirrpanda, Ashley Hansen, Steven Armstrong
F: Mark LeCras, Quinten Lynch, Mark Seaby
Foll: Dean Cox, Chad Fletcher, Jamie McNamara
I/C: Brad Ebert, Ben McKinley, Scott Selwood, Matt Spangher
EMG: Tim Houlihan, Pat McGinnity, Tony Notte

In: Braun, Armstrong, Seaby, Spangher
Out: Kennedy (knee), Glass (thigh), Houlihan, Davis.

St Kilda
B: Sean Dempster, Max Hudghton, Jason Gram
HB: Brendon Goddard, Sam Gilbert, Sam Fisher
C: Andrew McQualter, Nick Dal Santo, Lenny Hayes
HF: Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt, Robert Eddy
F: Clint Jones, Michael Gardiner, David Armitage
Foll: Steven King, Luke Ball, Leigh Montagna
I/C: Adam Schneider, Jason Blake, Stephen Milne, Aaron Fiora
EMG: Jarryn Geary, Michael Rix, Shane Birss

In: M. Gardiner
Out: Justin Koschitzke (susp)

markinUSA · Post: # 608899Post **markinUSA** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 7:06pm

It's a little hard for me to read the ins and outs with the coloured letters - is it just me or does anyone else have the same trouble?

Ralphy · Post: # 608904Post **Ralphy** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 7:12pm

sorry about that. have fixed it.

perfectionist · Thu 24 Jul 2008 7:23pm

Our team looks OK, and WC still has plenty of good players in the line up. This will be no easy game.

Solar · Post: # 608922Post **Solar** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 7:51pm

good selection

no reason why we should not win by 50+

no excuses, run and hit hard and work our butts off.

remboy · Post: # 608926Post **remboy** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:02pm

I'm not convinced about Gardiner at full forward, although I don't mind having him in the team. Who are the guys at FB & CHB for the Weagles? There's a couple on the bench I've never heard of either.

markinUSA · Post: # 608927Post **markinUSA** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:02pm

Thank you Ralphy, much appreciated.

Let's have a great win this week!

Otiman · Post: # 608929Post **Otiman** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:11pm

Who would have thought the Eagles forward line would look more potent than it's midfield.

Armoooo · Post: # 608930Post **Armoooo** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:12pm

remboy wrote:I'm not convinced about Gardiner at full forward, although I don't mind having him in the team. Who are the guys at FB & CHB for the Weagles? There's a couple on the bench I've never heard of either.

Wilkes and McKenzie are young blokes that show plenty of promise, Riewoldt should have an absolute field day though, I can see any match up for him, not a single one, they don't have any tall players with a big enough tank IMO...

I would expect McQualter to get the job on Priddis, Selwood will probably go to Dal...

Hudghton on Lynch, Blake on Hansen.
Wirrpanda is a danger player, I hope he gets paid the respect he deserves.

We match up extremely well against these guys, but we still need 100% effort for 4 quarters...

saintsRrising · Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:17pm

Kennedy and Glass are both big outs for the Weagles.

I expect Milne and Schneider to havea big day out between them.

Whichever tall supports Rooey (and most likey it will be a number rotating through all day) just have to ensure that they compete and provide opportunities.

jonesy · Post: # 608934Post **jonesy** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:23pm

They're side on paper really isn't that bad,and considering some of there outs it's bewildering to think they've only won 2 games.

I'll be happy with the 4pts

Otiman · Post: # 608940Post **Otiman** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 8:33pm

Armoooo wrote:I would expect McQualter to get the job on Priddis, Selwood will probably go to Dal...

Hudghton on Lynch, Blake on Hansen.

Nope.

Dempster on Priddis, McQualter on Fletcher.

Eddy on Wirrpanda, with the possibility of Gilbert swinging forward at some stage.

CHB and FB are good bets.

saintjake · Post: # 608949Post **saintjake** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:26pm

M.Gards at full foward looks likley to undo all the goo work we
have worked so hard for,a mobile foward line,
much rather have frase up there.
or some of the younger guys.

BIT ANGRY!

