Changes if any next week
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
- Bernard Shakey
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 11242
- Joined: Sun 18 Mar 2007 11:22pm
- Location: Down By The River 1989, 2003, 2009 & 2013
- Has thanked: 126 times
- Been thanked: 137 times
From what I saw at training today I would think there will be 2 changes.
McEvoy and Geary in for Kosi obviously and one of Gilbert, Armitage and Fiora.
I lean towards Armitage being ommitted, only because he doesn't get much game time. Subiaco is a rather large ground and if Armo is not up to Docklands, he may enjoy a rest.
Having said that Allen and Michael Gardiner may be in the mix. Gardiner doesn't look ready to me and anyway I reckon Blake will tag Cox.
McEvoy and Geary in for Kosi obviously and one of Gilbert, Armitage and Fiora.
I lean towards Armitage being ommitted, only because he doesn't get much game time. Subiaco is a rather large ground and if Armo is not up to Docklands, he may enjoy a rest.
Having said that Allen and Michael Gardiner may be in the mix. Gardiner doesn't look ready to me and anyway I reckon Blake will tag Cox.
Old enough to repaint, but young enough to sell
out: kosi
in: m.gardiner
Gardiner can play at full-forward if needed and have either BJ, blake or S.Fisher playing their aswell
If we are to bring in a pure forward i would pick Ferguson
he has shown more than Allen and C.Gardiner
Played well against Melbourne and i reckon will be a good solid player
Geary is a possibility but i dont think Armo warrants a dropping or Eddy
Birss is pushing for selection aswell
I don't no if Bakes and X Clarke are fit but i would think bakes is a walk-up in our best 22 and X.Clarke is in best 26. X.Clarke and Fiora play same role so i would pick out of those 2.
I wouldn't change the team unless there is an obvious improvement in the replacement. e.g. geary for armo i dont think is needed because we have been winning lately.
Heard Banger walked off track early i wouldn't be to anxious he's done this many a time and still played.
No Casey match so i reckon most of the team will head down to Perth,
hope we have a good win
in: m.gardiner
Gardiner can play at full-forward if needed and have either BJ, blake or S.Fisher playing their aswell
If we are to bring in a pure forward i would pick Ferguson
he has shown more than Allen and C.Gardiner
Played well against Melbourne and i reckon will be a good solid player
Geary is a possibility but i dont think Armo warrants a dropping or Eddy
Birss is pushing for selection aswell
I don't no if Bakes and X Clarke are fit but i would think bakes is a walk-up in our best 22 and X.Clarke is in best 26. X.Clarke and Fiora play same role so i would pick out of those 2.
I wouldn't change the team unless there is an obvious improvement in the replacement. e.g. geary for armo i dont think is needed because we have been winning lately.
Heard Banger walked off track early i wouldn't be to anxious he's done this many a time and still played.
No Casey match so i reckon most of the team will head down to Perth,
hope we have a good win
Banger
If they make more than one change and feel the need to bring in another forward as well as a ruckmen Geary could be a player they could bring in as a half-forward/midfielder. Say Gardiner comes in, that means he can push forward as could BJ if needed which means it wouldn't necessarily have to be a taller forward. However, the player that wouldmost likely be dropped would be Armitage who plays that role anyway. Nevertheless, it's something interesting to consider as Geary has kicked 9 goals in his past 3 games for Casey.
Regardless, my changes would just be:
Out- Kosi
In- M Gardiner
However if Harvey doesn't come up or they decide to give Armo a rest then Geary should be the player to come in.
Regardless, my changes would just be:
Out- Kosi
In- M Gardiner
However if Harvey doesn't come up or they decide to give Armo a rest then Geary should be the player to come in.
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Sun 25 Sep 2005 1:40am
- Location: Hampton/Gold Coast
- Been thanked: 7 times
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Sun 25 Sep 2005 1:40am
- Location: Hampton/Gold Coast
- Been thanked: 7 times
HAVING WATCHED Michael RIX IN A NUMBER OF GAMES WITH THE CASEY SCORPIONS YOU WOULD NOT GET A PLAYER WITH A BIGGER HEART (MAYBE C. JONES) HE CAN TAKE MARKS AROUND THE GROUND AND CAN KICK A GOAL AS OPPOSED TO M> GARDINER AND S.KING . THERE IS MORE TO A RUCKMAN THAN JUST WINNING CENTRE BOUNCES. I THINK HE DESERVES ANOTHER GAME FOR ST. KILDAperfectionist wrote:In: M Gardiner, R Clarke and L Fisher
Out: S Gilbert, R Eddy and A Fiora
(Kosi - it's nothing)