if the Best and Fairest were held today ......

st_Trav_ofWA · Sun 22 Jun 2008 1:55pm

who would win the awards ?

Trevor Barker Medal ?

Most Promising New Player Award ?

Most goals for the year ?

Best Clubman ?
.
.
.

SaintBot · Post: # 592392Post **SaintBot** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 2:42pm

Best & Fairest Top 10
1. Lenny Hayes
2. Sam Fisher
3. Luke Ball
4. Nick Riewoldt
5. Robert Harvey
6. Jason Gram
7. Max Hudghton
8. Brendon Goddard
9. Leigh Montagna
10. Nick Dal Santo

123 · Post: # 592403Post **123** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 3:06pm

max is higher than that in my book. never seen a guy bleed so badly for his team

matrix · Post: # 592406Post **matrix** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 3:12pm

123 wrote:max is higher than that in my book. never seen a guy bleed so badly for his team

luke ball would bleed quite i bit....and has.

lenny would be leading
bally second
anyone could be third, fourth etc

most promising new player?...dunno seen three this round, cant comment till had more than one chance.

most goals?...is milney still in front?

best club man?.....
harvey or max.....flip a coin

plugger66 · Post: # 592434Post **plugger66** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 4:12pm

123 wrote:max is higher than that in my book. never seen a guy bleed so badly for his team

Does that mean if I cut myself before each game I could win it. Max has had a couple of good guys this year a few average games and has been beaten a couple of times which is strange for him.

saints11 · Post: # 592456Post **saints11** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 4:38pm

b&f Lenny hayes
most promising: jarryn geary
most goals: milne
best clubman lenny hayes

Post: # 592457Post **n1ck** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 4:39pm

Lenny Hayes would have a mortgage on the medal.

Harvey, Ball, Roo, Goddard, Fisher would round out the top 6... not in any particular order.

Otiman · Post: # 592632Post **Otiman** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 7:50pm

Hayes, Ball, Sam Fisher.

Either of those 3 would be leading at present.

esaint66 · Post: # 592638Post **esaint66** » Sun 22 Jun 2008 7:55pm

n1ck wrote:Lenny Hayes would have a mortgage on the medal.

Harvey, Ball, Roo, Goddard, Fisher would round out the top 6... not in any particular order.

Yeah couldnt have put it better myself.

Winmarvellous · Sun 22 Jun 2008 9:04pm

Agreed.

saintbrat · Post: # 598002Post **saintbrat** » Thu 03 Jul 2008 9:28am

On Numbers alone - Sam Fisher would sneak in ahead of Lenny and Luke

Sam is in the top 3 of - Kicks, H'balls and total disposals- with Lenny and Luke
and 2 nd to Nick R in Marks .

New player;- will be a toss up given how many they play Eddy or Geary ( do they count with casey)
Goals- Milney
Clubman- Jason Blake

Halo Halo · Post: # 598006Post **Halo Halo** » Thu 03 Jul 2008 9:46am

Best & Fairest: Lenny
Most Promising: Jarryn Geary
Most Goals: Riewoldt
Best Clubman: Luke Ball

saint66au · Post: # 598007Post **saint66au** » Thu 03 Jul 2008 9:48am

Would love the Blake to get the Clubman award..

Is best new player have to be first year? Clint Jones has it done and dusted if 2nd years count. If not..hmm..do we have to give it? No 1st year player has really done enough to warrant it yet IMHO..but 8 rounds still to go

Red · Post: # 598027Post **Red** » Thu 03 Jul 2008 11:10am

How do they determine votes?

saintbrat · Post: # 598032Post **saintbrat** » Thu 03 Jul 2008 11:29am

varies and is generally determined by football department and coaches
pretty sure last years was 10-1 votes per game as determined by coaches

some teams use player input some only coaches,
some do votes per game on every player

robbo_25 · Post: # 598075Post **robbo_25** » Thu 03 Jul 2008 1:21pm

Best & Fairest: Lenny Hayes
Most Promising: David Armitage
Most Goals: Stephen Milne
Best Clubman: Luke Ball