Cairnsman · Post: # 608952Post **Cairnsman** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:33pm

Hope MG has a good game. It would be good to get 6 games into him before September.

Having MG, Kosi and Kingy firing come September will make us hard to beat.

With MG and Kingy as our key Ruckman and Kosi rotating through as well in between kicking goals and helping down back.

If all three are firing it also helps our mids with first use of the footy.

Raven · Post: # 608953Post **Raven** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:35pm

It's not like he'll stay at full forward the entire game. It's not like he's our sole goal kicker.

plugger66 · Post: # 608959Post **plugger66** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:48pm

Raven wrote:It's not like he'll stay at full forward the entire game. It's not like he's our sole goal kicker.

Its not likely he will play at FF at all.

maverick · Post: # 608961Post **maverick** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:52pm

plugger66 wrote:
Raven wrote:It's not like he'll stay at full forward the entire game. It's not like he's our sole goal kicker.
Its not likely he will play at FF at all.

Who will then?

plugger66 · Post: # 608964Post **plugger66** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:54pm

maverick wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Raven wrote:It's not like he'll stay at full forward the entire game. It's not like he's our sole goal kicker.
Its not likely he will play at FF at all.
Who will then?

Rooy, Gilbo and Blake will rotate.

maverick · Post: # 608965Post **maverick** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 9:58pm

plugger66 wrote:
maverick wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Raven wrote:It's not like he'll stay at full forward the entire game. It's not like he's our sole goal kicker.
Its not likely he will play at FF at all.
Who will then?
Rooy, Gilbo and Blake will rotate.

Hope you're right, one of the worst forward lines we have picked for a while (on paper anyway)

Lynch Beast · Thu 24 Jul 2008 10:00pm

11 premiership players

only 2 of them aren't backbone players...

So different to the 2006 grand final team

B: Adam Selwood Darren Glass David Wirrpanda
HB: Brett Jones Adam Hunter Beau Waters
C: Michael Braun Ben Cousins Andrew Embley
HF: Daniel Chick Ashley Hansen Tyson Stenglein
F: Chad Fletcher Quinten Lynch Rowan Jones
Foll: Dean Cox Chris Judd Daniel Kerr
Int: Steven Armstrong Drew Banfield Sam Butler
Mark Seaby

So many class players missing

jonesy · Post: # 608968Post **jonesy** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 10:04pm

Lynch Beast wrote:11 premiership players

only 2 of them aren't backbone players...

So different to the 2006 grand final team

B: Adam Selwood Darren Glass David Wirrpanda
HB: Brett Jones Adam Hunter Beau Waters
C: Michael Braun Ben Cousins Andrew Embley
HF: Daniel Chick Ashley Hansen Tyson Stenglein
F: Chad Fletcher Quinten Lynch Rowan Jones
Foll: Dean Cox Chris Judd Daniel Kerr
Int: Steven Armstrong Drew Banfield Sam Butler
Mark Seaby

So many class players missing

Stating the obvious here but Kerr,Judd,cousins are big blows for you guys. If you were able to chuck them on our list I don't think we'd ever get beaten

makemytime · Thu 24 Jul 2008 10:07pm

i'm glad kosi was suspended for this match and not another match but without him, our forward line doesn't have many targets left unless gards plays forward.

still got plenty of run in the tank with so many running players, we should win and i think milney or roo will kick a bag against the young eagles defence

WayneJudson42 · Thu 24 Jul 2008 10:34pm

I'm shocked!!!

Is this the shortest ever thread about team selection ever?

Only 1 change. No arguments, no abuse.

No one complaining that Geary wasn't selected... or the Fiora was.

Wow. I'm impressed

skeptic · Post: # 608982Post **skeptic** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 10:35pm

would feel a bit better with another recognised marking forward this week

remboy · Post: # 608987Post **remboy** » Thu 24 Jul 2008 10:49pm

skeptic wrote:would feel a bit better with another recognised marking forward this week

While I'm inclined to agree that another marking forward would be good the selection committee may be thinking it might be wet. Does anyone know what the forecast for PErth is on the weekend? If it's going to be wet I think they've got it right.