Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Raven wrote:I think 'hate' is a very strong word and I rarely use it, but there are players who annoy me when I see them being thugs/idiots on or off the field:
Barry Hall
Adam Goodes
Warren Tredrea
Chad Cornes
Brendan Fevola (I used to work with his aunt, that's kind of part of it)
Jeff Farmer
Matthew Lloyd (not so much a thug, I just don't like seeing him in any shape or form, it feels like his eyes are about to burst from the sockets)
Good call Raven. I forgot Tredrea. Right up there with Lloyd at the top of my list. Brett Burton as well. Same as some others, no reason, I just don't like him.
I reckon it's harsh calling Ling soft. I reckon Ling is a bloody tough nut and would love to have him. Always in and under the pack.
Mr Magic wrote:
On the field you and I have differing views.
ok
Mr Magic wrote:
Doesn't make either of us right/wrong, just different opinion of him.
correct except to say that I would have thought to hate a player he would have had to have done something pretty ordinary , a lot more than what Brent has done to upset you.
Mr Magic wrote:
On the field you and I have differing views.
ok
Mr Magic wrote:
Doesn't make either of us right/wrong, just different opinion of him.
correct except to say that I would have thought to hate a player he would have had to have done something pretty ordinary , a lot more than what Brent has done to upset you.
Just my opinion The Fireman.
No big deal - I dislike the way he plays, you obviously don't.
IIRC he 'lost' me when he got a bloke reported by pretenfding he had been 'struck'. A really low act in my opinion.
He annoyed me on Saturday night when he kicked the ball into Mini in the last quarter and then started squealing to the umpires for a free kick for some 'imaginary offence'.
I only get to see him properly once or twice a season (when we play NM) and my opinion of him has been reinforced by the way he has played in those games.
Other than that I believe he has appeared quite regularly in video highlights trying to 'con' free kicks by 'acting'.
I despise 'cheats' on the sporting field and players acting for free kicks are 'cheats in my book.
Brent Harvey
Des Headland
Scott West
Jeff Farmer
Josh Carr
STRENGTH THROUGH LOYALTY.
''I still get really excited, and I've got the '66 thing up on the wall in a frame … You look at it and think: one day, we want to achieve that.''- Arryn Siposs
as i've posted many times... supremely talented player who was good enough to be 1 of the competition's elite... after his best season of footbal he pi$$ed of back to Freo to play cheap, pass me the ball off the HBF footy and stopped doing the hard things he did when he played for us.
The rest of Australia can wander mask-free, socialise, eat out, no curfews, no zoning, no police rings of steel, no illogical inconsistent rules.
They can even WATCH LIVE FOOTY!
Most of the players mentioned here are amongst the most talented in the comp.
The Fireman hates mercenaries who change club for the money. He must have hated Aaron Hamill and Fraser Gehrig.
Hamill left because his pres at the time humiliated him in front of the Carlton football club, he wanted more money and deserved it, his club refused.
Gherig wanted to come back to Melb.
The 2 players I mentioned were solely after the $$$$.
As a Saints fan maybe you should have known that.
Mr Magic wrote:Didak
Farmer
Brent Harvey
Dale Thomas
Chapman
Josh Carr
Chad Cornes
Lloyd
Hall
Peter Bell (only becasue of that idiot who rings the bell every time)
Interesting how some people hate players that I have no issue with at all and vice versa I'm sure.
Why do you hate Brent Harvey? I reckon he's gutsy.
i hate brent harvey too. not sure why. just really annoys me.
i actually love aker and fev. the game needs some showmen. and they are so darn good.
i hate lloyd. what a twerp. i hate jeff white. he just prances around like a big pony and never goes for the ball.
hunter - dishes it out but cant take it. thinks hes tough but cries like a baby when somone else is tough back.
brodie holland - same as hunter. gives it out to weaker younger opponents - thinks hes tough but cries like a baby and totally squibs against tougher opponents.
Con Gorozidis wrote:
i actually love aker and fev. the game needs some showmen. and they are so darn good.
i hate lloyd. what a twerp. i hate jeff white. he just prances around like a big pony and never goes for the ball.
hunter - dishes it out but cant take it. thinks hes tough but cries like a baby when somone else is tough back.
brodie holland - same as hunter. gives it out to weaker younger opponents - thinks hes tough but cries like a baby and totally squibs against tougher opponents.
